Jeremy F Strain1, Kyle B Womack2, Nyaz Didehbani1, Jeffrey S Spence1, Heather Conover1, John Hart3, Michael A Kraut4, C Munro Cullum2. 1. Center for BrainHealth, School of Behavioral and Brain Sciences, The University of Texas at Dallas, Dallas. 2. Department of Psychiatry, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas3Department of Neurology and Neurotherapeutics, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas. 3. Center for BrainHealth, School of Behavioral and Brain Sciences, The University of Texas at Dallas, Dallas2Department of Psychiatry, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas3Department of Neurology and Neurotherapeutics, University of Texas. 4. Center for BrainHealth, School of Behavioral and Brain Sciences, The University of Texas at Dallas, Dallas4Department of Radiology, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
Abstract
IMPORTANCE: To our knowledge, this is the first study to show an association between concussion, cognition, and anatomical structural brain changes across the age spectrum in former National Football League athletes. OBJECTIVE: To assess the relationship of hippocampal volume, memory performance, and the influence of concussion history in retired National Football League athletes with and without mild cognitive impairment (MCI). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This retrospective cohort study assessed differences between groups, mean hippocampal volumes, and memory performance by computing age quintiles based on group-specific linear regression models corrected for multiple comparisons for both athletes and control participants. The study was conducted starting in November 2010 and is ongoing at a research center in the northern region of Texas. This current analysis was conducted from October 9, 2013, to August 21, 2014. Participants included 28 retired National Football League athletes, 8 of whom had MCI and a history of concussion, 21 cognitively healthy control participants, and 6 control participants with MCI without concussion. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Hippocampal volume, age, California Verbal Learning Test scores, and the number of grade 3 (G3) concussions. In addition, the number of games played was examined as an objective variable pertaining to football history. RESULTS: The mean (SD) age was 58.1 (13) years for the 28 former athletes and 59.0 (12) years for the 27 control participants. Retired athletes with concussion history but without cognitive impairment had normal but significantly lower California Verbal Learning Test scores compared with control participants (mean [SD], 52.5 [8] vs 60.24 [7]; P = .002); those with a concussion history and MCI performed worse (mean [SD], 37 [8.62]) compared with both control participants (P < .001) and athletes without memory impairment (P < .001). Among the athletes, 17 had a G3 concussion and 11 did not. Older retired athletes with at least 1 G3 concussion had significantly smaller bilateral hippocampal volumes compared with control participants at the 40th age percentile (left, P = .04; right, P = .03), 60th percentile (left, P = .009; right, P = .01), and 80th percentile (left, P = .001; right, P = .002) and a smaller right hippocampal volume compared with athletes without a G3 concussion at the 40th percentile (P = .03), 60th percentile (P = .02), and 80th percentile (P = .02). Athletes with a history of G3 concussion were more likely to have MCI (7 of 7) compared with retired athletes without a history of G3 concussion (1 of 5) older than 63 years (P = .01). In addition, the left hippocampal volume in retired athletes with MCI and concussion was significantly smaller compared with control participants with MCI (P = .03). CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCE: Prior concussion that results in loss of consciousness is a risk factor for increased hippocampal atrophy and the development of MCI. In individuals with MCI, hippocampal volume loss appears greater among those with a history of concussion.
IMPORTANCE: To our knowledge, this is the first study to show an association between concussion, cognition, and anatomical structural brain changes across the age spectrum in former National Football League athletes. OBJECTIVE: To assess the relationship of hippocampal volume, memory performance, and the influence of concussion history in retired National Football League athletes with and without mild cognitive impairment (MCI). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This retrospective cohort study assessed differences between groups, mean hippocampal volumes, and memory performance by computing age quintiles based on group-specific linear regression models corrected for multiple comparisons for both athletes and control participants. The study was conducted starting in November 2010 and is ongoing at a research center in the northern region of Texas. This current analysis was conducted from October 9, 2013, to August 21, 2014. Participants included 28 retired National Football League athletes, 8 of whom had MCI and a history of concussion, 21 cognitively healthy control participants, and 6 control participants with MCI without concussion. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Hippocampal volume, age, California Verbal Learning Test scores, and the number of grade 3 (G3) concussions. In addition, the number of games played was examined as an objective variable pertaining to football history. RESULTS: The mean (SD) age was 58.1 (13) years for the 28 former athletes and 59.0 (12) years for the 27 control participants. Retired athletes with concussion history but without cognitive impairment had normal but significantly lower California Verbal Learning Test scores compared with control participants (mean [SD], 52.5 [8] vs 60.24 [7]; P = .002); those with a concussion history and MCI performed worse (mean [SD], 37 [8.62]) compared with both control participants (P < .001) and athletes without memory impairment (P < .001). Among the athletes, 17 had a G3 concussion and 11 did not. Older retired athletes with at least 1 G3 concussion had significantly smaller bilateral hippocampal volumes compared with control participants at the 40th age percentile (left, P = .04; right, P = .03), 60th percentile (left, P = .009; right, P = .01), and 80th percentile (left, P = .001; right, P = .002) and a smaller right hippocampal volume compared with athletes without a G3 concussion at the 40th percentile (P = .03), 60th percentile (P = .02), and 80th percentile (P = .02). Athletes with a history of G3 concussion were more likely to have MCI (7 of 7) compared with retired athletes without a history of G3 concussion (1 of 5) older than 63 years (P = .01). In addition, the left hippocampal volume in retired athletes with MCI and concussion was significantly smaller compared with control participants with MCI (P = .03). CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCE: Prior concussion that results in loss of consciousness is a risk factor for increased hippocampal atrophy and the development of MCI. In individuals with MCI, hippocampal volume loss appears greater among those with a history of concussion.
