Rupsa Datta1, Alba Alfonso-García2, Rachel Cinco3, Enrico Gratton1. 1. Laboratory of Fluorescence Dynamics, Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of California, Irvine. 2. Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of California, Irvine. 3. Department of Developmental &Cell Biology, University of California, Irvine.
Abstract
Presence of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in excess of normal physiological level results in oxidative stress. This can lead to a range of pathological conditions including inflammation, diabetes mellitus, cancer, cardiovascular and neurodegenerative disease. Biomarkers of oxidative stress play an important role in understanding the pathogenesis and treatment of these diseases. A number of fluorescent biomarkers exist. However, a non-invasive and label-free identification technique would be advantageous for in vivo measurements. In this work we establish a spectroscopic method to identify oxidative stress in cells and tissues by fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM). We identified an autofluorescent, endogenous species with a characteristic fluorescent lifetime distribution as a probe for oxidative stress. To corroborate our hypothesis that these species are products of lipid oxidation by ROS, we correlate the spectroscopic signals arising from lipid droplets by combining FLIM with THG and CARS microscopy which are established techniques for selective lipid body imaging. Further, we performed spontaneous Raman spectral analysis at single points of the sample which provided molecular vibration information characteristics of lipid droplets.
Presence of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in excess of normal physiological level results in oxidative stress. This can lead to a range of pathological conditions including inflammation, diabetes mellitus, cancer, cardiovascular and neurodegenerative disease. Biomarkers of oxidative stress play an important role in understanding the pathogenesis and treatment of these diseases. A number of fluorescent biomarkers exist. However, a non-invasive and label-free identification technique would be advantageous for in vivo measurements. In this work we establish a spectroscopic method to identify oxidative stress in cells and tissues by fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM). We identified an autofluorescent, endogenous species with a characteristic fluorescent lifetime distribution as a probe for oxidative stress. To corroborate our hypothesis that these species are products of lipid oxidation by ROS, we correlate the spectroscopic signals arising from lipid droplets by combining FLIM with THG and CARS microscopy which are established techniques for selective lipid body imaging. Further, we performed spontaneous Raman spectral analysis at single points of the sample which provided molecular vibration information characteristics of lipid droplets.
Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are intrinsic free radicals produced as a result of normal
cellular metabolism. ROS concentration at moderate level plays a role in signaling
pathways of physiological processes and in maintaining redox homeostasis123. However, increased concentration of ROS causes oxidative stress.
This is detrimental to the cellular components because of several biochemical processes
including lipid peroxidation and proteins and DNA damage3. Modifications
of these biomolecules could ultimately lead to a number of human diseases such as
inflammation, diabetes mellitus, atherosclerosis, cancer, and neurodegenerative
disease45678910. Therefore, biomarkers of oxidative
stress play an important role in understanding the pathogenesis and treatment of these
diseases.Detecting ROS itself is a direct measure for identifying the presence of oxidative
stress. ROS-specific fluorescent indicators are available commercially. However, the use
of these indicators requires administration of a foreign material to the physiological
environment. Instability of ROS molecules and further perturbation of biological systems
by the current invasive ROS detection techniques make this a difficult task. Indirect
techniques for detecting ROS utilize the more stable ROS oxidation products. These
identify damage to biomolecules by ROS or quantify levels of antioxidants or redox
molecules. In this work, we show label-free detection of oxidative stress by
fluorescence lifetime measurement of intrinsic fluorescent species using multiphoton
fluorescence microscopy. These species with granular appearance co-localize with lipid
droplets. We hypothesize that the identified species are products of lipid oxidation by
ROS. A similar preliminary observation was reported previously in human embryonic stem
cells11. The identified endogenous biomarker unfolds opportunities of
performing non-invasive measurements of oxidative stress in vivo.Multiphoton fluorescence microscopy (MPM) has been employed previously to perform label
free fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) of intrinsic fluorophores like reduced
nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH), collagen, retinol, and retinoic acid1112. The main advantages of MPM are reduced phototoxicity and higher
penetration depth, needed for in vivo measurements especially in tissue samples.
Endogenous fluorophores enable non-invasive imaging of biological samples, minimizing
the perturbation of normal physiological conditions. For example, autofluorescent
metabolic coenzymes flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) and NADH are frequently employed
as probes of metabolism for label-free imaging1314. For analyzing the
fluorescent decay in FLIM images, we employed the phasor approach. This method
simplifies and speeds up the analysis because it works on the raw data without the need
to perform a fit of the fluorescence decay at each point of an image15.
