OBJECTIVE: To establish applicability, the recently proposed International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) consensus on drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) requires testing in clinical and research settings. This study evaluates the reliability and validity of these criteria in a clinical population. METHODS: In phase I, two independent evaluators reviewed 97 randomly selected medical records of patients with epilepsy at two separate intervals. Both ILEA consensus and standard diagnostic criteria were employed. Kappa, weighted kappa, and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were used to determine interobserver and intraobserver variability. In phase II, ILAE consensus criteria were applied to 250 patients with epilepsy to determine risk factors associated with development of DRE and to calculate point prevalence. RESULTS: The interobserver agreement of the four definitions was as follows: Berg (0.56), Kwan and Brodie (0.58), Camfield and Camfield (0.69), and ILAE (0.77). The intraobserver agreement of the four definition was as follows: Berg (0.81), Kwan and Brodie (0.82), Camfield and Camfield (0.72), and ILAE (0.82). The prevalence of DRE was the following: with the Berg's definition was 28.4%, Kwan and Brodie 34%, Camfield and Camfield 37%, and with ILAE was 33%. SIGNIFICANCE: This is first study to establish reliability and validity of ILAE criteria for the diagnosis of DRE. This new definition compares favorably with previously established constructs, which continue to retain clinical significance. Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
OBJECTIVE: To establish applicability, the recently proposed International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) consensus on drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) requires testing in clinical and research settings. This study evaluates the reliability and validity of these criteria in a clinical population. METHODS: In phase I, two independent evaluators reviewed 97 randomly selected medical records of patients with epilepsy at two separate intervals. Both ILEA consensus and standard diagnostic criteria were employed. Kappa, weighted kappa, and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were used to determine interobserver and intraobserver variability. In phase II, ILAE consensus criteria were applied to 250 patients with epilepsy to determine risk factors associated with development of DRE and to calculate point prevalence. RESULTS: The interobserver agreement of the four definitions was as follows: Berg (0.56), Kwan and Brodie (0.58), Camfield and Camfield (0.69), and ILAE (0.77). The intraobserver agreement of the four definition was as follows: Berg (0.81), Kwan and Brodie (0.82), Camfield and Camfield (0.72), and ILAE (0.82). The prevalence of DRE was the following: with the Berg's definition was 28.4%, Kwan and Brodie 34%, Camfield and Camfield 37%, and with ILAE was 33%. SIGNIFICANCE: This is first study to establish reliability and validity of ILAE criteria for the diagnosis of DRE. This new definition compares favorably with previously established constructs, which continue to retain clinical significance. Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Authors: Vejay N Vakharia; Rachel Sparks; Roman Rodionov; Sjoerd B Vos; Christian Dorfer; Jonathan Miller; Daniel Nilsson; Martin Tisdall; Stefan Wolfsberger; Andrew W McEvoy; Anna Miserocchi; Gavin P Winston; Aidan G O'Keeffe; Sebastien Ourselin; John S Duncan Journal: J Neurosurg Date: 2018-04-01 Impact factor: 5.115
Authors: Heidrun Potschka; Andrea Fischer; Wolfgang Löscher; Ned Patterson; Sofie Bhatti; Mette Berendt; Luisa De Risio; Robyn Farquhar; Sam Long; Paul Mandigers; Kaspar Matiasek; Karen Muñana; Akos Pakozdy; Jacques Penderis; Simon Platt; Michael Podell; Clare Rusbridge; Veronika Stein; Andrea Tipold; Holger A Volk Journal: BMC Vet Res Date: 2015-08-28 Impact factor: 2.741