Authors: Michael A Kraut; Sarah Kremen; Jessica B Segal; Vincent Calhoun; Lauren R Moo; John Hart Journal: J Cogn Neurosci Date: 2002-01-01 Impact factor: 3.225
Authors: A T Du; N Schuff; D Amend; M P Laakso; Y Y Hsu; W J Jagust; K Yaffe; J H Kramer; B Reed; D Norman; H C Chui; M W Weiner Journal: J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Date: 2001-10 Impact factor: 10.154
Authors: John D MacKenzie; Faez Siddiqi; James S Babb; Linda J Bagley; Lois J Mannon; Grant P Sinson; Robert I Grossman Journal: AJNR Am J Neuroradiol Date: 2002-10 Impact factor: 3.825
Authors: Michael Grundman; Ronald C Petersen; Steven H Ferris; Ronald G Thomas; Paul S Aisen; David A Bennett; Norman L Foster; Clifford R Jack; Douglas R Galasko; Rachelle Doody; Jeffrey Kaye; Mary Sano; Richard Mohs; Serge Gauthier; Hyun T Kim; Shelia Jin; Arlan N Schultz; Kimberly Schafer; Ruth Mulnard; Christopher H van Dyck; Jacobo Mintzer; Edward Y Zamrini; Deborah Cahn-Weiner; Leon J Thal Journal: Arch Neurol Date: 2004-01
Authors: Benjamin L Brett; Jonathan Savitz; Morgan Nitta; Lezlie España; T Kent Teague; Lindsay D Nelson; Michael A McCrea; Timothy B Meier Journal: Brain Behav Immun Date: 2020-07-24 Impact factor: 7.217
Authors: Michael A Sugarman; Ann C McKee; Thor D Stein; Yorghos Tripodis; Lilah M Besser; Brett Martin; Joseph N Palmisano; Eric G Steinberg; Maureen K O'Connor; Rhoda Au; Michael McClean; Ronald Killiany; Jesse Mez; Michael W Weiner; Neil W Kowall; Robert A Stern; Michael L Alosco Journal: Alzheimers Dement Date: 2019-03-07 Impact factor: 21.566
Authors: Matt Aldag; Regina C Armstrong; Faris Bandak; Patrick S F Bellgowan; Timothy Bentley; Sean Biggerstaff; Katrina Caravelli; Joan Cmarik; Alicia Crowder; Thomas J DeGraba; Travis A Dittmer; Richard G Ellenbogen; Colin Greene; Raj K Gupta; Ramona Hicks; Stuart Hoffman; Robert C Latta; Michael J Leggieri; Donald Marion; Robert Mazzoli; Michael McCrea; John O'Donnell; Mark Packer; James B Petro; Todd E Rasmussen; Wendy Sammons-Jackson; Richard Shoge; Victoria Tepe; Ladd A Tremaine; James Zheng Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2017-09 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Breton M Asken; Molly J Sullan; Aliyah R Snyder; Zachary M Houck; Vaughn E Bryant; Loren P Hizel; Molly E McLaren; Duane E Dede; Michael S Jaffee; Steven T DeKosky; Russell M Bauer Journal: Neuropsychol Rev Date: 2016-08-25 Impact factor: 7.444
Authors: Christian Lepage; Marc Muehlmann; Yorghos Tripodis; Jakob Hufschmidt; Julie Stamm; Katie Green; Pawel Wrobel; Vivian Schultz; Isabelle Weir; Michael L Alosco; Christine M Baugh; Nathan G Fritts; Brett M Martin; Christine Chaisson; Michael J Coleman; Alexander P Lin; Ofer Pasternak; Nikos Makris; Robert A Stern; Martha E Shenton; Inga K Koerte Journal: Brain Imaging Behav Date: 2019-06 Impact factor: 3.978
Authors: Robert Zivadinov; Paul Polak; Ferdinand Schweser; Niels Bergsland; Jesper Hagemeier; Michael G Dwyer; Deepa P Ramasamy; John G Baker; John J Leddy; Barry S Willer Journal: J Head Trauma Rehabil Date: 2018 Sep/Oct Impact factor: 2.710