F Harrisberger1, K Spalek2, R Smieskova1, A Schmidt1, D Coynel3, A Milnik4, M Fastenrath2, V Freytag4, L Gschwind2, A Walter5, T Vogel5, K Bendfeldt6, D J-F de Quervain7, A Papassotiropoulos8, S Borgwardt9. 1. University of Basel, Department of Psychiatry (UPK), Wilhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4056 Basel, Switzerland; University Hospital Basel, Medical Image Analysis Center, Schanzenstrasse 55, 4031 Basel, Switzerland. 2. University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland. 3. University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Molecular Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland. 4. University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Molecular Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland. 5. University of Basel, Department of Psychiatry (UPK), Wilhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4056 Basel, Switzerland. 6. University Hospital Basel, Medical Image Analysis Center, Schanzenstrasse 55, 4031 Basel, Switzerland. 7. University of Basel, Department of Psychiatry (UPK), Wilhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4056 Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland. 8. University of Basel, Department of Psychiatry (UPK), Wilhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4056 Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, Department of Psychology, Division of Molecular Neuroscience, Birmannsgasse 8, 4055 Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, Department Biozentrum, Life Science Training Facility, Klingelbergstrasse 50/70, 4056 Basel, Switzerland. 9. University of Basel, Department of Psychiatry (UPK), Wilhelm Klein-Strasse 27, 4056 Basel, Switzerland; University Hospital Basel, Medical Image Analysis Center, Schanzenstrasse 55, 4031 Basel, Switzerland; King's College London, Department of Psychosis Studies, Institute of Psychiatry, De Crespigny Park 16, SE5 8AF London, UK. Electronic address: stefan.borgwardt@upkbs.ch.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) Val66Met polymorphism (refSNP Cluster Report: rs6265) is a common and functionally relevant single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). The gene itself, as well as the SNP rs6265, have been implicated in hippocampal learning and memory. However, imaging genetic studies have produced controversial results about the impact of this SNP on hippocampal volumes in healthy subjects. METHODS: We examined the association between the rs6265 polymorphism and hippocampal volume in 643 healthy young subjects using automatic segmentation and subsequently included these data in a meta-analysis based on published studies with 5298 healthy subjects in total. RESULTS: We found no significant association between SNP rs6265 and hippocampal volumes in our sample (g=0.05, p=0.58). The meta-analysis revealed a small, albeit significant difference in hippocampal volumes between genotype groups, such that Met-carriers had slightly smaller hippocampal volumes than Val/Val homozygotes (g=0.09, p=0.04), an association that was only evident when manual (g=0.22, p=0.01) but not automatic tracing approaches (g=0.04, p=0.38) were used. Studies using manual tracing showed evidence for publication bias and a significant decrease in effect size over the years with increasing sample sizes. CONCLUSIONS: This study does not support the association between SNP rs6265 and hippocampal volume in healthy individuals. The weakly significant effect observed in the meta-analysis is mainly driven by studies with small sample sizes. In contrast, our original data and the meta-analysis of automatically segmented hippocampal volumes, which was based on studies with large samples sizes, revealed no significant genotype effect. Thus, meta-analyses of the association between rs6265 and hippocampal volumes should consider possible biases related to measuring technique and sample size.
BACKGROUND: The brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) Val66Met polymorphism (refSNP Cluster Report: rs6265) is a common and functionally relevant single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). The gene itself, as well as the SNP rs6265, have been implicated in hippocampal learning and memory. However, imaging genetic studies have produced controversial results about the impact of this SNP on hippocampal volumes in healthy subjects. METHODS: We examined the association between the rs6265 polymorphism and hippocampal volume in 643 healthy young subjects using automatic segmentation and subsequently included these data in a meta-analysis based on published studies with 5298 healthy subjects in total. RESULTS: We found no significant association between SNP rs6265 and hippocampal volumes in our sample (g=0.05, p=0.58). The meta-analysis revealed a small, albeit significant difference in hippocampal volumes between genotype groups, such that Met-carriers had slightly smaller hippocampal volumes than Val/Val homozygotes (g=0.09, p=0.04), an association that was only evident when manual (g=0.22, p=0.01) but not automatic tracing approaches (g=0.04, p=0.38) were used. Studies using manual tracing showed evidence for publication bias and a significant decrease in effect size over the years with increasing sample sizes. CONCLUSIONS: This study does not support the association between SNP rs6265 and hippocampal volume in healthy individuals. The weakly significant effect observed in the meta-analysis is mainly driven by studies with small sample sizes. In contrast, our original data and the meta-analysis of automatically segmented hippocampal volumes, which was based on studies with large samples sizes, revealed no significant genotype effect. Thus, meta-analyses of the association between rs6265 and hippocampal volumes should consider possible biases related to measuring technique and sample size.