The method does not require a priori knowledge of the fluorescence lifetime components
in the imaged sample and gives instantaneous results. Briefly, the data from each pixel
of the image are subjected to a Fourier transformation to obtain the corresponding
phasor as previously described1115. In the phasor approach we can
identify separate clusters of species with different lifetimes. The lifetime information
shown in the phasor plot can be mapped back to the image to resolve the spatial location
of these species.To validate the concurrence of lipid droplets with the identified oxidative stress
biomarkers, we combined the FLIM approach with two coherent nonlinear microscopy
techniques: third harmonic generation (THG) imaging microscopy and coherent anti-Stokes
Raman scattering (CARS) microscopy. It is known that a strong THG signal is generated at
the interface between media with difference in third order nonlinear susceptibility,
refractive index and dispersion. In particular it has been shown that the interface
between a lipid droplet and its surrounding produces a strong THG contrast16. Hence, the technique can be employed to selectively identify lipid
bodies in biological samples. CARS is also a label-free technique used for imaging
neutral lipid droplets. The contrast of the CARS signal in the lipid droplets arises
from the Raman response of the abundant C-H bonds in the lipid molecules17. Thus, laser scanning CARS microscopy is applied to visualize lipid droplets in cells
and tissues. Both of these techniques have the advantage of being label-free and
non-invasive while they can still be correlated to the results of FLIM imaging.To further investigate the chemical nature of the observed species, we performed
classical Raman spectral analysis. Raman spectroscopy has the advantages of providing
high molecular selectivity18, and non-invasiveness, especially compared
to techniques like mass spectroscopy. We employed a confocal Raman microscope where we
could select specific locations on the biological sample, and acquire Raman spectra from
these areas. For identifying lipids on our samples, we looked at the fingerprint region
and the C-H stretching vibration region. Characteristic spectra of lipid droplets have
previously been identified in these Raman bands1920.In this work, we establish a non-invasive, label-free MPM method to identify a biomarker
of oxidative stress. We found the identified endogenous fluorescent species to have a
characteristic fluorescence lifetime distribution on the phasor plot. MPM imaging
provided high resolution imaging and by phasor analysis of FLIM, this biomarker could be
easily identified in live cells and ex-vivo tissues and correlated to lipid droplet
locations. We hypothesize that the fluorescent species is a product of lipid oxidation
by ROS. We show co-localization of the spectroscopic signals to lipid droplets by
combining FLIM with THG and CARS microscopy which are techniques employed for selective
lipid body imaging. Raman spectral analysis on the regions with this characteristic
lifetime provided additional evidence of molecular vibrations arising from oxidized
lipids.
Results
Identification of a unique long lifetime species in white adipose tissue
by FLIM
We performed fluorescence lifetime imaging measurements on freshly excised
perigonadal white adipose tissue (WAT) using endogenous autofluorescence.
Performing the phasor analysis of the acquired FLIM data, we identified a long
lifetime distribution cluster in the phasor plot (Fig. 1A,
encircled in red cursor) of 7.8 ns. This distribution of the long lifetime
species (LLS) has a distinct position on the phasor plot separate from the
NADH-FLIM signature (Fig. 1A, encircled in blue cursor).
The LLS and NADH-FLIM phasor clusters are mapped back onto the intensity image
(Fig. 1A, right panel inset image). The tissue regions
exhibiting the long lifetime component are colored red. These pixels correspond
to the areas within the large lipid droplets present in the adipocytes. The
NADH-FLIM cluster is chosen by the blue cursor on the phasor plot, and this
selection corresponds to regions surrounding the lipid droplet: adipocyte
cytoplasm, nuclei, and the extracellular regions. To further ascertain that the
pixels selected by the red cursor are associated to lipids, we performed THG
imaging on the same region. We found a strong THG signal arising from the
periphery of lipid droplets (Fig. 1B left top panel). The
LLS FLIM map overlaid on the THG image shows that the periphery of regions with
long fluorescence lifetime have strong THG signal (Fig. 1B
right panel, regions of overlap in pink). This is consistent with our hypothesis
that we are observing lipid droplet associated autofluorescence. Based on FLIM
and THG results, we manually drew, on the fluorescence intensity image, a region
of interest (ROI) in two different lipid droplets (Supplementary
Fig. S1). The phasor distribution associated to these ROIs shows a
unique component on the universal circle which corresponds to a single
exponential lifetime at 7.8 ns.
Figure 1
Unique fluorescence long lifetime signature (LLS) in white adipose tissue and
correlation with THG image.
(A). Left panel is average fluorescence intensity image of white adipose
tissue excited at 740 nm. Right panel is the corresponding phasor
distribution. The red circular cursor chooses the long lifetime distribution
cluster while blue cursor chooses the NADH phasor distribution. The inset
image is the FLIM pseudo-color map with red and blue regions corresponding
to the two identified phasor clusters selected with red and blue cursors
respectively. Scale bar is 20 µm. (B). Top left panel is the THG
intensity image with the sample excited at 1038 nm. Bottom left panel is the
FLIM map of long lifetime species (LLS). Right panel is the composite image
of LLS FLIM map and THG image.
