Literature DB >> 24868070

Making short-term international medical volunteer placements work: a qualitative study.

Omnia Elnawawy1, Andrew C K Lee2, Gerda Pohl3.   

Abstract

BACKGROUND: International medical volunteering has grown in recent decades. It has the potential to benefit and harm the volunteer and host countries; but there is a paucity of literature on the impacts of international medical volunteering and a need to find ways to optimise the benefits of such placements. AIM: In this study, one example of international medical volunteering was examined involving British GPs on short-term placements in Nepal. The intention was to explore the expectations and experiences of the local health workers, volunteers, and host organisation to try and understand what makes volunteer placements work.
DESIGN: Qualitative study of key informant interviews.
SETTING: Stakeholders of a short-term international medical volunteer (IMV) placement programme in Nepal.
METHOD: Key informant interviews were carried out via face-to-face or telephone/internet interviews with five previous volunteers, three representatives from a non-governmental organisation providing placements, and five local health workers in Nepal who had had contact with the IMVs. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analysed using standard thematic framework approaches.
RESULTS: All the stakeholders had their own specific motives for participating in the IMV programme. The relationship between volunteers and the Nepalese health workers was complex and characterised by discrepant and occasionally unrealistic expectations. Managing these different expectations was challenging.
CONCLUSION: Contextual issues and cultural differences are important considerations in medical volunteer programmes, and this study highlights the importance of robust preparation pre-placement for the volunteer and host to ensure positive outcomes. © British Journal of General Practice 2014.

Keywords:  international educational exchange; medical tourism; volunteerism

Mesh:

Year:  2014        PMID: 24868070      PMCID: PMC4032015          DOI: 10.3399/bjgp14X680101

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Br J Gen Pract        ISSN: 0960-1643            Impact factor:   5.386


  14 in total

1.  Medical tourism can do harm.

Authors:  Rachel Bishop; James A Litch
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2000-04-08

Review 2.  Expanding the boundaries of medical education: evidence for cross-cultural exchanges.

Authors:  Ian S Mutchnick; Cheryl A Moyer; David T Stern
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  2003-10       Impact factor: 6.893

Review 3.  The impact of international placements on nurses' personal and professional lives: literature review.

Authors:  Lori Button; Barbara Green; Cassam Tengnah; Inez Johansson; Christine Baker
Journal:  J Adv Nurs       Date:  2005-05       Impact factor: 3.187

4.  Volunteering overseas--lessons from surgical brigades.

Authors:  Adam J Wolfberg
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  2006-02-02       Impact factor: 91.245

5.  Twelve tips for effective international clinical placements.

Authors:  Susan Balandin; Michelle Lincoln; Reena Sen; David P Wilkins; David Trembath
Journal:  Med Teach       Date:  2007-11       Impact factor: 3.650

6.  Fly-By medical care: Conceptualizing the global and local social responsibilities of medical tourists and physician voluntourists.

Authors:  Jeremy Snyder; Shafik Dharamsi; Valorie A Crooks
Journal:  Global Health       Date:  2011-04-06       Impact factor: 4.185

7.  A model for sustainable short-term international medical trips.

Authors:  Parminder Suchdev; Kym Ahrens; Eleanor Click; Lori Macklin; Doris Evangelista; Elinor Graham
Journal:  Ambul Pediatr       Date:  2007 Jul-Aug

8.  The contribution of international health volunteers to the health workforce in sub-Saharan Africa.

Authors:  Geert Laleman; Guy Kegels; Bruno Marchal; Dirk Van der Roost; Isa Bogaert; Wim Van Damme
Journal:  Hum Resour Health       Date:  2007-07-31

9.  Short-term visits by eye care professionals: ensuring greater benefit to the host community.

Authors:  Andy Pyott
Journal:  Community Eye Health       Date:  2008-12

10.  Perceptions of short-term medical volunteer work: a qualitative study in Guatemala.

Authors:  Tyler Green; Heidi Green; Jean Scandlyn; Andrew Kestler
Journal:  Global Health       Date:  2009-02-26       Impact factor: 4.185

View more
  10 in total

1.  Boost or burden? Issues posed by short placements in resource-poor settings.

Authors:  Jon Dowell; Claire Blacklock; Catherine Liao; Neil Merrylees
Journal:  Br J Gen Pract       Date:  2014-06       Impact factor: 5.386

2.  Effective practices of international volunteering for health: perspectives from partner organizations.

Authors:  Benjamin J Lough; Rebecca Tiessen; Judith N Lasker
Journal:  Global Health       Date:  2018-01-24       Impact factor: 4.185

3.  Common Illnesses in Tropical Asia and Significance of Medical Volunteering.

Authors:  Chai Hong Rim; Chang Won Lee; Young Soo Heo; Rinet Aieng; Sung Yeon Jun; Sung Hun Choi; Jae Suk Rim
Journal:  Open Med (Wars)       Date:  2018-07-30

4.  A Comprehensive Framework to Optimize Short-Term Experiences in Global Health (STEGH).

Authors:  Shivani Shah; Henry C Lin; Lawrence C Loh
Journal:  Global Health       Date:  2019-04-02       Impact factor: 4.185

5.  The Impact of an International Elective on Anesthesiology Residents as Assessed by a Longitudinal Study.

Authors:  Lena Dohlman; Matthew DiMeglio; Krzysztof Laudanski
Journal:  J Med Educ Curric Dev       Date:  2019-09-20

6.  More harm than good? The questionable ethics of medical volunteering and international student placements.

Authors:  Irmgard Bauer
Journal:  Trop Dis Travel Med Vaccines       Date:  2017-03-06

Review 7.  The 'triple win' practice: the importance of organizational support for volunteer endeavors undertaken by health care professionals and staff.

Authors:  Dilani Logan; Lawrence C Loh; Vivian Huang
Journal:  J Glob Health       Date:  2018-06       Impact factor: 4.413

8.  Research articles on volunteering in biomedical journals: a MEDLINE-based bibliometric analysis.

Authors:  Bo-Ren Cheng; Hsiao-Ting Chang; Ming-Hwai Lin; Tzeng-Ji Chen; Li-Fang Chou; Shinn-Jang Hwang
Journal:  J Int Med Res       Date:  2020-02       Impact factor: 1.671

9.  A questionnaire study of the negative outcomes for UK health professional volunteers in low and middle income countries.

Authors:  Natasha Tyler; Helen Louise Ackers; Anya Ahmed; Ged Byrne; Lucie Byrne-Davis
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2020-06-15       Impact factor: 2.692

10.  Assessment of Local Health Worker Attitudes toward International Medical Volunteers in Low- and Middle-income Countries: A Global Survey.

Authors:  Crystal Bae; Nehal Naik; Monika Misak; Sean L Barnes; Avelino C Verceles; Alfred Papali; Michael T McCurdy; Lia I Losonczy
Journal:  J Epidemiol Glob Health       Date:  2020-09
  10 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.