BACKGROUND: RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) is the current gold-standard method to quantify gene expression for expression quantitative trait locus (eQTL) studies. However, a potential caveat in these studies is that RNA-seq reads carrying the non-reference allele of variant loci can have lower probability to map correctly to the reference genome, which could bias gene quantifications and cause false positive eQTL associations. In this study, we analyze the effect of this allelic mapping bias in eQTL discovery. RESULTS: We simulate RNA-seq read mapping over 9.5 M common SNPs and indels, with 15.6% of variants showing biased mapping rate for reference versus non-reference reads. However, removing potentially biased RNA-seq reads from an eQTL dataset of 185 individuals has a very small effect on gene and exon quantifications and eQTL discovery. We detect only a handful of likely false positive eQTLs, and overall eQTL SNPs show no significant enrichment for high mapping bias. CONCLUSION: Our results suggest that RNA-seq quantifications are generally robust against allelic mapping bias, and that this does not have a severe effect on eQTL discovery. Nevertheless, we provide our catalog of putatively biased loci to allow better controlling for mapping bias to obtain more accurate results in future RNA-seq studies.
BACKGROUND: RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) is the current gold-standard method to quantify gene expression for expression quantitative trait locus (eQTL) studies. However, a potential caveat in these studies is that RNA-seq reads carrying the non-reference allele of variant loci can have lower probability to map correctly to the reference genome, which could bias gene quantifications and cause false positive eQTL associations. In this study, we analyze the effect of this allelic mapping bias in eQTL discovery. RESULTS: We simulate RNA-seq read mapping over 9.5 M common SNPs and indels, with 15.6% of variants showing biased mapping rate for reference versus non-reference reads. However, removing potentially biased RNA-seq reads from an eQTL dataset of 185 individuals has a very small effect on gene and exon quantifications and eQTL discovery. We detect only a handful of likely false positive eQTLs, and overall eQTL SNPs show no significant enrichment for high mapping bias. CONCLUSION: Our results suggest that RNA-seq quantifications are generally robust against allelic mapping bias, and that this does not have a severe effect on eQTL discovery. Nevertheless, we provide our catalog of putatively biased loci to allow better controlling for mapping bias to obtain more accurate results in future RNA-seq studies.
Authors: E S Lander; L M Linton; B Birren; C Nusbaum; M C Zody; J Baldwin; K Devon; K Dewar; M Doyle; W FitzHugh; R Funke; D Gage; K Harris; A Heaford; J Howland; L Kann; J Lehoczky; R LeVine; P McEwan; K McKernan; J Meldrim; J P Mesirov; C Miranda; W Morris; J Naylor; C Raymond; M Rosetti; R Santos; A Sheridan; C Sougnez; Y Stange-Thomann; N Stojanovic; A Subramanian; D Wyman; J Rogers; J Sulston; R Ainscough; S Beck; D Bentley; J Burton; C Clee; N Carter; A Coulson; R Deadman; P Deloukas; A Dunham; I Dunham; R Durbin; L French; D Grafham; S Gregory; T Hubbard; S Humphray; A Hunt; M Jones; C Lloyd; A McMurray; L Matthews; S Mercer; S Milne; J C Mullikin; A Mungall; R Plumb; M Ross; R Shownkeen; S Sims; R H Waterston; R K Wilson; L W Hillier; J D McPherson; M A Marra; E R Mardis; L A Fulton; A T Chinwalla; K H Pepin; W R Gish; S L Chissoe; M C Wendl; K D Delehaunty; T L Miner; A Delehaunty; J B Kramer; L L Cook; R S Fulton; D L Johnson; P J Minx; S W Clifton; T Hawkins; E Branscomb; P Predki; P Richardson; S Wenning; T Slezak; N Doggett; J F Cheng; A Olsen; S Lucas; C Elkin; E Uberbacher; M Frazier; R A Gibbs; D M Muzny; S E Scherer; J B Bouck; E J Sodergren; K C Worley; C M Rives; J H Gorrell; M L Metzker; S L Naylor; R S Kucherlapati; D L Nelson; G M Weinstock; Y Sakaki; A Fujiyama; M Hattori; T Yada; A Toyoda; T Itoh; C Kawagoe; H Watanabe; Y Totoki; T Taylor; J Weissenbach; R Heilig; W Saurin; F Artiguenave; P Brottier; T Bruls; E Pelletier; C Robert; P Wincker; D R Smith; L Doucette-Stamm; M Rubenfield; K Weinstock; H M Lee; J Dubois; A Rosenthal; M Platzer; G Nyakatura; S Taudien; A Rump; H Yang; J Yu; J Wang; G Huang; J Gu; L Hood; L Rowen; A Madan; S Qin; R W Davis; N A Federspiel; A P Abola; M J Proctor; R M Myers; J Schmutz; M Dickson; J Grimwood; D R Cox; M V Olson; R Kaul; C Raymond; N Shimizu; K Kawasaki; S Minoshima; G A Evans; M Athanasiou; R Schultz; B A Roe; F Chen; H Pan; J Ramser; H Lehrach; R Reinhardt; W R McCombie; M de la Bastide; N