We acquired FLIM and THG of 25 z-slices at every 3 µm of the visceral
white adipose tissue from surface to a depth of 72 µm. Figure 2A is the 3-D reconstruction of THG (cyan) and LLS
FLIM map (in red), and Fig. 2B shows the 3-D
reconstruction beneath the surface of the tissue with both signals merged. Figure 2C and 2D are the THG and LLS
FLIM signals respectively.
Figure 2
Simultaneous THG and FLIM in WAT reconstructed from 25 z – slices
at every 3 µM of the tissue.
(A). 3D reconstructed THG signal from white adipose tissue in cyan overlapped
with long lifetime FLIM map in red (B). THG and FLIM from the same tissue
sample reconstructed from below the top surface (C). 3D reconstructed only
THG signal from below the top surface (D). Corresponding 3D FLIM map of long
lifetime species in the tissue.
To investigate the differences of the long lifetime species in visceral versus
subcutaneous WAT, we performed FLIM on visceral fat depot (perigonadal WAT) and
subcutaneous fat depot (flank area) of the same animal. We also collected
spectral emission data from the same tissue area and analyzed the emission
characteristics using the spectral phasor approach method described
previously21. Fig. 3A shows the FLIM
phasor and spectral phasor analysis in the field of view for the two kinds of
WATs. Separate masks were applied manually to select the whole cell (Mask 1) and
the region with NADH FLIM signature (Mask 2) within the selected cell. For
generating Mask 2 we were guided by the FLIM phasor distribution where the decay
of NADH can be distinguished. The Boolean XOR operation was performed between
Mask 1 and Mask 2 to obtain the resulting Whole cell–NADH
mask. The FLIM phasor distribution (Fig. 3A, iii, Visceral
WAT and Fig. 3B, iii, Subcutaneous WAT) and the spectral
distribution (Fig. 3A, v, Visceral WAT and Fig. 3B, v, Subcutaneous WAT) were mapped back onto the phasor plot
after application of Whole cell–NADH mask on the imaged area.
The FLIM phasor distribution (Fig. 3A iv, Visceral WAT and
Fig. 3B iv, Subcutaneous WAT) and the spectral phasor
distribution (Fig. 3A vi, Visceral WAT and Fig. 3B vi, Subcutaneous WAT) were mapped back onto the phasor plot,
after application of the NADH mask. The spectral phasor method was
employed together with lifetime measurements to determine the characteristic
emission average spectrum of the areas that correspond to long lifetime species
(LLS) and those with NADH FLIM signature. The spectral phasor distribution of
the LLS was centered on 497.4 nm for visceral WAT and 496.2 nm for subcutaneous
WAT. NADH spectral phasor distribution was centered at 487 nm for both the WATs.
Supplementary Fig. S2 shows the FLIM and spectral phasor
distribution of the complete imaged areas of visceral and subcutaneous WAT.
Figure 3
FLIM and spectral phasor distribution of visceral and subcutaneous white
adipose tissue.
(A). Top panel are fluorescence intensity images of visceral white adipose
tissue with the ROI masks [Whole cell – NADH
] (A i) and [NADH] (A ii). Middle panel
are FLIM phasor distribution from the masks. Aiii shows FLIM phasor
distribution from mask in (Ai) while (A iv) shows FLIM phasor distribution
from mask in (Aii). Bottom panels are spectral phasor distribution from the
masks. (Av) shows FLIM phasor distribution from mask in (Ai) and (A vi)
shows FLIM phasor distribution from mask in (Aii). (B). Top panel are
fluorescence intensity images of visceral white adipose tissue with the ROI
masks [Whole cell – NADH] (B i) and
[NADH] (B ii). Middle panel are FLIM phasor
distribution from the masks. (B iii) shows FLIM phasor distribution from
mask in (Bi) while (B iv) shows FLIM phasor distribution from mask in (Bii).
Bottom panels are spectral phasor distribution from the masks. (Bv) shows
FLIM phasor distribution from mask in (Bi) and (Bvi) shows FLIM phasor
distribution from mask in (Bii).
FLIM phasor signature of long lifetime species
In the phasor approach to FLIM, according to the vector law of phasor addition,
if a pixel contains a mixture of two molecular species, the corresponding phasor
will be distributed along a line joining phasors of the two pure species15. Here we have a system of three molecular species, namely free
NADH, protein bound NADH, and oxidized lipid associated fluorescent species
(LLS). The line joining the free and protein bound NADH, which is from 0.4 ns to
3.4 ns in the phasor plot, has been previously named the “metabolic
trajectory”1112 in the phasor plot. From Fig. 1 and Fig. 2, the FLIM signature
of pure LLS can be established to be 7.8 ns. The phasor of a pixel in the image
containing a mixture of the three species will lie inside the triangle whose
vertices are formed by the phasors of the three pure species on the phasor plot
(Fig. 4A). For the NADH lifetime signature, FLIM of
pure free NADH and NADH bound to lactate dehydrogenase was used to locate the
extremes of the bound and free NADH trajectory. The distribution of LLS was
obtained from the WAT in Fig. 1.
