Carmelo Cottone1, Cesare Tosetti2, Giuseppe Disclafani1, Enzo Ubaldi3, Rosanna Cogliandro4, Vincenzo Stanghellini4. 1. Italian College of General Practitioners (SIMG), Palermo, Italy. 2. Italian College of General Practitioners (SIMG), Bologna, Italy. 3. Italian College of General Practitioners (SIMG), Ascoli Piceno, Italy. 4. Department of Digestive Diseases and Internal Medicine, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Definition and diagnosis of constipation remain challenging, partly due to different perceptions of the disease by doctors and patients. AIM: To evaluate prevalence and features of constipation among individuals seen in general practice, by comparing different diagnostic instruments. METHODS: Standardized questionnaires and the Bristol stool form scale were distributed to all subjects attending 10 general practitioners for any reason in a 2-week period. The questionnaires investigated constipation defined according to: (1) self-perception (yes/no); (2) a visual analogue scale; (3) Rome III Criteria. RESULTS: The prevalence of constipation in 1306 subjects (790 female, 516 male) resulted: (1) 34% self-reported; (2) 28% by visual analogue scale; (3) 24% by Rome Criteria. Constipation was more frequent in females. A high frequency of symptoms of obstructed defecations was observed with differences among patients with self-reported constipation with or without Bristol stool type 1-2. CONCLUSIONS: Prevalence of constipation among individuals attending their GP ranges between 24 and 34%, according to the different definitions adopted. Symptoms of obstructed defecations are frequent. The combination of self-evaluation and the Bristol stool type scale is potentially useful to identify subgroups of patients with different clinical features in general practice.
BACKGROUND: Definition and diagnosis of constipation remain challenging, partly due to different perceptions of the disease by doctors and patients. AIM: To evaluate prevalence and features of constipation among individuals seen in general practice, by comparing different diagnostic instruments. METHODS: Standardized questionnaires and the Bristol stool form scale were distributed to all subjects attending 10 general practitioners for any reason in a 2-week period. The questionnaires investigated constipation defined according to: (1) self-perception (yes/no); (2) a visual analogue scale; (3) Rome III Criteria. RESULTS: The prevalence of constipation in 1306 subjects (790 female, 516 male) resulted: (1) 34% self-reported; (2) 28% by visual analogue scale; (3) 24% by Rome Criteria. Constipation was more frequent in females. A high frequency of symptoms of obstructed defecations was observed with differences among patients with self-reported constipation with or without Bristol stool type 1-2. CONCLUSIONS: Prevalence of constipation among individuals attending their GP ranges between 24 and 34%, according to the different definitions adopted. Symptoms of obstructed defecations are frequent. The combination of self-evaluation and the Bristol stool type scale is potentially useful to identify subgroups of patients with different clinical features in general practice.
Entities:
Keywords:
Constipation; Rome criteria; epidemiology; general practice; questionnaire
Authors: Greger Lindberg; Saeed S Hamid; Peter Malfertheiner; Ole Ostergaard Thomsen; Luis Bustos Fernandez; James Garisch; Alan Thomson; Khean-Lee Goh; Rakesh Tandon; Suliman Fedail; Benjamin C Y Wong; Aamir Ghafoor Khan; Justus H Krabshuis; Anton LeMair Journal: J Clin Gastroenterol Date: 2011-07 Impact factor: 3.062
Authors: M Bellini; P Alduini; G Bassotti; A Bove; R Bocchini; M P Sormani; P Bruzzi; F Pucciani Journal: Dig Liver Dis Date: 2005-11-02 Impact factor: 4.088
Authors: W F Stewart; J N Liberman; R S Sandler; M S Woods; A Stemhagen; E Chee; R B Lipton; C E Farup Journal: Am J Gastroenterol Date: 1999-12 Impact factor: 10.864
Authors: Nilay D Shah; Denesh K Chitkara; G Richard Locke; Patrick D Meek; Nicholas J Talley Journal: Am J Gastroenterol Date: 2008-06-28 Impact factor: 10.864
Authors: Iris Rijnaarts; Nicole M de Roos; Taojun Wang; Erwin G Zoetendal; Jan Top; Marielle Timmer; Koen Hogenelst; Emily P Bouwman; Ben Witteman; Nicole de Wit Journal: J Nutr Sci Date: 2022-04-28