Paul A Sutton1, John Mason2, Dale Vimalachandran1, Scarlett McNally3. 1. Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, United Kingdom; Countess of Chester Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Chester, United Kingdom. 2. Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, United Kingdom. 3. Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, United Kingdom; East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust, Sussex, United Kingdom. Electronic address: smcnally@rcseng.ac.uk.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Numerous factors influence the career choices of undergraduate medical students, although little work has focused specifically on the surgical specialties. We aimed to investigate medical students' early experiences of surgery along with the motivators and barriers to selecting a surgical career. METHODS: All final-year medical students were invited to participate in an online survey. A range of quantitative data (expressed as a proportion of total respondents) and qualitative data (grouped and thematically analyzed) were collected to evaluate students' attitudes to careers in surgery and potential influences on these. RESULTS: A total of 482 students from 20 medical schools throughout England and Wales completed the survey. Overall, 91% of respondents had work experience before medical school, in which the greatest satisfaction was reported in the 21% who undertook placements in surgery. In addition, 58% expressed a desire to spend time working abroad and 59% to undertake a period of research; the primary motivator for both was career/professional development. Surgery was the most popular career choice amongst respondents. The 2 most important factors in decisions pertaining to their career were reported as interest in the specialty and work-life balance. Students draw career advice from numerous sources, most commonly mentors (49%) and student surgical societies (46%). Only 1% wanted more website information, with personal contact being paramount. DISCUSSION: It is vital for the continuing strength of the profession and the quality of surgery for the public that we continue to attract the best undergraduates into careers in surgery. Surgeons of all grades must be aware that how they are perceived by students affects future career choices. Early experiences of surgery are fundamental in assisting medical students to make informed career choices.
INTRODUCTION: Numerous factors influence the career choices of undergraduate medical students, although little work has focused specifically on the surgical specialties. We aimed to investigate medical students' early experiences of surgery along with the motivators and barriers to selecting a surgical career. METHODS: All final-year medical students were invited to participate in an online survey. A range of quantitative data (expressed as a proportion of total respondents) and qualitative data (grouped and thematically analyzed) were collected to evaluate students' attitudes to careers in surgery and potential influences on these. RESULTS: A total of 482 students from 20 medical schools throughout England and Wales completed the survey. Overall, 91% of respondents had work experience before medical school, in which the greatest satisfaction was reported in the 21% who undertook placements in surgery. In addition, 58% expressed a desire to spend time working abroad and 59% to undertake a period of research; the primary motivator for both was career/professional development. Surgery was the most popular career choice amongst respondents. The 2 most important factors in decisions pertaining to their career were reported as interest in the specialty and work-life balance. Students draw career advice from numerous sources, most commonly mentors (49%) and student surgical societies (46%). Only 1% wanted more website information, with personal contact being paramount. DISCUSSION: It is vital for the continuing strength of the profession and the quality of surgery for the public that we continue to attract the best undergraduates into careers in surgery. Surgeons of all grades must be aware that how they are perceived by students affects future career choices. Early experiences of surgery are fundamental in assisting medical students to make informed career choices.
Keywords:
Interpersonal and Communication Skills; Patient Care; Practice-Based Learning and Improvement; Professionalism; career; medical student; surgery; undergraduate
Authors: E Kay-Rivest; N Varma; G M Scott; J J Manoukian; M Desrosiers; J P Vaccani; L H P Nguyen Journal: J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 2017-02-27
Authors: Amal Thomas; Aasim Nisar Murtaza; Harry Victor Michael Spiers; Alexander Zargaran; Mohammed Turki; Jai Mathur; Akiko Fukui; David Zargaran; Omar Khan Journal: Ann Med Surg (Lond) Date: 2018-11-10
Authors: Kristian Nikolaus Schneider; Max Masthoff; Georg Gosheger; Nikolas Schopow; Jan Christoph Theil; Bernhard Marschall; Jürgen Zehrfeld Journal: Chirurg Date: 2020-11 Impact factor: 0.955