Figure 4
Unique LLS FLIM signature and a new oxidative stress axis on phasor
plot.
(A). Phasor plot showing triangle formed by FLIM fingerprints of free 2.5
µM NADH in solution, NADH bound to 0.75 U/ml Lactate
dehydrogenase (LDH) enzyme and unique LLS from lipid droplets in perigonadal
WAT of female mouse. From the law of phasor addition, a system containing
mixtures of these three species will fall within the triangle joining the
three phasors. (B). FLIM of oleic acid fed HeLa cell. Bi is the transmission
image and Bii is the corresponding fluorescence intensity image with the
sample excited with 740 nm and emission collected using bandpass filter
480/80 nm. Biii is the resulting phasor distribution from the sample with
blue cursor selecting the NADH phasor distribution and red cursor choosing
the LLS cluster. Blue dotted line is the metabolic trajectory while red
dotted line is the oxidative stress axis. Biv is the NADH map where pixels
with lifetime within the blue cursor in Biii are colored blue. Bv is the LLS
map where pixels with lifetime within the red cursor in Biii are colored
red. (C). FLIM of HeLa cell in normal media but exhibiting LLS. Ci is the
transmission image while Cii is the corresponding fluorescence intensity
image using same excitation and emission as B. Ciii is the resulting phasor
distribution from the sample. The blue and red cursors as well as the
metabolic trajectory and the oxidative stress axis are kept at same
positions as Biii. Civ is the corresponding NADH map while Cv is the LLS
map.
Long lifetime species in HeLa cells treated with oleic acid
For characterizing the biochemical origin the LLS associated with lipid and
oxidative stress, we treated HeLa cells with oleic acid to stimulate lipid
droplet formation in the cells. Oleic acid supplementation often results in
increased neutral lipid accumulation in form of lipid droplets2223. Additionally, it has been reported that oleic acid
increases ROS generation and oxidative stress2425. As a
control, we cultured HeLa cells in normal media as well as lipoprotein deprived
serum (LPDS) media, which are not expected to generate elevated numbers of lipid
droplets or cause additional stress. In the FLIM phasor distribution of oleic
acid fed HeLa cells (Fig. 4B, iii), we could identify
populations with NADH (blue cursor) and LLS (red cursor) FLIM signatures. NADH
phasor distribution in the imaged cell falls along the metabolic trajectory
shown by a blue dotted line in Fig. 4B, iii. Using the
phasor approach to FLIM, we mapped these populations back to the image to
visualize the regions of identified lifetime clusters on the phasor plot. The
NADH phasor distribution cluster corresponds to the nucleus and cytoplasm of the
cell (Fig. 4B, iv). The LLS phasor distribution falls
along the line joining the center of NADH distribution and the pure LLS FLIM
signature on the universal circle. This oxidative stress trajectory shown by a
red dotted line in Fig. 4B, iii lies within the triangle
formed by the phasors of free NADH, protein bound NADH, and LLS on the phasor
plot, as shown in Fig. 4A. When mapped back onto the
image, regions with long lifetime distribution, chosen by the red cursor,
correspond to the intracellular lipid droplets of the oleic acid treated HeLa
cells (Fig. 4B, v).A small percentage of control HeLa cells cultured in normal media also displayed
the LLS phasor distribution (Fig. 4C). However, when the
long lifetime species is present, it usually appears in lipid droplets near the
cellular membrane.In Fig. 5 we show FLIM phasor distribution of the three
groups of HeLa cells (oleic acid treated, normal media, and LPDS). For each
group, FLIM analysis was performed on 12 areas. This included 55 oleic acid fed
cells, 58 cells cultured in normal media, and 54 cells in LPDS media. Comparing
the individual phasor distribution of the three groups, the LLS population along
the oxidative stress axis is found to be markedly pronounced in the oleic acid
fed group (Fig. 5A and Fig. 5B),
while it is negligible in the control groups.
Figure 5
Increase in areas with LLS in oleic acid treated HeLa cells.
(A). Phasor distribution of HeLa cells treated with 400 μM
oleic acid for 24 hours. Red dotted line shows the oxidative stress axis.
(B). Phasor distribution of HeLa cells in normal media (top panel) and in
lipoprotein deficient serum, LPDS (bottom panel). Red dotted line shows the
oxidative stress axis. (C). Binary division of the phasor distribution with
LLS window (red square) selecting pixels with longer lifetime and NADH
window (blue square) selecting the shorter lifetime distribution. (D). Bar
graphs showing percentage of pixels within lifetime in the LLS window in the
three groups.
For statistical analysis, the phasor distributions of all three groups were
divided into two windows, NADH (blue square) and LLS (red square) as shown in
Fig. 5C. We calculated the fraction of pixels in all
the acquired images with phasors in the NADH window and the LLS window. These
values were normalized to the total number of pixels with phasors in the two
windows and converted into percentage. The percentage of pixels in the LLS
window in the three groups are plotted in Fig. 5D. The
plot shows a 6-fold increase in the lipid droplet associated LLS in HeLa cells
treated with oleic acid compared to the control cells in normal media and LPDS
media.
