| Literature DB >> 25270859 |
Emma Kirby1, Alex Broom1, Phillip Good2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Nurses are generally present, and often influential, in supporting patient and family acceptance of medical futility and in assisting doctors in negotiating referral to palliative care. Yet the specificities of the nursing role and how nurses may contribute to timely and effective referrals is not well understood. This study aimed to systematically explore hospital-based nurses' accounts of the transition to palliative care, and the potential role of nurses in facilitating more effective palliative care transitions.Entities:
Keywords: PALLIATIVE CARE; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Mesh:
Year: 2014 PMID: 25270859 PMCID: PMC4179576 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2014-006026
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Indicative quotations
| Participant | Example quotation |
|---|---|
| #9 | I think because us as nursing staff will spend the majority of time with them. Being here as well we do hourly roundings, so we are always in there, like at least every hour if not half-an-hour, doing things for these patients |
| #12 | So from a nursing perspective we're often encouraging early palliative care referrals, and one of the stumbling blocks we get is because often the patients have multiple practitioners involved in their care. So they can have surgeons, medical oncologists and radiation oncologists, it's quite difficult for us to deem who the appropriate person is to make that decision |
| #13 | I actually always go, when I find out a bit about the patient and what support they've got, I will say to the consultant or whoever “have you mentioned palliative care? This person could probably benefit from it. Is it alright if…”—no I just don't ask if it's alright actually |
| I: | And can anyone do that? |
| #13 | Yeah. But I don't know if they're confident enough to do it…And it all depends on the person, how proactive and how confident they feel |
| #14 | The news is just devastating and it's hard for the patient to think about the future, and their family. And it's about trying to look ahead for the future, with increasing disabilities and how they're going to manage that and who's out there, and who can support them. So I think the nurse's role is absolutely crucial, you're chasing a doctor to go in with them to sit down and give news |
Professional roles and relationships: the nursing role in the transition to palliative care.
Indicative quotations
| Participant | Example quotation |
|---|---|
| #17 | To support and listen, and a lot of family support. We give a lot of support to partners and kids. It's just the simplest little question, “how's it going? How are you going?” And I often say “it's just as tough on you isn't it?” And they always say “oh thank god someone's asked me how I’m going!” And then if they need a little bit of help somewhere, refer. That’s what you do. And lots of hugs, we give a lot of hugs here. We do! But lots of listening, I think just listening, active listening… |
| #3 | Lots of talking with patients and making sure everything's connected I guess, that everyone's aware of what they need to be aware of…It's part of nursing, because I’m talking to them, I’m assessing them and looking at how they're going in their day-to-day lives, what their symptoms and side-effects are. But also it's, you know I’m lucky in my role that I can just sit down and spend twenty minutes, half-an-hour, whatever they need, just talking about everything. |
| #18 | So a lot of them we have to explain, even though we say the word “palliative” some people still get quite freaked out about that, and we have to say “but there's various stages of palliative care.” So once you kind of reassure them that look it's just the avenue or the pathway that we're going down now |
| #4 | Because I'm basically the only palliative care nurse here, they [patients/families] all get my phone number. So many of them will ring me just to chat about things, they might start to ring for their pain, but by the end of their conversation they're talking about some of the end-of-life discussions, or their families are. “What can I expect?” you know. “Where do you think we're headed?” |
| #14 | Particularly the partners, the wives, the husbands and the partners. I have an open door policy, and quite often they'll come in and sit in the seat and cry their eyes out. “How am I going to tell our children? What's the best way of telling our children? How am I going to tell his mother?” They're at a total loss, “what can we do about this? Will I need to sell my house? Should I sell my house?” All these things are flowing out, and I give them time to talk through all these kind of issues |
Talking to patients and families: emotional support and effective transitions.
Indicative quotations
| Participant | Example quotation |
|---|---|
| #10 | I think it's better if we interact more with them [patients]. But sometimes the workload hinders us from talking to the doctor, going with a doctor. I think it's better if one of the nurses go on the ward rounds with the doctor so we know what's been said, we get the right information through them [patients] |
| #11 | Yeah I think it definitely takes its toll, especially with heavy workloads. I mean when someone is palliative you want, well every patient you want to do everything you can. But especially when it's coming towards the end and families are upset, you want to be able to sit with them for half-an-hour and just be there for them. But with heavy patient loads you just don't get to, I mean you can offer them cups of tea and that every now and again, but to sit with that one patient for say half-an-hour, it's almost impossible because you have every other patient to consider as well |
| #14 | Sometimes I'm thinking on my feet, because as the [senior nurse] here, I'm thinking “oh god I've got ten minutes and I've got to be elsewhere,” and I know I've really got to be elsewhere with that. But you don't want that person to think they're not getting 100% from you. People are constantly knocking at the door when you're talking to people. But I think it's just important that they know that you're there for them, and you can also give them information and passing them on to the appropriate person |
| #16 | You don't have time to think about it [not being able to answer all of the patient/family questions] because you've got to go to your next patient who might be having curative intent treatment… If you've got someone who's dying with a really you know, family that need a lot of support, yet you're trying to hang a bag of chemo on time, and making sure that your own output is spot on, and then you've got three other patients you have to get out of bed and shower, I mean you're stressed to the max |
Managing task-oriented nursing and supporting patients in transition.
Indicative quotations
| Participant | Example quotation |
|---|---|
| #11 | I find it very hard personally because I think finding the right words to say can be a bit difficult sometimes. I think particularly for the family, just discussing what's important for the patient to discuss with the family, if they're able to discuss with their family what they want, because I think the families can sometimes not take into consideration what the patients want and push for more treatments if the patient doesn't want the treatment. I find that they can be very pushy in that sense. But in terms of bringing it up it is hard…It's tough. I find it really tough |
| #4 | But when it starts to you know, sometimes even the best of palliative care, some doctors are okay with it, but other doctors you know, some people are crying all through their consultation, it takes its toll on them too. Because they don't have anyone to debrief with either |
| #16 | At the time on the ward, you don't have time to think about it because you've got to go to your next patient who might be having curative intent treatment, so you’ve got to be positive. You've got to learn how to respond to things, and be emotional at the appropriate times. If you're happy, you're a happy person, you're in a good mood and you're upbeat, you can't go into that room with a patient who's dying and be smiling “hey how are you all going? Is everyone okay?” because to them it's not. But then you go into the next room, you can't go in there sombre, you need to be positive for that patient without being unrealistic. So it's like you just put on a different mask |
| #6 | I find it really difficult. I'm getting better. I guess the more, in this role I've had more exposure to it so. But you never feel comfortable about having those discussions. I've got siblings that are the age of people, or they're my age that are having treatments. So it's a bit, I'm pretty raw, like if I get upset I'll get upset in front of them. It doesn't worry me, and it doesn't worry them. It shows you care, I think |
| #20 | I’ve seen a couple of young nurses become quite unhinged at an event and I just don't know…I don't feel there's that support for the younger girls anymore, or older girls, or anyone really. And from my perspective yes I do get very upset, but I realise that things come to an end. And the positive is that if I can do everything I can, then that’s great. Because you spend time with the families…It's quite you know, you’ve got to have a bit of downtime |
Emotional work: the burden of managing the transition to palliative care.