Seasonal Variation in Population Abundance and Chytrid Infection in Stream-Dwelling Frogs of the Brazilian Atlantic Forest.

Enigmatic amphibian declines were first reported in southern and southeastern Brazil in the late 1980s and included several species of stream-dwelling anurans (families Hylodidae and Cycloramphidae). At that time, we were unaware of the amphibian-killing fungus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis (Bd); therefore, pollution, habitat loss, fragmentation and unusual climatic events were hypothesized as primary causes of these declines. We now know that multiple lineages of Bd have infected amphibians of the Brazilian Atlantic forest for over a century, yet declines have not been associated specifically with Bd outbreaks. Because stream-dwelling anurans occupy an environmental hotspot ideal for disease transmission, we investigated temporal variation in population and infection dynamics of three stream-adapted species (Hylodes asper, H. phyllodes, and Cycloramphus boraceiensis) on the northern coast of São Paulo state, Brazil. We surveyed standardized transects along streams for four years, and show that fluctuations in the number of frogs correlate with specific climatic variables that also increase the likelihood of Bd infections. In addition, we found that Bd infection probability in C. boraceiensis, a nocturnal species, was significantly higher than in Hylodes spp., which are diurnal, suggesting that the nocturnal activity may either facilitate Bd zoospore transmission or increase susceptibility of hosts. Our findings indicate that, despite long-term persistence of Bd in Brazil, some hosts persist with seasonally variable infections, and thus future persistence in the face of climate change will depend on the relative effect of those changes on frog recruitment and pathogen proliferation.

Introduction

Enigmatic amphibian declines were first reported in Brazil in the late 1980s and were attributed to unusual climatic events, pollution, habitat loss, and fragmentation [1,2,3,4]. Reported declines included populations of obligate stream-dwelling frogs in the genera Hylodes, Crossodactylus (Hylodidae), and Cycloramphus (Cycloramphidae) throughout the mountainous regions of the Atlantic coastal forest of southern and southeastern Brazil [1,2,3]. At that time, the exact drivers of decline were unknown, and the changes in species abundances were considered enigmatic, yet infectious diseases were proposed as a possible cause because amphibian populations disappeared from relatively undisturbed habitats [2,4].

The pathogenic chytrid fungus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis (hereafter Bd) has been implicated in declines of wild amphibian populations worldwide [5,6,7,8], including in pristine areas with high natural vegetation cover [9]. In cases where the pathogen has invaded new areas, susceptible species are extirpated or decline just a few months after Bd invasion [10,11,12,13], with highly deleterious effects on naïve host communities [14]. In contrast, retrospective studies have identified localities with long-term Bd endemism [15,16]. One of these, the Brazilian Atlantic forest, has the oldest Bd infection records (late 1800s) [16] and a high diversity of genetically distinct Bd lineages [17,18]. Therefore, Atlantic forest anurans have experienced long-term co-existence with this pathogen, which might explain high infection tolerance in many current anuran populations [19,20].

More than 40% of Bd-infected species from southern and southeastern Brazil belong to the families Cycloramphidae and Hylodidae [16]. The genera Cycloramphus and Hylodes are obligate stream-dwelling frogs, often highly philopatric [21], and typically rely on undisturbed forested habitat [22,23]. Undisturbed forests provide optimal microclimatic conditions for Bd proliferation and harbor a greater diversity of host species, enhancing the potential for pathogen transmission [9,24,25,26]. After Bd emergence, stream-associated riparian amphibians in naïve communities were the first to show rapid declines [11,27]; thus, their preferred microhabitat has an impact on the probability of Bd infection because specific environmental factors in those habitats are more conducive to transmission and pathogen proliferation [9,20,24]. Interestingly, among the Brazilian stream dwelling species in which Bd was detected in recent years [19,20], apparently none have shown dramatic population declines, despite relatively high infection prevalence and intensity. Given that the extinction threat for stream-dwellers may be highly underestimated [24], studies evaluating amphibian population dynamics and the impact of Bd are a priority for the conservation of these Atlantic forest taxa.

In this study we investigated population dynamics and seasonal changes in Bd prevalence in three species of stream-dwelling frogs in the Cycloramphidae and Hylodidae families (Hylodes asper, H. phyllodes, and Cycloramphus boraceiensis) on the northern coast of São Paulo state, southeastern Brazil. We surveyed standardized transects along Atlantic forest streams during four years and tested for a correlation between fluctuations in the number of frogs with specific climatic variables that may increase the likelihood of infections by Bd. We also quantified Bd prevalence and infection intensity in host species during a cool period of low precipitation (winter 2007) and a warmer period of high precipitation (summer 2008). We hypothesized that environmental variables influence both pathogen and host dynamics over seasons in the Atlantic forest, enabling host-pathogen coexistence over the years [16].

