PURPOSE: High rate of malunion and non union in displaced fracture clavicle treated conservatively lead to use of different types of internal fixation methods which also were found to be associated with various complications. Moreover their superiority over conservative treatment has not been established. This study was designed to compare clinical outcome of conservative treatment with external fixator in cases with displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. METHODS: Fifty adult consenting cases of acute midshaft fracture clavicle, displaced >15 mm were included. Twenty five cases were allotted to conservative (group A) and external fixator (group B) each. In group A treatment was given in form of clavicle brace. In group B schanz pins were inserted obliquely between supero-inferior and anterior-posterior direction and connected with rod. The outcome was measured by Constant score, union time and complications. RESULTS: Mean radiographic union time in group A was 23.45 ± 1.40 weeks (with 8% non union and 80% malunion) and in group B it was 9.36 ± 1.49 weeks. Mean Constant score at 6 months in group A was 78.28 ± 6.45 and in group B 92.72 ± 1.48. Mean shortening at 6 months in group A was 19.36 mm. In group B shortening at 6 months was noticed in three cases (6, 5, 6 mm). CONCLUSION: Close reduction of acute fracture mid clavicle and application of external fixator is a simple procedure providing the benefits of rigid fixation and undisturbed fracture environment. Pain relief is faster, union time is shorter and there are no hardware related problems.
PURPOSE: High rate of malunion and non union in displaced fracture clavicle treated conservatively lead to use of different types of internal fixation methods which also were found to be associated with various complications. Moreover their superiority over conservative treatment has not been established. This study was designed to compare clinical outcome of conservative treatment with external fixator in cases with displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. METHODS: Fifty adult consenting cases of acute midshaft fracture clavicle, displaced >15 mm were included. Twenty five cases were allotted to conservative (group A) and external fixator (group B) each. In group A treatment was given in form of clavicle brace. In group B schanz pins were inserted obliquely between supero-inferior and anterior-posterior direction and connected with rod. The outcome was measured by Constant score, union time and complications. RESULTS: Mean radiographic union time in group A was 23.45 ± 1.40 weeks (with 8% non union and 80% malunion) and in group B it was 9.36 ± 1.49 weeks. Mean Constant score at 6 months in group A was 78.28 ± 6.45 and in group B 92.72 ± 1.48. Mean shortening at 6 months in group A was 19.36 mm. In group B shortening at 6 months was noticed in three cases (6, 5, 6 mm). CONCLUSION: Close reduction of acute fracture mid clavicle and application of external fixator is a simple procedure providing the benefits of rigid fixation and undisturbed fracture environment. Pain relief is faster, union time is shorter and there are no hardware related problems.
Authors: Michael D McKee; Elizabeth M Pedersen; Caroline Jones; David J G Stephen; Hans J Kreder; Emil H Schemitsch; Lisa M Wild; Jeffrey Potter Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2006-01 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Silvana De Giorgi; Angela Notarnicola; Silvio Tafuri; Giuseppe Solarino; Lorenzo Moretti; Biagio Moretti Journal: BMC Res Notes Date: 2011-09-08
Authors: Frans-Jasper G Wijdicks; Olivier A J Van der Meijden; Peter J Millett; Egbert J M M Verleisdonk; R Marijn Houwert Journal: Arch Orthop Trauma Surg Date: 2012-01-10 Impact factor: 3.067
Authors: Barış Özkul; Mehmet Selçuk Saygılı; Yaşar Mahsut Dinçel; Ilhan Avni Bayhan; Deniz Akbulut; Bilal Demir Journal: Med Princ Pract Date: 2017-10-01 Impact factor: 1.927