Use of non-linear label free microscopy techniques to determine the origin
of the autofluorescence signal
To further elaborate on our hypothesis that the long lifetime component arises
from oxidized lipid associated autofluorescence, we employed THG and CARS
imaging along with FLIM of oleic acid fed HeLA cells. Both these techniques
offer additional contrasts for observing lipid structures. Figure
6 shows the results of simultaneous FLIM and THG imaging of oleic
acid treated fixed HeLa cell. In the phasor plot we identified the LLS cluster
along the oxidative stress axis (red cursor in the phasor plot, Fig. 6B) and mapped them on the FLIM image (Fig.
6A middle panel). The area selected by the red cursor falls within
the THG signal (Fig. 6A right panel) arising from lipid
droplets. Supplementary Fig. S3 demonstrates similar LLS
lifetime distribution of fixed and live oleic acid treated HeLa cells (n = 3)
thus indicating that fixation of the cells does not affect the LLS lifetime.
Figure 6
Sequential FLIM and THG imaging of oleic acid treated fixed HeLa cell
(A).
Left panel is average fluorescence intensity image of treated HeLa cell
excited at 740 nm. Middle panel is the FLIM map of long lifetime phasor
cluster selected by red cursor in the phasor plot (B). Right panel is the
THG signal from the same sample excited at 1038 nm. (B). FLIM phasor plot
with red cursor selecting the long lifetime cluster. (C). THG phasor
plot.
Further proof for the oxidized lipid origin of LLS was obtained from combined
FLIM and CARS imaging. Once again we performed imaging on three groups of HeLa
cells : oleic acid-treated, LPDS, and normal media (Fig.
7). The group treated with oleic acid had much stronger CARS signal,
revealing abundant and larger lipid droplets compared to the other two groups.
This also correlates with increased areas of oxidized lipid associated
autofluorescence in the oleic acid fed group (Fig. 7,
middle column). However, it should be noted that not all lipid droplets,
unveiled by CARS signal, exhibit the LLS signature. Supplementary
Fig. S4 shows additional LLS FLIM map and CARS images of the three
groups. Interestingly, comparing the FLIM and CARS signals, we noticed few cells
(white arrow) with LLS signature that are absent in the CARS images. These cells
with strong oxidized lipid signal might have undergone apoptosis precisely due
to oxidative stress, and were washed off when the media was changed before CARS
imaging.
Figure 7
FLIM and CARS imaging of oleic acid treated HeLa cells.
Top panel is fluorescence intensity image, LLS FLIM map in red and CARS image
of oleic acid fed HeLa cells. Bottom panel is fluorescence intensity image ,
LLS FLIM map in red and CARS image of the control groups of HeLa cells in
LPDS media (top row) and in normal media (bottom row).
Chemical analysis by Raman spectroscopy
For chemical characterization of the oxidized lipid associated species with
autofluorescence signal, we obtained Raman spectra at regions of oleic acid
loaded HeLa cells that displayed the unique LLS FLIM signature. In Fig. 8A, ii, the lipid droplet from where Raman spectra was
obtained has been indicated by a blue square. This region also had a strong THG
signal (Fig. 8A, iii). The blue curve in Fig. 8B shows the Raman spectra of a lipid droplet in the
fingerprint (1200–1800 cm−1) and the CH
stretching (2700–3200 cm−1) regions. We
also obtained Raman spectra of 90% pure oleic acid (Fig.
8B black curve). The Raman spectra in the CH stretching regions
acquired from the LLS containing lipid droplets show the typical vibrational
bands of pure oleic acid. There is an additional peak in the fingerprint region
at 1746 cm−1, which is assigned to the C = O
stretching mode of ester bonds. This bond is formed upon esterification of the
fatty acid into neutral triglycerides, which constitute the major component of
lipid droplets. Supplementary Fig. S5 shows similar Raman
spectra obtained from lipid droplets in two different oleic acid fed fixed HeLa
cells with LLS signatures and THG signal. For this analysis, Raman spectra were
normalized by sections. The fingerprint band data were normalized to the 1646
cm−1 Raman band, whereas the CH stretching band
data were normalized to the 2850 cm−1 Raman band.
Figure 8
Chemical characterization of LLS by Raman spectroscopy.
(A). Fluorescence intensity image (Ai) of fixed oleic acid fed HeLa cells.
