Arman Kilic1, Robert S D Higgins1, Bryan A Whitson1, Ahmet Kilic2. 1. From Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD (Arman Kilic); and Division of Cardiac Surgery, Department of Surgery, Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH (R.S.D.H., B.A.W., Ahmet Kilic). 2. From Department of Surgery, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD (Arman Kilic); and Division of Cardiac Surgery, Department of Surgery, Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH (R.S.D.H., B.A.W., Ahmet Kilic). Ahmet.Kilic@osumc.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: This study evaluated whether minority orthotopic heart transplant (OHT) recipients tend to be transplanted at worse performing centers. METHODS AND RESULTS: OHT recipients between 2000 and 2010 were identified in the United Network for Organ Sharing database and stratified by race. Center performance was evaluated using observed-to-expected mortality ratios that were calculated using validated indexes for recipient and donor risk in OHT. The primary outcome was 1-year post-OHT mortality. A total of 102 centers performed OHT in 18 085 patients. Blacks had higher unadjusted 1-year mortality, which was confirmed after risk adjustment. Blacks had increased risk-adjusted mortality at poor performing centers (observed-to-expected mortality ratio, >1.2; odds ratio, 1.37 [95% confidence interval, 1.12-1.69]; P=0.002) and a strong trend toward increased mortality at excellent performing centers (observed-to-expected mortality ratio, <0.8; odds ratio, 1.42 [95% confidence interval, 0.99-2.02]; P=0.06). A higher proportion of blacks were treated at centers with higher-than-expected mortality (56.4% versus 47.1% whites versus 48.1% Hispanics; P<0.001), a finding that persisted after adjusting for insurance type and highest education level. In addition, there was a positive correlation between the percentage of blacks and observed-to-expected mortality ratios at the center level (r=0.32; P=0.001). In multivariable analysis incorporating immunologic and socioeconomic variables, there was no clear dominant source for the disparities in outcomes of OHT between races. CONCLUSIONS: Blacks have a propensity to be transplanted at worse performing centers; however, center effect alone does not explain the mortality difference between ethnicities. Although referral of minorities to better performing centers would improve absolute survival, it would not likely eliminate the racial disparities that exist in OHT outcomes.
BACKGROUND: This study evaluated whether minority orthotopic heart transplant (OHT) recipients tend to be transplanted at worse performing centers. METHODS AND RESULTS: OHT recipients between 2000 and 2010 were identified in the United Network for Organ Sharing database and stratified by race. Center performance was evaluated using observed-to-expected mortality ratios that were calculated using validated indexes for recipient and donor risk in OHT. The primary outcome was 1-year post-OHT mortality. A total of 102 centers performed OHT in 18 085 patients. Blacks had higher unadjusted 1-year mortality, which was confirmed after risk adjustment. Blacks had increased risk-adjusted mortality at poor performing centers (observed-to-expected mortality ratio, >1.2; odds ratio, 1.37 [95% confidence interval, 1.12-1.69]; P=0.002) and a strong trend toward increased mortality at excellent performing centers (observed-to-expected mortality ratio, <0.8; odds ratio, 1.42 [95% confidence interval, 0.99-2.02]; P=0.06). A higher proportion of blacks were treated at centers with higher-than-expected mortality (56.4% versus 47.1% whites versus 48.1% Hispanics; P<0.001), a finding that persisted after adjusting for insurance type and highest education level. In addition, there was a positive correlation between the percentage of blacks and observed-to-expected mortality ratios at the center level (r=0.32; P=0.001). In multivariable analysis incorporating immunologic and socioeconomic variables, there was no clear dominant source for the disparities in outcomes of OHT between races. CONCLUSIONS: Blacks have a propensity to be transplanted at worse performing centers; however, center effect alone does not explain the mortality difference between ethnicities. Although referral of minorities to better performing centers would improve absolute survival, it would not likely eliminate the racial disparities that exist in OHT outcomes.
Authors: Emelia J Benjamin; Michael J Blaha; Stephanie E Chiuve; Mary Cushman; Sandeep R Das; Rajat Deo; Sarah D de Ferranti; James Floyd; Myriam Fornage; Cathleen Gillespie; Carmen R Isasi; Monik C Jiménez; Lori Chaffin Jordan; Suzanne E Judd; Daniel Lackland; Judith H Lichtman; Lynda Lisabeth; Simin Liu; Chris T Longenecker; Rachel H Mackey; Kunihiro Matsushita; Dariush Mozaffarian; Michael E Mussolino; Khurram Nasir; Robert W Neumar; Latha Palaniappan; Dilip K Pandey; Ravi R Thiagarajan; Mathew J Reeves; Matthew Ritchey; Carlos J Rodriguez; Gregory A Roth; Wayne D Rosamond; Comilla Sasson; Amytis Towfighi; Connie W Tsao; Melanie B Turner; Salim S Virani; Jenifer H Voeks; Joshua Z Willey; John T Wilkins; Jason Hy Wu; Heather M Alger; Sally S Wong; Paul Muntner Journal: Circulation Date: 2017-01-25 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Asia McDavid; Kelly MacBrair; Sitaramesh Emani; Lianbo Yu; Peter H U Lee; Bryan A Whitson; Brent C Lampert; Riddhima Agarwal; Ahmet Kilic Journal: Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg Date: 2018-01-01
Authors: Palak Shah; Sean Agbor-Enoh; Pramita Bagchi; Christopher R deFilippi; Angela Mercado; Gouqing Diao; Dave Jp Morales; Keyur B Shah; Samer S Najjar; Erika Feller; Steven Hsu; Maria E Rodrigo; Sabra C Lewsey; Moon Kyoo Jang; Charles Marboe; Gerald J Berry; Kiran K Khush; Hannah A Valantine Journal: J Heart Lung Transplant Date: 2022-06-28 Impact factor: 13.569
Authors: Hasina Maredia; Mary Grace Bowring; Allan B Massie; Sunjae Bae; Amber Kernodle; Shakirat Oyetunji; Christian Merlo; Robert S D Higgins; Dorry L Segev; Errol L Bush Journal: Circ Heart Fail Date: 2021-02-02 Impact factor: 8.790
Authors: Olivia Agata Walkowiak; William A Hardy; Lauren V Huckaby; Minoo N Kavarana; Suyog A Mokashi; Taufiek Konrad Rajab Journal: Healthcare (Basel) Date: 2022-03-25