Tania Conte1, Craig Mitton1, Logan M Trenaman1, Negar Chavoshi2, Harold Siden3. 1. School of Population and Public Health, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC ; Centre for Clinical Epidemiology and Evaluation, Vancouver, BC. 2. School of Population and Public Health, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC ; Canuck Place Children's Hospice, Vancouver, BC. 3. Canuck Place Children's Hospice, Vancouver, BC ; Child and Family Research Institute, Vancouver, BC ; Division of General Pediatrics, Department of Pediatrics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Pediatric palliative care is a relatively new and evolving field, and the cost of pediatric palliative care programs is unclear. We conducted a systematic review to compare inpatient health care utilization and costs among children with life-threatening conditions who have accessed a pediatric palliative care program and those who have not. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL and LILACS databases from January 2000 to July 2013, as well as the grey literature, for experimental or observational studies that compared pediatric palliative care programs with usual care. Outcomes of interest included hospital admissions, length of stay and health care costs. RESULTS: Of the 5193 records identified, we reviewed 109 in full and included 11 in our study. The overall quality of the studies was moderate to low. We observed mixed results for all outcomes. Compared with patients receiving usual care, fewer patients in the palliative care group had hospital admissions and fewer of those with cancer had planned hospital admissions. In contrast, no effects were observed regarding the overall number of hospital, emergency or outpatient admissions. Conflicting results were observed with regards to critical care utilization. Studies showed a trend toward shorter lengths of stay in hospital in the palliative care group. However, a single study that also considered inpatient time in hospice facilities found an increase in total length of stay, which showed a shift in the setting of health care utilization. We observed no conclusive trend in the effects on cost. INTERPRETATION: Evidence suggests that pediatric palliative care programs may result in a shift of utilization to other health care settings beyond hospital care. These settings should be considered when measuring resource utilization and costs.
BACKGROUND: Pediatric palliative care is a relatively new and evolving field, and the cost of pediatric palliative care programs is unclear. We conducted a systematic review to compare inpatient health care utilization and costs among children with life-threatening conditions who have accessed a pediatric palliative care program and those who have not. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL and LILACS databases from January 2000 to July 2013, as well as the grey literature, for experimental or observational studies that compared pediatric palliative care programs with usual care. Outcomes of interest included hospital admissions, length of stay and health care costs. RESULTS: Of the 5193 records identified, we reviewed 109 in full and included 11 in our study. The overall quality of the studies was moderate to low. We observed mixed results for all outcomes. Compared with patients receiving usual care, fewer patients in the palliative care group had hospital admissions and fewer of those with cancer had planned hospital admissions. In contrast, no effects were observed regarding the overall number of hospital, emergency or outpatient admissions. Conflicting results were observed with regards to critical care utilization. Studies showed a trend toward shorter lengths of stay in hospital in the palliative care group. However, a single study that also considered inpatient time in hospice facilities found an increase in total length of stay, which showed a shift in the setting of health care utilization. We observed no conclusive trend in the effects on cost. INTERPRETATION: Evidence suggests that pediatric palliative care programs may result in a shift of utilization to other health care settings beyond hospital care. These settings should be considered when measuring resource utilization and costs.
Authors: Ross M Hays; Jeanette Valentine; Gerri Haynes; J Russel Geyer; Nanci Villareale; Beth McKinstry; James W Varni; Shervin S Churchill Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2006-06 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: Alessandro Liberati; Douglas G Altman; Jennifer Tetzlaff; Cynthia Mulrow; Peter C Gøtzsche; John P A Ioannidis; Mike Clarke; P J Devereaux; Jos Kleijnen; David Moher Journal: BMJ Date: 2009-07-21
Authors: Lesley C Arland; Verna L Hendricks-Ferguson; Joanne Pearson; Nicholas K Foreman; Jennifer R Madden Journal: J Spec Pediatr Nurs Date: 2013-03-24 Impact factor: 1.260
Authors: Daphna Gans; Gerald F Kominski; Dylan H Roby; Allison L Diamant; Xiao Chen; Wenjiao Lin; Nina Hohe Journal: Policy Brief UCLA Cent Health Policy Res Date: 2012-08
Authors: Caprice A Knapp; Elizabeth A Shenkman; Mircea I Marcu; Vanessa L Madden; Joseph V Terza Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2009-03 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: L K Fraser; M van Laar; M Miller; J Aldridge; P A McKinney; R C Parslow; R G Feltbower Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 2013-02-28 Impact factor: 7.640
Authors: Justin A Yu; Yael Schenker; Scott H Maurer; Stacey C Cook; Dio Kavlieratos; Amy Houtrow Journal: Fam Syst Health Date: 2019-05-02 Impact factor: 1.950
Authors: Jeffrey Goldhagen; Mark Fafard; Kelly Komatz; Terry Eason; William C Livingood Journal: BMC Palliat Care Date: 2016-08-03 Impact factor: 3.234
Authors: Esther van Puffelen; Suzanne Polinder; Ilse Vanhorebeek; Pieter Jozef Wouters; Niek Bossche; Guido Peers; Sören Verstraete; Koen Felix Maria Joosten; Greet Van den Berghe; Sascha Cornelis Antonius Theodorus Verbruggen; Dieter Mesotten Journal: Crit Care Date: 2018-01-15 Impact factor: 9.097
Authors: Karin Zimmermann; Eva Cignacco; Sandra Engberg; Anne-Sylvie Ramelet; Nicolas von der Weid; Katri Eskola; Eva Bergstraesser; Marc Ansari; Christoph Aebi; Reta Baer; Maja Beck Popovic; Vera Bernet; Pierluigi Brazzola; Hans Ulrich Bucher; Regula Buder; Sandra Cagnazzo; Barbara Dinten; Anouk Dorsaz; Franz Elmer; Raquel Enriquez; Patricia Fahrni-Nater; Gabi Finkbeiner; Bernhard Frey; Urs Frey; Jeannette Greiner; Ralph-Ingo Hassink; Simone Keller; Oliver Kretschmar; Judith Kroell; Bernard Laubscher; Kurt Leibundgut; Reta Malaer; Andreas Meyer; Christoph Stuessi; Mathias Nelle; Thomas Neuhaus; Felix Niggli; Geneviève Perrenoud; Jean-Pierre Pfammatter; Barbara Plecko; Debora Rupf; Felix Sennhauser; Caroline Stade; Maja Steinlin; Lilian Stoffel; Karin Thomas; Christian Vonarburg; Rodo von Vigier; Bendicht Wagner; Judith Wieland; Birgit Wernz Journal: BMC Pediatr Date: 2018-02-16 Impact factor: 2.125