Aii is the LLS FLIM map in red. Dotted blue box encloses the lipid droplet
with LLS signal from where the Raman spectrum was acquired. Aiii is the THG
image from the same area. (B). Blue curve is the Raman spectra from the
lipid droplet of interest (marked by a blue square in Aii). Black curve is
the Raman spectra from 90% pure oleic acid. Red dotted box highlights the
additional peak observed in the Raman spectra from biological sample which
is not a feature of oleic acid
Discussion
In this work we identified a fluorescent species with unique long lifetime properties
(around 7.8 ns) which is distinct from the common NADH lifetime in cells
(1–2 ns). We present results showing autofluorescent long lifetime
species (LLS) linked to products of lipid oxidation by ROS, and hence potential
biomarker for oxidative stress. Lipids, per se, are non-fluorescent, however,
oxidized lipids can be12. We found that most of the fluorescence
arises from lipid droplets with granular structure. This long lifetime distribution
found in cells represents a species different from free/bound NADH. In this work we
grouped both nuclear and cytoplasmic NADH as a single distribution, although phasor
analysis can separate NADH from the two sub cellular regions. To identify the source
of fluorescence in the LLS, we performed FLIM imaging of freshly excised visceral
and subcutaneous WAT from old female mice. We found the LLS phasor distribution from
the adipocyte lipid droplets to fall on the universal circle at 7.8 ns. This
indicates the existence of a pure chemical species in the lipid droplet, as it is
known that lifetime distribution of pure species with single exponential decay would
lie on the universal circle15. This also confirms the existence of a
species separate from NADH in our sample. NADH distribution in biological samples
generally falls on the metabolic trajectory, the line joining position of pure free
NADH (0.4 ns) and pure protein bound NADH (3.4 ns)11. This metabolic
trajectory and the LLS signature on the universal circle form a triangle on the
phasor plot. From phasor algebra, a pixel in the image where LLS can coexist with
the NADH distribution will have a position inside this triangle. Hence using the
phasor approach, it was possible to distinguish these separate populations and map
them back to the images to reveal their spatial locations.To investigate the unique LLS in cells and their association with lipid droplets, we
used HeLa cells fed with oleic acid to stimulate the formation of lipid droplets,
and we observed the LLS signal arising from the lipid droplets. In these samples,
the linear combination of the long lifetime components due to oxidized lipids
species and NADH autofluorescence give rise to a separate, easily identifiable
cluster of phasors. This distribution cluster falls along the line joining the
center of NADH distribution and LLS FLIM signature (7.8 ns) on the universal circle.
We propose this line as the new oxidative stress axis on the phasor plot. Mapping
the lifetime phasors back onto the images, we observed the lipid droplet with LLS
were present in the cytoplasm of the HeLa cells. In rare occasions the LLS were also
observed in a few cells grown in normal media. Interestingly, these LLS containing
lipid droplets were mostly localized towards the membrane of the cells. We explored
the fluorescence emission characteristics of the LLS by employing spectral
phasors21. By comparing FLIM phasor and spectral phasor analysis
of both visceral and subcutaneous WAT, we found the regions with the LLS FLIM
signature to have distinct emission spectral properties than NADH. The LLS spectral
phasor distribution was centered on 497.4 nm for visceral WAT and 496.2 nm for
subcutaneous WAT. These were separable from NADH spectral phasor distribution
centered on 487 nm for both tissues.To identify the cellular location of the intrinsic fluorescent species, we imaged
tissue and cells using THG microscopy along with FLIM. THG signal arises from the
interface between the lipid droplets and their surroundings thus revealing the
spatial location of the droplets. Coupling the two modalities of label-free imaging,
we verified the co-localization of LLS within the lipid droplets of adipocytes in
visceral WAT. A 3D reconstruction of FLIM and THG images through 72 µm
depth of visceral WAT exhibited LLS signal throughout the lipid droplets of the
adipocytes surrounded by strong THG signal from the periphery of the droplets. This
is where the FLIM and THG signals overlapped. Simultaneous FLIM and THG from oleic
acid fed HeLa cells displayed the same results.Additionally, to test the chemical origin of the fluorescence signal we performed
FLIM on oleic acid fed HeLa cells followed by CARS imaging of the same cells. This
was possible due to the label-free and non-invasive nature of both imaging
techniques. CARS images revealed a large amount of lipid droplets in the samples,
supporting the increase in LLS phasor distribution along the oxidative stress axis.