Dedhia; H Blöcker; K Hornischer; G Nordsiek; R Agarwala; L Aravind; J A Bailey; A Bateman; S Batzoglou; E Birney; P Bork; D G Brown; C B Burge; L Cerutti; H C Chen; D Church; M Clamp; R R Copley; T Doerks; S R Eddy; E E Eichler; T S Furey; J Galagan; J G Gilbert; C Harmon; Y Hayashizaki; D Haussler; H Hermjakob; K Hokamp; W Jang; L S Johnson; T A Jones; S Kasif; A Kaspryzk; S Kennedy; W J Kent; P Kitts; E V Koonin; I Korf; D Kulp; D Lancet; T M Lowe; A McLysaght; T Mikkelsen; J V Moran; N Mulder; V J Pollara; C P Ponting; G Schuler; J Schultz; G Slater; A F Smit; E Stupka; J Szustakowki; D Thierry-Mieg; J Thierry-Mieg; L Wagner; J Wallis; R Wheeler; A Williams; Y I Wolf; K H Wolfe; S P Yang; R F Yeh; F Collins; M S Guyer; J Peterson; A Felsenfeld; K A Wetterstrand; A Patrinos; M J Morgan; P de Jong; J J Catanese; K Osoegawa; H Shizuya; S Choi; Y J Chen; J Szustakowki Journal: Nature Date: 2001-02-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Eric E Schadt; Stephanie A Monks; Thomas A Drake; Aldons J Lusis; Nam Che; Veronica Colinayo; Thomas G Ruff; Stephen B Milligan; John R Lamb; Guy Cavet; Peter S Linsley; Mao Mao; Roland B Stoughton; Stephen H Friend Journal: Nature Date: 2003-03-20 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Barbara E Stranger; Alexandra C Nica; Matthew S Forrest; Antigone Dimas; Christine P Bird; Claude Beazley; Catherine E Ingle; Mark Dunning; Paul Flicek; Daphne Koller; Stephen Montgomery; Simon Tavaré; Panos Deloukas; Emmanouil T Dermitzakis Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2007-09-16 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Michael Morley; Cliona M Molony; Teresa M Weber; James L Devlin; Kathryn G Ewens; Richard S Spielman; Vivian G Cheung Journal: Nature Date: 2004-07-21 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Helena Kilpinen; Sebastian M Waszak; Andreas R Gschwind; Sunil K Raghav; Robert M Witwicki; Andrea Orioli; Eugenia Migliavacca; Michaël Wiederkehr; Maria Gutierrez-Arcelus; Nikolaos I Panousis; Alisa Yurovsky; Tuuli Lappalainen; Luciana Romano-Palumbo; Alexandra Planchon; Deborah Bielser; Julien Bryois; Ismael Padioleau; Gilles Udin; Sarah Thurnheer; David Hacker; Leighton J Core; John T Lis; Nouria Hernandez; Alexandre Reymond; Bart Deplancke; Emmanouil T Dermitzakis Journal: Science Date: 2013-10-17 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Adaikalavan Ramasamy; Daniah Trabzuni; J Raphael Gibbs; Allissa Dillman; Dena G Hernandez; Sampath Arepalli; Robert Walker; Colin Smith; Gigaloluwa Peter Ilori; Andrey A Shabalin; Yun Li; Andrew B Singleton; Mark R Cookson; John Hardy; Mina Ryten; Michael E Weale Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2013-02-21 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Tuuli Lappalainen; Michael Sammeth; Marc R Friedländer; Peter A C 't Hoen; Jean Monlong; Manuel A Rivas; Mar Gonzàlez-Porta; Natalja Kurbatova; Thasso Griebel; Pedro G Ferreira; Matthias Barann; Thomas Wieland; Liliana Greger; Maarten van Iterson; Jonas Almlöf; Paolo Ribeca; Irina Pulyakhina; Daniela Esser; Thomas Giger; Andrew Tikhonov; Marc Sultan; Gabrielle Bertier; Daniel G MacArthur; Monkol Lek; Esther Lizano; Henk P J Buermans; Ismael Padioleau; Thomas Schwarzmayr; Olof Karlberg; Halit Ongen; Helena Kilpinen; Sergi Beltran; Marta Gut; Katja Kahlem; Vyacheslav Amstislavskiy; Oliver Stegle; Matti Pirinen; Stephen B Montgomery; Peter Donnelly; Mark I McCarthy; Paul Flicek; Tim M Strom; Hans Lehrach; Stefan Schreiber; Ralf Sudbrak; Angel Carracedo; Stylianos E Antonarakis; Robert Häsler; Ann-Christine Syvänen; Gert-Jan van Ommen; Alvis Brazma; Thomas Meitinger; Philip Rosenstiel; Roderic Guigó; Ivo G Gut; Xavier Estivill; Emmanouil T Dermitzakis Journal: Nature Date: 2013-09-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Nicholas B Larson; Shannon McDonnell; Amy J French; Zach Fogarty; John Cheville; Sumit Middha; Shaun Riska; Saurabh Baheti; Asha A Nair; Liang Wang; Daniel J Schaid; Stephen N Thibodeau Journal: Am J Hum Genet Date: 2015-05-14 Impact factor: 11.025
Authors: Matti Pirinen; Tuuli Lappalainen; Noah A Zaitlen; Emmanouil T Dermitzakis; Peter Donnelly; Mark I McCarthy; Manuel A Rivas Journal: Bioinformatics Date: 2015-03-27 Impact factor: 6.937
Authors: Yael Baran; Meena Subramaniam; Anne Biton; Taru Tukiainen; Emily K Tsang; Manuel A Rivas; Matti Pirinen; Maria Gutierrez-Arcelus; Kevin S Smith; Kim R Kukurba; Rui Zhang; Celeste Eng; Dara G Torgerson; Cydney Urbanek; Jin Billy Li; Jose R Rodriguez-Santana; Esteban G Burchard; Max A Seibold; Daniel G MacArthur; Stephen B Montgomery; Noah A Zaitlen; Tuuli Lappalainen Journal: Genome Res Date: 2015-05-07 Impact factor: 9.043