Greg S Whiteley1, Chris Derry1, Trevor Glasbey2, Paul Fahey1. 1. 1University of Western Sydney,School of Science and Health,Richmond,NSW,Australia. 2. 2Whiteley Corporation,North Sydney,NSW,Australia.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the reliability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and to document precision and variability measurements using known and quantitated standard materials. METHODS: Four commercially branded ATP bioluminometers and their consumables were subjected to a series of controlled studies with quantitated materials in multiple repetitions of dilution series. The individual dilutions were applied directly to ATP swabs. To assess precision and reproducibility, each dilution step was tested in triplicate or quadruplicate and the RLU reading from each test point was recorded. Results across the multiple dilution series were normalized using the coefficient of variation. RESULTS: The results for pure ATP and bacterial ATP from suspensions of Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa are presented graphically. The data indicate that precision and reproducibility are poor across all brands tested. Standard deviation was as high as 50% of the mean for all brands, and in the field users are not provided any indication of this level of imprecision. CONCLUSIONS: The variability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and their consumables is unacceptably high with the current technical configuration. The advantage of speed of response is undermined by instrument imprecision expressed in the numerical scale of relative light units (RLU).
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the reliability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and to document precision and variability measurements using known and quantitated standard materials. METHODS: Four commercially branded ATP bioluminometers and their consumables were subjected to a series of controlled studies with quantitated materials in multiple repetitions of dilution series. The individual dilutions were applied directly to ATP swabs. To assess precision and reproducibility, each dilution step was tested in triplicate or quadruplicate and the RLU reading from each test point was recorded. Results across the multiple dilution series were normalized using the coefficient of variation. RESULTS: The results for pure ATP and bacterial ATP from suspensions of Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa are presented graphically. The data indicate that precision and reproducibility are poor across all brands tested. Standard deviation was as high as 50% of the mean for all brands, and in the field users are not provided any indication of this level of imprecision. CONCLUSIONS: The variability of commercial ATP bioluminometers and their consumables is unacceptably high with the current technical configuration. The advantage of speed of response is undermined by instrument imprecision expressed in the numerical scale of relative light units (RLU).
Authors: Lisa Hall; Alison Farrington; Brett G Mitchell; Adrian G Barnett; Kate Halton; Michelle Allen; Katie Page; Anne Gardner; Sally Havers; Emily Bailey; Stephanie J Dancer; Thomas V Riley; Christian A Gericke; David L Paterson; Nicholas Graves Journal: Implement Sci Date: 2016-03-24 Impact factor: 7.327