Authors: Lachlan T Strike; Baptiste Couvy-Duchesne; Narelle K Hansell; Gabriel Cuellar-Partida; Sarah E Medland; Margaret J Wright Journal: Neuropsychol Rev Date: 2015-03-14 Impact factor: 7.444
Authors: J P Hayes; A Reagan; M W Logue; S M Hayes; N Sadeh; D R Miller; M Verfaellie; E J Wolf; R E McGlinchey; W P Milberg; A Stone; S A Schichman; M W Miller Journal: Genes Brain Behav Date: 2017-08-30 Impact factor: 3.449
Authors: Kaja K Jasińska; Peter J Molfese; Sergey A Kornilov; W Einar Mencl; Stephen J Frost; Maria Lee; Kenneth R Pugh; Elena L Grigorenko; Nicole Landi Journal: Behav Brain Res Date: 2017-03-27 Impact factor: 3.332
Authors: Nicolai Franzmeier; Jinyi Ren; Alexander Damm; Gemma Monté-Rubio; Mercè Boada; Agustín Ruiz; Alfredo Ramirez; Frank Jessen; Emrah Düzel; Octavio Rodríguez Gómez; Tammie Benzinger; Alison Goate; Celeste M Karch; Anne M Fagan; Eric McDade; Katharina Buerger; Johannes Levin; Marco Duering; Martin Dichgans; Marc Suárez-Calvet; Christian Haass; Brian A Gordon; Yen Ying Lim; Colin L Masters; Daniel Janowitz; Cihan Catak; Steffen Wolfsgruber; Michael Wagner; Esther Milz; Sonia Moreno-Grau; Stefan Teipel; Michel J Grothe; Ingo Kilimann; Martin Rossor; Nick Fox; Christoph Laske; Jasmeer Chhatwal; Peter Falkai; Robert Perneczky; Jae-Hong Lee; Annika Spottke; Henning Boecker; Frederic Brosseron; Klaus Fliessbach; Michael T Heneka; Peter Nestor; Oliver Peters; Manuel Fuentes; Felix Menne; Josef Priller; Eike J Spruth; Christiana Franke; Anja Schneider; Christine Westerteicher; Oliver Speck; Jens Wiltfang; Claudia Bartels; Miguel Ángel Araque Caballero; Coraline Metzger; Daniel Bittner; Stephen Salloway; Adrian Danek; Jason Hassenstab; Igor Yakushev; Peter R Schofield; John C Morris; Randall J Bateman; Michael Ewers Journal: Mol Psychiatry Date: 2019-03-21 Impact factor: 15.992
Authors: Amanda L Rodrigue; Aaron F Alexander-Bloch; Emma E M Knowles; Samuel R Mathias; Josephine Mollon; Marinka M G Koenis; Nora I Perrone-Bizzozero; Laura Almasy; Jessica A Turner; Vince D Calhoun; David C Glahn Journal: Cereb Cortex Date: 2020-07-30 Impact factor: 5.357
Authors: Anthony O Ahmed; Samantha Kramer; Naama Hofman; John Flynn; Marie Hansen; Victoria Martin; Anilkumar Pillai; Peter F Buckley Journal: Neuropsychobiology Date: 2021-03-11 Impact factor: 2.328