Robert C Cope1, Phillip Cassey2, Graeme J Hugo3, Joshua V Ross4. 1. School of Mathematical Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia. 2. School of Earth & Environmental Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia. 3. Geography, Environment and Population, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia. 4. School of Mathematical Sciences & NHMRC CRE in Infectious Diseases Modelling to Inform Public Health Policy, Th University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To assess the risk of Ebola importation to Australia during the first six months of 2015, based upon the current outbreak in West Africa. METHODOLOGY: We assessed the risk under two distinct scenarios: (i) assuming that significant numbers of cases of Ebola remain confined to Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone, and using historic passenger arrival data into Australia; and, (ii) assuming potential secondary spread based upon international flight data. A model appropriate to each scenario is developed, and parameterised using passenger arrival card or international flight data, and World Health Organisation case data from West Africa. These models were constructed based on WHO Ebola outbreak data as at 17 October 2014 and 3 December 2014. An assessment of the risk under each scenario is reported. On 27 October 2014 the Australian Government announced a policy change, that visas from affected countries would be refused/cancelled, and the predicted effect of this policy change is reported. RESULTS: The current probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015, having travelled directly from West Africa with historic passenger arrival rates into Australia, is 0.34. Under the new Australian Government policy of restricting visas from affected countries (as of 27 October 2014), the probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015 is reduced to 0.16. The probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015 via an outbreak from a secondary source country is approximately 0.12. CONCLUSIONS: Our models suggest that if the transmission of Ebola remains unchanged, it is possible that a case will enter Australia within the first six months of 2015, either directly from West Africa (even when current visa restrictions are considered), or via secondary outbreaks elsewhere. Government and medical authorities should be prepared to respond to this eventuality. Control measures within West Africa over recent months have contributed to a reduction in projected risk of a case entering Australia. A significant further reduction of the rate at which Ebola is proliferating in West Africa, and control of the disease if and when it proliferates elsewhere, will continue to result in substantially lower risk of the disease entering Australia.
OBJECTIVES: To assess the risk of Ebola importation to Australia during the first six months of 2015, based upon the current outbreak in West Africa. METHODOLOGY: We assessed the risk under two distinct scenarios: (i) assuming that significant numbers of cases of Ebola remain confined to Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone, and using historic passenger arrival data into Australia; and, (ii) assuming potential secondary spread based upon international flight data. A model appropriate to each scenario is developed, and parameterised using passenger arrival card or international flight data, and World Health Organisation case data from West Africa. These models were constructed based on WHO Ebola outbreak data as at 17 October 2014 and 3 December 2014. An assessment of the risk under each scenario is reported. On 27 October 2014 the Australian Government announced a policy change, that visas from affected countries would be refused/cancelled, and the predicted effect of this policy change is reported. RESULTS: The current probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015, having travelled directly from West Africa with historic passenger arrival rates into Australia, is 0.34. Under the new Australian Government policy of restricting visas from affected countries (as of 27 October 2014), the probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015 is reduced to 0.16. The probability of at least one case entering Australia by 1 July 2015 via an outbreak from a secondary source country is approximately 0.12. CONCLUSIONS: Our models suggest that if the transmission of Ebola remains unchanged, it is possible that a case will enter Australia within the first six months of 2015, either directly from West Africa (even when current visa restrictions are considered), or via secondary outbreaks elsewhere. Government and medical authorities should be prepared to respond to this eventuality. Control measures within West Africa over recent months have contributed to a reduction in projected risk of a case entering Australia. A significant further reduction of the rate at which Ebola is proliferating in West Africa, and control of the disease if and when it proliferates elsewhere, will continue to result in substantially lower risk of the disease entering Australia.