These results once more substantiate our hypothesis of association of LLS with lipid
oxidation products. Interestingly, not all lipid droplets detected both by CARS and
THG have the autofluorescence long lifetime signature.Confocal Raman spectroscopy allows non-invasive chemical analysis of biological
samples. We employed this technique to analyze the locations where the long lifetime
components were detected. Fixed HeLa cells with oleic acid induced lipid droplet
were imaged by FLIM, and Raman spectra were acquired subsequently from granules with
LLS FLIM signature. The Raman spectra of the regions with LLS displayed the Raman
signatures indicative of esterified oleic acid, characteristic from triglycerides in
the lipid droplets19202627.Lipid droplet associated autofluorescence has been identified previously. These
include lipofuscin granules and retinosomes. Lipofuscin granules are found in humanretinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cells, fibroblasts and other types of cells and
have also been reported as oxidative stress marker2829. Stringari
et al reported existence of long lifetime species (about 8 ns) in human embryonic
stem cells and co-localized these lipid granules with
4,4-difluoro-1,3,5,7,8-pentamethyl-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene (BODIPY493/503),
which is a stain for neutral lipids11. They established that the
autofluorescent species with long lifetime were not associated to lipofuscin, which
has a much shorter lifetime (See Supplementary Fig. 6)30. This ascertains the LLS reported in this study are not related to
lipofuscin. Retinosomes are lipid droplet containing retinol, retinoic acid, and
retinol ester which are also sources of autofluorescence3132. The
lifetime fingerprint of pure retinol and retinoic acid with fluorescent lifetime
shorter than LSS has been shown to be in a different spatial location of the
lifetime phasor plot compared to the lipid droplet associated LLS reported here (See
Supplementary Fig. 6)12. Furthermore, retinol
and retinoic acid have a very prominent Raman band in the
1590–1600cm−1 range that was not observed
in our Raman spectra33. The phasor distribution of pure retinol in
Bovineserum albumin (BSA), excited at 740nm (2PE), is also shown in Supplementary Fig. 6.ROS and oxidative stress are related to a myriad of pathological conditions including
diabetes mellitus, obesity, inflammation, cancer, cardiovascular diseases, lung
diseases and neurodegenerative diseases45678910 . Its
role in pathogenesis has made it an important candidate for research on disease
development, diagnosis and treatment routes. Thus a biomarker for oxidative stress
could be used to elucidate pathways of disease development. Autofluorescence of
oxidized lipid has the potential to be such a biomarker and in this work we show a
unique detection approach by employing FLIM imaging.Even though MPM still has limited application in clinical settings, it improves
penetration for deep tissue imaging and in vivo animal models. Furthermore, as shown
in this work, we can apply this imaging technique to live cells and freshly excised
tissue.The long lifetime species FLIM signature of oxidized lipids detected using the phasor
approach is a promising, non-invasive tool to detect oxidative stress in biological
systems. As far as we know, this is the first time a label-free fluorescent
technique has been proposed for this purpose. As shown in this work, phasor analysis
of FLIM allows an efficient way to uniquely identify intrinsic, autofluorescent
marker of oxidative stress in cell cultures as well as tissue samples.
Methods
Instruments
Fluorescence lifetime imaging measurements of HeLa cells were performed on Zeiss
LSM 710 microscope (Carl Zeiss, Jena, Germany) using a 40x water immersion
objective, 1.2 N.A. (Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). For the 2-Photon
excitation laser source, Titanium:Sapphire MaiTai laser (Spectra-Physics,
Mountain View, CA) was used with excitation at 740 nm. Image scan speed was
25.21 µs/pixel and image size is 256 × 256 pixels. For
separating excitation from emission signal a dichroic at 690 nm was employed.
The emission filter used was a bandpass 460/80 nm and photomultiplier tube
(H7422P-40, Hamamatsu, Japan) was used for detection. FLIM data was acquired
using A320 FastFLIM FLIMbox (ISS, Champaign, IL).FLIM and third harmonic generation imaging of tissue sample were acquired using a
custom- built upright deep tissue imaging microscope. The operation principle
has been discussed previously34. For FLIM measurements, tissue
sample was excited at 740 nm and emission filter employed was bandpass
405–590 nm. For THG, excitation of 1038 nm was used and signal was
collected with bandpass filter 320–390 nm. Both FLIM and THG signals
were collected in transmission geometry on the same sample.For FLIM and THG data acquisition and processing, the SimFCS software developed
at the Laboratory of Fluorescence Dynamics (LFD, UC Irvine) was used.Coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) images were obtained by combining a
1064 nm, 76 MHz mode-locked Nd:Vanadate laser (Picotrain, High-Q, Hohenems,
Austria) and a 817 nm beam tuned from a MIRA 900 (Coherent, Santa Clara,
California). The two beams were overlapped both temporally and spatially, and
sent into a laser scanner (Fluoview 300, Olympus, Center Valley, PA), attached
to an inverted microscope (IX71, Olympus). The combined beams were then focused
through a 20 × 0.75 NA objective lens (UPlanSApo, Olympus) onto the
sample. The CARS signal was collected through the transmission channel by a
photomultiplier tube (Hamamatsu, Japan) after passing through a 625/50
filter.Spontaneous Raman spectra from the lipid droplets present in the cells were
acquired with a commercial Raman microscope (InVia Confocal; Renisahw,
Wotton-under-Edge, Gloucestershire, UK). The excitation wavelength at 523 nm was
focused into the sample with a 50 × objective, and the scattered
light was sent into the spectrometer that contained a 2400 l/mm grating. The
autofluorescent lipid droplets are identified based on morphology. The Raman
spectrum is then taken with 10s integration time, and the baseline was estimated
by minimizing a non-quadratic cost function.
