Jody Hoffer Gittell1, Joanne Beswick, Don Goldmann, Stanley S Wallack. 1. Jody Hoffer Gittell, PhD, is Professor, Executive Director, Relational Coordination Research Collaborative, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts. E-mail: jodyhoffergittell@brandeis.edu. Joanne Beswick, MS, MA, is Research Program Manager, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts. Don Goldmann, MD, is Chief Medical and Scientific Officer, Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Stanley S. Wallack, PhD, is Professor, Executive Director, Schneider Institutes for Health Policy, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: To deliver greater value in the accountable care context, the Institute of Medicine argues for a culture of teamwork at multiple levels--across professional and organizational siloes and with patients and their families and communities. The logic of performance improvement is that data are needed to target interventions and to assess their impact. We argue that efforts to build teamwork will benefit from teamwork measures that provide diagnostic information regarding the current state and teamwork interventions that can respond to the opportunities identified in the current state. PURPOSE: We identify teamwork measures and teamwork interventions that are validated and that can work across multiple levels of teamwork. We propose specific ways to combine them for optimal effectiveness. APPROACH: We review measures of teamwork documented by Valentine, Nembhard, and Edmondson and select those that they identified as satisfying the four criteria for psychometric validation and as being unbounded and therefore able to measure teamwork across multiple levels. We then consider teamwork interventions that are widely used in the U.S. health care context, are well validated based on their association with outcomes, and are capable of working at multiple levels of teamwork. We select the top candidate in each category and propose ways to combine them for optimal effectiveness. FINDINGS: We find relational coordination is a validated multilevel teamwork measure and TeamSTEPPS® is a validated multilevel teamwork intervention and propose specific ways for the relational coordination measure to enhance the TeamSTEPPS intervention. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: Health care systems and change agents seeking to respond to the challenges of accountable care can use TeamSTEPPS as a validated multilevel teamwork intervention methodology, enhanced by relational coordination as a validated multilevel teamwork measure with diagnostic capacity to pinpoint opportunities for improving teamwork along specific dimensions (e.g., shared knowledge, timely communication) and in specific role relationships (e.g., nurse/medical assistant, emergency unit/medical unit, primary care/specialty care).
BACKGROUND: To deliver greater value in the accountable care context, the Institute of Medicine argues for a culture of teamwork at multiple levels--across professional and organizational siloes and with patients and their families and communities. The logic of performance improvement is that data are needed to target interventions and to assess their impact. We argue that efforts to build teamwork will benefit from teamwork measures that provide diagnostic information regarding the current state and teamwork interventions that can respond to the opportunities identified in the current state. PURPOSE: We identify teamwork measures and teamwork interventions that are validated and that can work across multiple levels of teamwork. We propose specific ways to combine them for optimal effectiveness. APPROACH: We review measures of teamwork documented by Valentine, Nembhard, and Edmondson and select those that they identified as satisfying the four criteria for psychometric validation and as being unbounded and therefore able to measure teamwork across multiple levels. We then consider teamwork interventions that are widely used in the U.S. health care context, are well validated based on their association with outcomes, and are capable of working at multiple levels of teamwork. We select the top candidate in each category and propose ways to combine them for optimal effectiveness. FINDINGS: We find relational coordination is a validated multilevel teamwork measure and TeamSTEPPS® is a validated multilevel teamwork intervention and propose specific ways for the relational coordination measure to enhance the TeamSTEPPS intervention. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: Health care systems and change agents seeking to respond to the challenges of accountable care can use TeamSTEPPS as a validated multilevel teamwork intervention methodology, enhanced by relational coordination as a validated multilevel teamwork measure with diagnostic capacity to pinpoint opportunities for improving teamwork along specific dimensions (e.g., shared knowledge, timely communication) and in specific role relationships (e.g., nurse/medical assistant, emergency unit/medical unit, primary care/specialty care).
Authors: Rachael N Martinez; Timothy P Hogan; Salva Balbale; Keshonna Lones; Barry Goldstein; Christine Woo; Bridget M Smith Journal: Telemed J E Health Date: 2017-01-09 Impact factor: 3.536
Authors: Stephen M Shortell; Bing Ying Poon; Patricia P Ramsay; Hector P Rodriguez; Susan L Ivey; Thomas Huber; Jeremy Rich; Tom Summerfelt Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2017-02-03 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Jennifer K Walter; Douglas Hill; William A Drust; Amy Lisanti; Aaron DeWitt; Amanda Seelhorst; Ma Luisa Hasiuk; Robert Arnold; Chris Feudtner Journal: J Pain Symptom Manage Date: 2022-03-23 Impact factor: 5.576
Authors: Danielle F Loeb; Samantha Pelican Monson; Steven Lockhart; Cori Depue; Evette Ludman; Donald E Nease; Ingrid A Binswanger; Danielle M Kline; Frank V de Gruy; Dixie G Good; Elizabeth A Bayliss Journal: BMC Psychiatry Date: 2019-10-15 Impact factor: 3.630
Authors: Katherine B Valenziano; Susan A Glod; Sharon Jia; Andrew Belser; Brent Brazell; Cheryl Dellasega; Linda Duncan; Michelle Farnan; Paul Haidet; Jan Phillips; Daniel Wolpaw; Peter W Dillon Journal: MedEdPORTAL Date: 2018-03-22
Authors: Pranavi V Sreeramoju; Tara N Palmore; Grace M Lee; Michael B Edmond; Jan E Patterson; Kent A Sepkowitz; Donald A Goldmann; David K Henderson; Keith S Kaye Journal: Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol Date: 2020-09-04 Impact factor: 3.254