Authors: Marcelo F C Gomes; Ana Pastore Y Piontti; Luca Rossi; Dennis Chao; Ira Longini; M Elizabeth Halloran; Alessandro Vespignani Journal: PLoS Curr Date: 2014-09-02
Authors: Martin I Meltzer; Charisma Y Atkins; Scott Santibanez; Barbara Knust; Brett W Petersen; Elizabeth D Ervin; Stuart T Nichol; Inger K Damon; Michael L Washington Journal: MMWR Suppl Date: 2014-09-26
Authors: Joseph A Lewnard; Martial L Ndeffo Mbah; Jorge A Alfaro-Murillo; Frederick L Altice; Luke Bawo; Tolbert G Nyenswah; Alison P Galvani Journal: Lancet Infect Dis Date: 2014-10-23 Impact factor: 25.071
Authors: Isaac I Bogoch; Maria I Creatore; Martin S Cetron; John S Brownstein; Nicki Pesik; Jennifer Miniota; Theresa Tam; Wei Hu; Adriano Nicolucci; Saad Ahmed; James W Yoon; Isha Berry; Simon I Hay; Aranka Anema; Andrew J Tatem; Derek MacFadden; Matthew German; Kamran Khan Journal: Lancet Date: 2014-10-21 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Stephen K Gire; Augustine Goba; Kristian G Andersen; Rachel S G Sealfon; Daniel J Park; Lansana Kanneh; Simbirie Jalloh; Mambu Momoh; Mohamed Fullah; Gytis Dudas; Shirlee Wohl; Lina M Moses; Nathan L Yozwiak; Sarah Winnicki; Christian B Matranga; Christine M Malboeuf; James Qu; Adrianne D Gladden; Stephen F Schaffner; Xiao Yang; Pan-Pan Jiang; Mahan Nekoui; Andres Colubri; Moinya Ruth Coomber; Mbalu Fonnie; Alex Moigboi; Michael Gbakie; Fatima K Kamara; Veronica Tucker; Edwin Konuwa; Sidiki Saffa; Josephine Sellu; Abdul Azziz Jalloh; Alice Kovoma; James Koninga; Ibrahim Mustapha; Kandeh Kargbo; Momoh Foday; Mohamed Yillah; Franklyn Kanneh; Willie Robert; James L B Massally; Sinéad B Chapman; James Bochicchio; Cheryl Murphy; Chad Nusbaum; Sarah Young; Bruce W Birren; Donald S Grant; John S Scheiffelin; Eric S Lander; Christian Happi; Sahr M Gevao; Andreas Gnirke; Andrew Rambaut; Robert F Garry; S Humarr Khan; Pardis C Sabeti Journal: Science Date: 2014-08-28 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Bruce Aylward; Philippe Barboza; Luke Bawo; Eric Bertherat; Pepe Bilivogui; Isobel Blake; Rick Brennan; Sylvie Briand; Jethro Magwati Chakauya; Kennedy Chitala; Roland M Conteh; Anne Cori; Alice Croisier; Jean-Marie Dangou; Boubacar Diallo; Christl A Donnelly; Christopher Dye; Tim Eckmanns; Neil M Ferguson; Pierre Formenty; Caroline Fuhrer; Keiji Fukuda; Tini Garske; Alex Gasasira; Stephen Gbanyan; Peter Graaff; Emmanuel Heleze; Amara Jambai; Thibaut Jombart; Francis Kasolo; Albert Mbule Kadiobo; Sakoba Keita; Daniel Kertesz; Moussa Koné; Chris Lane; Jered Markoff; Moses Massaquoi; Harriet Mills; John Mike Mulba; Emmanuel Musa; Joel Myhre; Abdusalam Nasidi; Eric Nilles; Pierre Nouvellet; Deo Nshimirimana; Isabelle Nuttall; Tolbert Nyenswah; Olushayo Olu; Scott Pendergast; William Perea; Jonathan Polonsky; Steven Riley; Olivier Ronveaux; Keita Sakoba; Ravi Santhana Gopala Krishnan; Mikiko Senga; Faisal Shuaib; Maria D Van Kerkhove; Rui Vaz; Niluka Wijekoon Kannangarage; Zabulon Yoti Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2014-09-22 Impact factor: 91.245