Methods

Field Sampling

To quantify amphibian population trends over time, we conducted standardized transect surveys in streams in Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar (PESM), which runs along 270 km (from 24°13'12.49" S, 47°22'4.71" W to 23°22'36.90" S, 44°44'19.07" W) of the coast of São Paulo state, southeastern Brazil. Our study area is located in PESM Núcleo Picinguaba, in the municipality of Ubatuba. Fieldwork was approved by Permit #16593–1 issued by MMA, IBAMA, and ICMBio. These Agencies also approved all methods used for collecting and manipulating biological samples. Approval by an Animal Ethics Committee was not required for this study. Approximately 40 species of anurans occur in Núcleo Picinguaba [27,28]. The climate in this region is seasonally wet with mean annual rainfall of 2519 mm, a warmer season from October to April (monthly rainfall 215–376 mm, with peak in December and January; mean temperatures from 21.1–25.5), and a drier, colder season from May to September (monthly rainfall 11–166 mm, with July the driest month; mean temperatures from 18.4–20.5) [29].

We surveyed four low elevation streams (150–330 m asl) on the escarpments of the Serra do Mar located along 4 km of the Rio-Santos highway (S1 Table). These four streams were chosen to represent the variation in width, slope, and water flow typical of small streams in the study area. Monthly surveys were conducted from February 2007 to January 2011. In each stream we sampled a 100–120 m long transect. We searched for adults of the three focal species of stream-dwelling frogs (H. asper, H. phyllodes, and C. boraceiensis) by slowly walking upstream once during daytime and once at night for 30–90 minutes.

Environmental data

Maximum and minimum temperature and total precipitation were obtained from the Ubatuba weather station (INMET) [30]. This station is located 28 km from the study site; based on the relative homogeneity of the climate in the region, we assume that the climate at the study site is similar to that in Ubatuba.

Bd sampling and quantification

To quantify seasonal patterns in Bd infection prevalence and intensity, we swabbed 20 frogs of each species once during winter (August 2007) and once during summer (February 2008). We captured frogs using non-powdered latex gloves to avoid transmission between animals and sample contamination, and followed standard field sampling protocols [31,32]. Each swab was stored in sterile plastic tubes, at -20°C, and frogs were immediately released at the site of capture. To quantify the presence and infection intensity of Bd in each sample, we first extracted DNA from swabs using PrepMan ULTRA (Life Technologies), and then quantified infection intensities using a Taqman qPCR Assay (Life Technologies) with standards of 0.1, 1, 10, 100, and 1000 zoospore genomic equivalents (g.e.) [31,33] using Bd strain CLFT023. We considered a sample as “Bd-positive” when the infection load was greater than or equal to one g.e. [31]. DNA samples are deposited in the SLFT Collection, at the Universidade Estadual de Campinas (S2 Table).

To evaluate the prevalence of Bd in each population, we followed the protocol where the number of sampled frogs is equal to 3/p (prevalence expressed in proportion) [34], except for the population of H. asper in summer 2008.

Statistical analyses

We performed seasonal-trend decomposition analyses to the monthly estimates of number of individuals found per 100 m and the monthly climatic data (min. temperature and precipitation). We pooled the data collected on the four stream transects and used the mean number of individuals per species to create time series objects in R [35]. Each time series was decomposed into its seasonal components using a periodic loess window [36], in which seasonal values are removed and remaining values are smoothed to detect the underlying trend [36]. In addition, we tested the temporal stability of populations by fitting separate general linear models (GLM) for each species. In these models, our independent variable was the average number of individuals. Calendar year, minimum and maximum temperature, and precipitation were fixed factors, while month and calendar year were nested and set as random factors to control for natural monthly fluctuations within each year.

We tested for seasonality in Bd prevalence and infection intensity with generalized linear models (GLMs) using logistic and quasipoisson regressions. Our logistic model for Bd presence/absence included season, species, and their interaction as predictors. Our quasipoisson model for Bd infection intensity included the same predictor variables. All statistical models were implemented in R [35].

Results

During the four-year monitoring period the climate in the study area became warmer and drier, with mean temperatures varying from 23–25°C in the first years to 27°C in 2010, and precipitation decreasing from 52 mm in 2007 to 29 mm in the last year of the study.

