| Literature DB >> 25374786 |
Nicola J Reavley1, Pamela D Pilkington2.
Abstract
Introduction. The paper reports on an exploratory study of the usefulness of Twitter for unobtrusive assessment of stigmatizing attitudes in the community. Materials and Methods. Tweets with the hashtags #depression or #schizophrenia posted on Twitter during a 7-day period were collected. Tweets were categorised based on their content and user information and also on the extent to which they indicated a stigmatising attitude towards depression or schizophrenia (stigmatising, personal experience of stigma, supportive, neutral, or anti-stigma). Tweets that indicated stigmatising attitudes or personal experiences of stigma were further grouped into the following subthemes: social distance, dangerousness, snap out of it, personal weakness, inaccurate beliefs, mocking or trivializing, and self-stigma. Results and Discussion. Tweets on depression mostly related to resources for consumers (34%), or advertised services or products for individuals with depression (20%). The majority of schizophrenia tweets aimed to increase awareness of schizophrenia (29%) or reported on research findings (22%). Tweets on depression were largely supportive (65%) or neutral (27%). A number of tweets were specifically anti-stigma (7%). Less than 1% of tweets reflected stigmatising attitudes (0.7%) or personal experience of stigma (0.1%). More than one third of the tweets which reflected stigmatising attitudes were mocking or trivialising towards individuals with depression (37%). The attitude that individuals with depression should "snap out of it" was evident in 30% of the stigmatising tweets. The majority of tweets relating to schizophrenia were categorised as supportive (42%) or neutral (43%). Almost 10% of tweets were explicitly anti-stigma. The percentage of tweets showing stigmatising attitudes was 5%, while less than 1% of tweets described personal experiences of stigmatising attitudes towards individuals with schizophrenia. Of the tweets that indicated stigmatising attitudes, most reflected inaccurate beliefs about schizophrenia being multiple personality disorder (52%) or mocked or trivialised individuals with schizophrenia (33%). Conclusions. The study supports the use of analysis of Twitter content to unobtrusively measure attitudes towards mental illness, both supportive and stigmatising. The results of the study may be useful in assisting mental health promotion and advocacy organisations to provide information about resources and support, raise awareness and counter common stigmatising attitudes.Entities:
Keywords: Depression; Schizophrenia; Stigma; Twitter
Year: 2014 PMID: 25374786 PMCID: PMC4217192 DOI: 10.7717/peerj.647
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PeerJ ISSN: 2167-8359 Impact factor: 2.984
Theme definitions and representative tweets.
| Theme | Definition | Representative #depression tweets | Representative #schizophrenia tweets |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||
|
| Describes personal experience with depression or schizophrenia as a consumer, or a friend or relative of someone with depression or schizophrenia. | • #depression makes me feel like i’m constantly living a outer body experience when i’m on my own. | • I was diagnosed with dementia praecox (#schizophrenia) 32 years ago. Sorry about my crazy tweets, I’m insane. |
|
| Promotes awareness of depression or schizophrenia by either (1) providing information (2) linking to information on a website (e.g., blog, news article, e-book, or YouTube video) or (3) encouraging discussion about depression or schizophrenia. | • Are You Depressed? Signs and Symptoms of Depression in Women: | • Five myths—and the facts—about schizophrenia |
|
| Provides resources, advice, or support specifically for consumers or friends and relatives of someone with depression or schizophrenia; or encourages social networking between consumers. | • RT @Daniel_L_Baker: if you’re suffering from | • 6 tips for families dealing |
|
| Describes and links to an online news story or article | • Toronto woman denied entry to U.S. after agent cites history of | • @HuffingtonPost article |
|
| Advertises a product or service for sale | • #Frankincense—Deep in | • Haloperidol schizophrenia best |
|
| Describes the outcomes of a research study | • #Depression in | • Meta-analysis finds that mindfulness may help with the negative symptoms of |
|
| Describes an individual’s personal opinion or view | • I think this #generation has issues with | • The Schofield’s are a family that make me feel grateful for my daughter |
|
| Indicates a negative attitude towards people with depression/schizophrenia | • Wanna know the secret of #depression? People only have it if they know they’ve become a | • Schizophrenia: |
|
| Describes a personal experience of stigmatising | • My husband suffered | • @seniorchuffy |
|
| Explicitly promotes the reduction of stigma towards people with depression/schizophrenia | • RT @Daniel_L_Baker: | • And if you think that people with #schizophrenia (like me) or other mental health conditions are “psycho” or dangerous, shame on you. |
|
| Supportive towards people with depression/schizophrenia | • It IS possible to recover from #depression. | • @SchizophreniaCa—_I support my son who has |
|
| Indicates a neutral attitude towards people with depression/ schizophrenia | • Our paper on prevalence of | • Symptoms of |
|
| Unwillingness to have social contact with people with depression/ schizophrenia |
| • The Schofield’s are a family that make me feel grateful for my daughter |
|
| Belief that people with depression/schizophrenia are dangerous |
| • Untreated |
|
| Belief that people with depression/schizophrenia could snap out of it | • How low can a person go b4 I can scold the person to wake up get a job get a life? |
|
|
| Belief that depression/schizophrenia is a sign of personal weakness | • #depression is a crisis of confidence |
|
|
| Indicates a lack of knowledge or inaccurate understanding of depression/schizophrenia is. E.g., That schizophrenia refers to having multiple personalities. | • Btw, Katie is my other personality | |
|
| Rude, derogotary, or trivialising towards people with depression/schizophrenia | • Tyson: To get rid of depression you sit in a cupboard and pee your pants! | • @richardrainey you realize that it looks like we are having a twitter conversation with ourselves. |
|
| Indicates that the consumer has internalised a stigmatising attitude towards people with depression/schizophrenia | • Wish it wasn’t so hard to ask for help |
|
Notes.
No tweets identified for this theme.
Figure 1Content of tweets by mental illness.
Figure 2Types of attitudes by mental illness.
Figure 3Types of stigmatising attitudes by mental illness.