Samples
HeLa cells were grown in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (D-MEM)
(1X), liquid (high glucose) supplemented with 10% Fetal Bovine Serum, and 1%
penicillinstreptomycin (100I U/ml) at 37°C in a 5% CO incubator.
For oleic acid treatment, the cells were cultured in 5% lipoprotein deficient
serum, LPDS (Intracel, Frederick, Maryland) and 95% D-MEM for 24 hours. Fatty
acid free bovineserum albumin was prepared by dissolving BSA powder
(Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri) in 5% LPDS media. 400 µM oleic
acid was prepared as a complex with BSA (OA/BSA) at molar ratio of 2:1. Cells
were treated with OA/BSA complex overnight. For controls, three different dishes
of HeLa cells were cultured in normal media and 5% LPDS media. For imaging, the
cells were plated in glass bottom dishes (Matek Corporation, Ashland,
Massachusetts). Prior to FLIM imaging, the oleic acid fed cells were washed with
1X Dulbecco’s Phosphate Buffered Saline, DPBS (Sigma-Aldrich). For
CARS imaging, media was replaced with DPBS. 4% Paraformaldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich)
solution was prepared to fix the cells for Raman spectroscopy measurements.White adipose tissue was obtained from 5 month old adult female mice.
Approximately 3mm diameter portions of fat from perigonadal and flank white
adipose tissue depots were freshly excised from the mice and subsequently
embedded in 1% low melt agarose in HBSS heated to 37°C between
coverslips separated by 0.2 mm spacers. All imaging were strictly performed
within 1 hour of tissue extraction. All animal procedures were performed with
strict adherence to NIH OLAW and institutional IACUC guidelines.For pure free and protein bound NADH FLIM measurements, 2.5 µM NADH
were diluted in 10 mM NaH2PO4*H2O at pH = 7.4.
For bound, it was mixed with 0.75 U/ml Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). For lifetime
measurement of retinoid in bovineserum albumin (BSA), retinol (Sigma-Aldrich)
was dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide, DMSO (EMD Millipore, California) and added
to BSA (Sigma-Aldrich) in buffer.
Additional Information
Ethic Statement: The experimental protocols were carried out in accordance with the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (NIH-OLAW) and were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of California, Irvine (IACUC-2011-2978).How to cite this article: Datta, R., Alfonso-Garcı´a, A., Cinco, R. & Gratton, E. Fluorescence lifetime imaging of endogenous biomarkerof oxidative stress. Sci. Rep.
5, 9848; doi: 10.1038/srep09848 (2015).
Authors: Melissa C Skala; Kristin M Riching; Annette Gendron-Fitzpatrick; Jens Eickhoff; Kevin W Eliceiri; John G White; Nirmala Ramanujam Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2007-11-27 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Christian Matthäus; Christoph Krafft; Benjamin Dietzek; Bernhard R Brehm; Stefan Lorkowski; Jürgen Popp Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2012-10-02 Impact factor: 6.986
Authors: Aris A Polyzos; Do Yup Lee; Rupsa Datta; Meghan Hauser; Helen Budworth; Amy Holt; Stephanie Mihalik; Pike Goldschmidt; Ken Frankel; Kelly Trego; Michael J Bennett; Jerry Vockley; Ke Xu; Enrico Gratton; Cynthia T McMurray Journal: Cell Metab Date: 2019-03-28 Impact factor: 27.287
Authors: Xiaoxin X Wang; Dong Wang; Yuhuan Luo; Komuraiah Myakala; Evgenia Dobrinskikh; Avi Z Rosenberg; Jonathan Levi; Jeffrey B Kopp; Amanda Field; Ashley Hill; Scott Lucia; Liru Qiu; Tao Jiang; Yingqiong Peng; David Orlicky; Gabriel Garcia; Michal Herman-Edelstein; Vivette D'Agati; Kammi Henriksen; Luciano Adorini; Mark Pruzanski; Cen Xie; Kristopher W Krausz; Frank J Gonzalez; Suman Ranjit; Alexander Dvornikov; Enrico Gratton; Moshe Levi Journal: J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2017-10-31 Impact factor: 10.121
Authors: Ning Ma; Gopakumar Kamalakshakurup; Mohammad Aghaamoo; Abraham P Lee; Michelle A Digman Journal: Cytometry A Date: 2018-12-11 Impact factor: 4.355
Authors: Takashi Hato; Seth Winfree; Richard Day; Ruben M Sandoval; Bruce A Molitoris; Mervin C Yoder; Roger C Wiggins; Yi Zheng; Kenneth W Dunn; Pierre C Dagher Journal: J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2017-03-01 Impact factor: 10.121
Authors: Aziz Ul Rehman; Ayad G Anwer; Martin E Gosnell; Saabah B Mahbub; Guozhen Liu; Ewa M Goldys Journal: Biomed Opt Express Date: 2017-02-10 Impact factor: 3.732