Population dynamics

Our surveys showed high variability in the average number of individuals for each of our three focal species, but also common peaks in frog abundance during January-March (warm season) and declines during the months of June-July (cold season) (Fig 1). Hylodes asper was the most common species at our sites with an average abundance (± standard deviation) of 14.0 ± 6.3 individuals per survey, followed by C. boraceiensis with 12.8 ± 3.7 individuals, and H. phyllodes with 1.5 ± 1.2 individuals (Fig 1). Fluctuations in the number of individuals corresponded to seasonal patterns in temperature and precipitation (Fig 1B). Time series decomposition of frog abundances and climatic variables helped us distinguish seasonal components and the separate cycles of high temperature and precipitation from cycles of cooler temperatures and drier conditions (Fig 2) that likely cause changes in amphibian density. Despite these cycles, minimum temperature only predicted abundance changes in H. asper (GLM, t 1, 28 = 5.01, P < 0.001).

Fig 1

Mean number of individuals, temperature and precipitation.

Four-year time series data of: (A) the mean number of individuals found in four stream transects, and (B) monthly minimum temperature (°C) and precipitation (mm) at Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar, Brazil. Shaded bars highlight Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis swab sampling. The first asterisk (dead or dying frog) for C. boraceiensis represents two individuals found within 3 days. Sampling began February 2007 and continued monthly through January 2011.

Fig 2

Seasonal decomposition of frog abundance, temperature and precipitation.

Seasonal decomposition of the time series data of: (A) the mean number of individuals found in four stream transects, and (B) monthly minimum temperature (°C) and precipitation (mm) at Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar, Brazil.

Our seasonal-trend decomposition analyses revealed apparent slight population declines of H. asper and C. boraceiensis in mid-2008 that extended through 2009 (Fig 3A). In contrast, H. phyllodes populations exhibited a slight increase in the first months of 2009 (Fig 3A). These changes were concordant with an increase in minimum temperature and decrease in precipitation at the end of 2008 (Fig 3B). Our linear mixed-effects models confirmed declines in abundance of H. asper during 2009 (GLM, t 1, 28 = −2.89, P < 0.01) and 2010 (GLM, t 1, 28 = −4.11, P < 0.001), as well as the increase in abundance for H. phyllodes in 2010 (GLM, t 1, 28 = 2.33, P = 0.027).

Fig 3

Frog abundance, temperature and precipitation.

Trends of the time series data of: (A) the mean number of individuals found in four stream transects, and (B) monthly minimum temperature (°C) and precipitation (mm) at Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar, Brazil.

Bd infection dynamics

Our logistic model of Bd infection revealed significant effects of season (β = 3.11 ± 0.89, DF = 102, Z = 3.51, P < 0.001) and species (β = 2.20 ± 0.90, DF = 102, Z = 2.45, P = 0.014). The prevalence of Bd in individuals sampled during winter was significantly higher than those sampled during summer (Fig 4) (P < 0.001), and C. boraceiensis showed higher infection load than the other two species. In addition, we found a marginal effect of the interaction between season and species for C. boraceiensis (β = -2.20 ± 1.13, DF = 102, Z = -1.95, P = 0.051). We did not detect any effects of these variables on Bd infection intensity, even after excluding uninfected frogs (Quasipoisson GLM: all P > 0.05).

Fig 4

Intensity of Bd infection.

Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis infection intensity of Cycloramphus boraceiensis (Cb), Hylodes asper (Ha) and Hylodes phyllodes (Hp) during winter and summer stream surveys at Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar, Brazil. The total number of individuals swabbed is shown in the bottom of each bar. We measured genomic equivalents (GEs) using qPCR, and report the proportion of individuals infected by each zoospore category: 0, 1–10, 11–100, 101–1000, and >1001 GEs.

We observed six cases of dead or dying frogs in the field during the course of the demographic study (three H. asper, two C. boraceiensis, and one H. phyllodes; Fig 1A, represented by asterisks). Frog mortality occurred mostly during the cool-dry periods of the year (Fig 2B).

The relationship between seasonal variation in Bd prevalence and host abundance was different across the three species. Cycloramphus boraceiensis showed no seasonal pattern of infection and population abundance. The prevalence of Bd in the population of Hyllodes phyllodes was higher during winter (P = 0.05) despite its lower population abundance (Fig 1A). In contrast, Hylodes asper showed different Bd prevalence between seasons (P < 0.001), being more infected during the winter than summer, when the number of individuals was also greater (Fig 1A). Although infection in the population of H. asper may have been underestimated during summer 2008 due to smaller sample size, these results indicate that seasonality may have different effects on disease dynamics across syntopic species. Re-analyses with larger sample sizes of population disease data would be interesting to confirm these possible differences.

Discussion

Understanding the effects of pathogens on wildlife requires long-term datasets to identify potential changes in natural population dynamics [37,38]. Our demographic surveys indicate that the three focal species of stream-dwelling frogs in Brazil have experienced periods of slight population growth, declines, and recovery over the four-year study. At the same time, climate in this area has become warmer and drier. Although we did not include a continuous survey of Bd infection through time for these three species, we found a higher probability of infection during winter months, and we report Bd-associated mortalities during cool-dry periods, which have also been observed in other studies of Bd enzootics in the tropics [39-41].

