Karla L Hanson1, Leah M Connor1. 1. From the Division of Nutritional Sciences, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Food insecurity is adversely associated with the physical and mental health of adults and children, and the mechanism that underlies this association has been assumed to be dietary intake of lower quality in food insecure than food secure individuals. A thorough understanding of observed associations between food insecurity and dietary quality is needed to test this assumption and may highlight pathways through which to improve the health of food-insecure adults and children. OBJECTIVE: We systematically reviewed all evidence of associations between food insecurity and dietary quality and contrasted associations observed in adults and those for children. DESIGN: Evidence came from studies that appeared in indexed, peer-reviewed journals and 1) sampled US residents, 2) separately sampled children and adults, 3) contained a measure of food insecurity or food insufficiency, and 4) included at least one measure of dietary quality. RESULTS: In adults, 170 associations between food insecurity and dietary quality were tested, and 50 associations (29%) suggested an adverse association. Food-insecure adults consumed fewer vegetables, fruit, and dairy products than did food secure adults and had lower intake of vitamins A and B-6, calcium, magnesium, and zinc. In children, 130 associations were tested, and 21 associations (16%) showed an adverse association. There was substantial evidence of only lower fruit consumption in food-insecure compared with food-secure children. Reporting and publication biases may have contributed to an overestimation of the association between food insecurity and dietary quality. CONCLUSIONS: Food insecurity is adversely associated with dietary quality in adults, particularly intakes of nutrient-rich vegetables, fruit, and dairy that promote good health. However, food insecurity was less-consistently associated with lower dietary quality in children. The idea that parents effectively shield their children from compromised dietary quality because of food shortages is supported by the evidence.
BACKGROUND: Food insecurity is adversely associated with the physical and mental health of adults and children, and the mechanism that underlies this association has been assumed to be dietary intake of lower quality in food insecure than food secure individuals. A thorough understanding of observed associations between food insecurity and dietary quality is needed to test this assumption and may highlight pathways through which to improve the health of food-insecure adults and children. OBJECTIVE: We systematically reviewed all evidence of associations between food insecurity and dietary quality and contrasted associations observed in adults and those for children. DESIGN: Evidence came from studies that appeared in indexed, peer-reviewed journals and 1) sampled US residents, 2) separately sampled children and adults, 3) contained a measure of food insecurity or food insufficiency, and 4) included at least one measure of dietary quality. RESULTS: In adults, 170 associations between food insecurity and dietary quality were tested, and 50 associations (29%) suggested an adverse association. Food-insecure adults consumed fewer vegetables, fruit, and dairy products than did food secure adults and had lower intake of vitamins A and B-6, calcium, magnesium, and zinc. In children, 130 associations were tested, and 21 associations (16%) showed an adverse association. There was substantial evidence of only lower fruit consumption in food-insecure compared with food-secure children. Reporting and publication biases may have contributed to an overestimation of the association between food insecurity and dietary quality. CONCLUSIONS: Food insecurity is adversely associated with dietary quality in adults, particularly intakes of nutrient-rich vegetables, fruit, and dairy that promote good health. However, food insecurity was less-consistently associated with lower dietary quality in children. The idea that parents effectively shield their children from compromised dietary quality because of food shortages is supported by the evidence.
Authors: Rebecca L Rivera; Yumin Zhang; Qi Wang; Melissa K Maulding; Janet A Tooze; Breanne N Wright; Bruce A Craig; Regan L Bailey; Heather A Eicher-Miller Journal: J Nutr Date: 2020-08-01 Impact factor: 4.798
Authors: Kelsey A Vercammen; Alyssa J Moran; Amanda C McClain; Anne N Thorndike; Aarohee P Fulay; Eric B Rimm Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2019-03-16 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: Trina L Gipson-Jones; LaToya J OʼNeal; Jylana L Sheats; Roland J Thorpe; Bettina M Beech; Marino A Bruce Journal: Fam Community Health Date: 2019 Apr/Jun
Authors: Michael P Burke; Lauren H Martini; Christine E Blake; Nicholas A Younginer; Carrie L Draper; Bethany A Bell; Angela D Liese; Sonya J Jones Journal: J Nutr Educ Behav Date: 2017-01-07 Impact factor: 3.045