Ronald G Tompkins1. 1. From the Department of Surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: This review explores the series of published analyses from Massachusetts General Hospital to better understand how changes in medical specialization of burn medicine likely enabled the most important increase in survival from burns in the past 70 years. BACKGROUND: Seventy years ago, survival from the most serious burn injuries was not possible even in the most advanced countries until critical advances were introduced. Insights into those few medical advances that actually impacted survival might be better understood from the consideration of a continuous series of survival analyses over 7 decades at Massachusetts General Hospital. METHODS: Mortality data from previously reported probit and logit analyses from thousands of patients treated at Massachusetts General Hospital were reviewed. A comparison of mortality from these prior mortality analyses from a more recent multicenter study and a national data set was performed. RESULTS: The only giant leap forward in survival occurred during the 1970s, with no improvement during either the preceding or subsequent 30-year intervals. Despite the many modern advances that have been added to the care of these patients since 1984, although these may have represented medical progress, these advances did not impact survival. CONCLUSIONS: Survival rates from burn injury may have been maximized by current treatment approaches within medical centers of excellence in burn medicine. Further efforts to improve the quality of life of survivors of burn injury should ultimately have very favorable impact upon the long-term outcomes in these patients who now survive such devastating injuries.
OBJECTIVE: This review explores the series of published analyses from Massachusetts General Hospital to better understand how changes in medical specialization of burn medicine likely enabled the most important increase in survival from burns in the past 70 years. BACKGROUND: Seventy years ago, survival from the most serious burn injuries was not possible even in the most advanced countries until critical advances were introduced. Insights into those few medical advances that actually impacted survival might be better understood from the consideration of a continuous series of survival analyses over 7 decades at Massachusetts General Hospital. METHODS: Mortality data from previously reported probit and logit analyses from thousands of patients treated at Massachusetts General Hospital were reviewed. A comparison of mortality from these prior mortality analyses from a more recent multicenter study and a national data set was performed. RESULTS: The only giant leap forward in survival occurred during the 1970s, with no improvement during either the preceding or subsequent 30-year intervals. Despite the many modern advances that have been added to the care of these patients since 1984, although these may have represented medical progress, these advances did not impact survival. CONCLUSIONS: Survival rates from burn injury may have been maximized by current treatment approaches within medical centers of excellence in burn medicine. Further efforts to improve the quality of life of survivors of burn injury should ultimately have very favorable impact upon the long-term outcomes in these patients who now survive such devastating injuries.
Authors: Joseph Cuschieri; Jeffrey L Johnson; Jason Sperry; Michael A West; Ernest E Moore; Joseph P Minei; Paul E Bankey; Avery B Nathens; Alex G Cuenca; Philip A Efron; Laura Hennessy; Wenzhong Xiao; Michael N Mindrinos; Grace P McDonald-Smith; Philip H Mason; Timothy R Billiar; David A Schoenfeld; H Shaw Warren; J Perren Cobb; Lyle L Moldawer; Ronald W Davis; Ronald V Maier; Ronald G Tompkins Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2012-05 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: R G Tompkins; J P Remensnyder; J F Burke; D M Tompkins; J F Hilton; D A Schoenfeld; G E Behringer; C C Bondoc; S E Briggs; W C Quinby Journal: Ann Surg Date: 1988-11 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Junhee Seok; H Shaw Warren; Alex G Cuenca; Michael N Mindrinos; Henry V Baker; Weihong Xu; Daniel R Richards; Grace P McDonald-Smith; Hong Gao; Laura Hennessy; Celeste C Finnerty; Cecilia M López; Shari Honari; Ernest E Moore; Joseph P Minei; Joseph Cuschieri; Paul E Bankey; Jeffrey L Johnson; Jason Sperry; Avery B Nathens; Timothy R Billiar; Michael A West; Marc G Jeschke; Matthew B Klein; Richard L Gamelli; Nicole S Gibran; Bernard H Brownstein; Carol Miller-Graziano; Steve E Calvano; Philip H Mason; J Perren Cobb; Laurence G Rahme; Stephen F Lowry; Ronald V Maier; Lyle L Moldawer; David N Herndon; Ronald W Davis; Wenzhong Xiao; Ronald G Tompkins Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2013-02-11 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Paul Wurzer; Ludwik K Branski; Marc G Jeschke; Arham Ali; Michael P Kinsky; Fredrick J Bohanon; Gabriel Hundeshagen; William B Norbury; Felicia N Williams; Lars-P Kamolz; Celeste C Finnerty; David N Herndon Journal: Shock Date: 2016-09 Impact factor: 3.454
Authors: Paula D Strassle; Felicia N Williams; Sonia Napravnik; David van Duin; David J Weber; Anthony Charles; Bruce A Cairns; Samuel W Jones Journal: J Burn Care Res Date: 2017 May/Jun Impact factor: 1.845
Authors: Randy D Kearns; Amanda P Bettencourt; William L Hickerson; Tina L Palmieri; Paul D Biddinger; Colleen M Ryan; James C Jeng Journal: J Burn Care Res Date: 2020-07-03 Impact factor: 1.845
Authors: Bong-Sung Kim; Christian Stoppe; Gerrit Grieb; Lin Leng; Maor Sauler; David Assis; David Simons; Arne Hendrick Boecker; Wibke Schulte; Marta Piecychna; Stephan Hager; Jürgen Bernhagen; Norbert Pallua; Richard Bucala Journal: Burns Date: 2016-05-18 Impact factor: 2.744
Authors: Kristo Nuutila; Josh Grolman; Lu Yang; Michael Broomhead; Stuart Lipsitz; Andrew Onderdonk; David Mooney; Elof Eriksson Journal: Adv Wound Care (New Rochelle) Date: 2019-12-18 Impact factor: 4.730
Authors: Jeremy Goverman; Katie Mathews; Richard Goldstein; Radha Holavanahalli; Karen Kowalske; Peter Esselman; Nicole Gibran; Oscar Suman; David Herndon; Colleen M Ryan; Jeffrey C Schneider Journal: J Burn Care Res Date: 2017 Jan/Feb Impact factor: 1.819
Authors: Jeremy Goverman; Waverley He; Geoffrey Martello; Ann Whalen; Edward Bittner; John Schulz; Nicole Gibran; David Herndon; Oscar Suman; Karen Kowalske; Walter J Meyer; Colleen Ryan; Jeffrey Schneider Journal: Ann Plast Surg Date: 2019-03 Impact factor: 1.763
Authors: J Goverman; K Mathews; D Nadler; E Henderson; K McMullen; D Herndon; W Meyer; J A Fauerbach; S Wiechman; G Carrougher; C M Ryan; J C Schneider Journal: Burns Date: 2016-05-20 Impact factor: 2.609