Our three focal species live in the same microhabitat, thus the risk of exposure and infection is likely constant across species, yet our Bd survey data indicate that the three species rely on different strategies to persist under climate variation and disease. Hylodes species are diurnal; in contrast, Cycloramphus species are crepuscular and nocturnal [23]. Temperatures differ between diurnal and nocturnal activity periods, and this in turn potentially modulates immune responses to infection [42] or the ability of hosts to reduce infection loads through behavioral fever [43,44]. Therefore, diurnal behavior may benefit Hylodes spp. by providing opportunities to increase their body temperature above 30°C, a temperature that kills infective zoospores [44,45]. Indeed, we observed individuals of both species of Hylodes under direct sunlight in many instances. In contrast, C. boraceiensis retreat in rock crevices during the day and do not experience the same breadth in temperatures, and we never found C. boraceiensis under direct sunlight [46]. Additionally, susceptibility to Bd infection may differ between the frog lineages studied (Hylodidae and Cycloramphidae) due to variation in immune function [47,48]. Future studies should investigate the immune limitations imposed by strictly nocturnal behavior as well as a possible phylogenetic signal in the vulnerability to Bd infection.

Long-term monitoring is especially important in cases of hosts surviving with enzootic pathogens, because only temporal demographic patterns can reveal if the observed changes in population size are of a scale that negatively impacts the probability of long-term population persistence. Fluctuations in environmental variables can affect the stability of amphibian population dynamics by influencing species’ survival, fecundity, breeding, or recruitment [49]. Only one previous study has estimated population parameters for our focal species. In H. asper, recruitment of juveniles is high and populations have almost complete annual turnover, raising concerns that even minor environmental changes could affect populations [50], and perhaps explain local extinctions of Hylodes observed in the late 1970s [1]. Indeed, our monitoring studies provide additional support for these findings by showing a decline in mid-2008 that corresponded with an increase in temperature and drier conditions (Fig 3). At the population level, our findings indicate that both H. phyllodes and C. boraceiensis showed a decrease in Bd prevalence over a period of six months (20–30% reduction in prevalence, Fig 4). Combined, our results show how two different stressors (infection and climate variation) can interact to affect population dynamics. Fortunately, the three species studied here show apparent resilience to these changes in temperature, precipitation, and infection. However, whether or not this advantage carried sub-lethal fitness costs is unknown.

In addition to revealing interspecific differences in the probability of infection among stream-dwelling frogs, our results corroborate seasonal variation in the prevalence of Bd, a pattern that has been documented in other tropical and temperate taxa [40,51,52]. In general, we found more infected frogs in the month with the coolest air temperature (Fig 4), indicating that environmental variables potentially increase host vulnerability to Bd in cold temperatures by one of two mechanisms: (1) immunosuppression or (2) stimulating pathogen replication in the environment. In fact, although cooler temperatures decrease Bd growth rate, they also stimulate zoosporangia to produce greater number of zoospores, which remain infectious for longer periods, a life history trade-off that could favor Bd transmission at lower temperatures [53].

According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [54], many areas in the Americas will experience a 4–4.5°C increase in surface temperatures and severe droughts as the result of anthropogenic climate change [54]. These projections also forecast an increase of 10–15% in autumn rainfall and increased droughts during the austral summer [54]. These changes impact frog phenology in different ways. First, more rainfall during autumn will increase reproduction in active frogs, but could limit juvenile survival if earlier life stages are more vulnerable to winter infection [55,56]. Second, droughts increase stress in amphibians and may also limit juvenile recruitment if species are not able to adapt rapidly to these novel conditions [57,58]. Alternatively, given the resilience observed in these three species, we can also predict a scenario more favorable for amphibians, in which increased temperatures could benefit temperature-dependent immune responses and the capacity to express behavioral fever. This would require very specific physiological adaptations to temperature as well as the availability of different microhabitats for thermoregulation. However, due to the tight interplay between hosts and pathogen, these scenarios will likely depend on the responses of the pathogen, which could be highly plastic [59]. Future studies in seasonally variable regions where Bd is endemic should focus on understanding the evolutionary potential of thermal tolerance across Bd lineages, as well as quantifying juvenile survival and recruitment under different temperatures and infection scenarios.

Geographic positions and brief description of each stream transect.

(PDF)

Click here for additional data file.

Data from amphibian samples collected at Parque Estadual da Serra do Mar, Picinguaba.

(PDF)

Click here for additional data file.