| Literature DB >> 24626472 |
Meera Kotagal1, Kiran J Agarwal-Harding2, Charles Mock3, Robert Quansah4, Carlos Arreola-Risa5, John G Meara2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Injury is a significant source of morbidity and mortality worldwide, and often disproportionately affects younger, more productive members of society. While many have made the case for improved injury prevention and trauma care, health system development in low- and middle-income countries is often limited by resources. This study aims to determine the economic benefit of improved injury prevention and trauma care in low- and middle-income countries.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24626472 PMCID: PMC3953529 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0091862
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Totals and rates of death, YLLs, and DALYs by income group.
| Totals and rates of death, YLLs, and DALYs by income group | |||
| IncomeGroup | Total deaths, in thousands(overall death rate, per 100,000 people) | Total YLLs, in thousands (overallYLL rate, per 100,000 people) | Total DALYs, in thousands (overallDALY rate, per 100,000 people) |
| Low | 637 (90.4) | 33,843 (4,806) | 36,884 (5,238) |
| Lower Middle | 1,782 (72.5) | 86,483 (3,517) | 99696 (4,055) |
| Upper Middle | 1,452 (60.9) | 61,085 (2,561) | 75480 (3,164) |
| LMICs | 3,871 (69.8) | 181,411 (3,270) | 212,060 (3,822) |
| High | 518 (47.5) | 16,174 (1,482) | 25,307 (2,318) |
| World | 4,390 (66.1) | 197,585 (2,976) | 237,367 (3,575) |
Totals are aggregated from all twelve mechanisms of injury and all countries in each income group. Rates are calculated as the total deaths, YLLs, or DALYs divided by total population of each income group. In accordance with the standard of the 2010 GBD study, values are presented here without discounting or age weighting.
Figure 1Percentage of total injury deaths by income level and injury type.
A) Percentage of total injury deaths by income level for each mechanism of injury. The mechanisms of injury are sorted on the x-axis from greatest-to-least by the percentage of deaths occurring in LMICs. B) Percentage of total injury deaths by injury type in each income group. The mechanisms of injury are sorted in the columns from greatest-to-least by the percentage of total deaths occurring worldwide.
Net deaths and DALYs averted by income group.
| Net deaths and YLLs averted by income group | |||
| Income Group | Net deaths averted, in thousands(% of total) | Net DALYs [0,0,0] averted, in thousands(% of total) | Net DALYs [3,1,β] averted, in thousands(% of total) |
| Low | 453 (71.1) | 24,685–24,735* (66.9–67.1*) | 12,205–12,557* (33.1–34.0*) |
| Lower Middle | 1,039 (58.3) | 52,482–52,838* (52.6–53.0*) | 25,520–27,500* (25.6–27.6*) |
| Upper Middle | 570 (39.2) | 25,759–24,405* (32.3–34.1*) | 11,428–12,176* (15.1–16.1*) |
| LMICs | 2,062 (53.3) | 102,926–101,978* (48.1*–48.5) | 49,153–52,232* (23.2–24.6*) |
| High | 56 (10.8) | 2,413–2,638* (9.5–10.4*) | 935–1,535* (3.7–6.1*) |
| World | 2,118 (48.2) | 105,339–104,617* (44.1*–44.4) | 50,088–53,767* (21.1–22.7*) |
Net deaths are deaths averted if injury mortality rates for each country were to match overall injury mortality rates in HICs (). Net DALYs are reported without discounting or age weighting (Net DALYs [0,0,0]), and with discounting of 3% and age weighting with a peak at 25 years, or β = 0.04 (NetDALYs [3,1,β]). The ranges of reported estimates are from the results of methods 1 and 2 in calculating net DALYs (see Methods). Net DALY values without an asterisk represent DALYs averted if injury mortality rates for each country were to match overall injury mortality rates in HICs in each age group (method 1, ). The values with an asterisk (*) represent DALYs averted if injury mortality and disability matched those of HICs method 2, ).
Economic benefit of reducing injury mortality.
| Total economic benefit by income group | |||
| Income Group | Human capital approach, in USD billions (% of total GNI) | VSL approach, in USD billions | |
| [0,0,0] | [3,1,β] | [3,1, | |
| Low | 28.8–28.9 (3.09–3.10) | 14.3–14.8 (1.53–1.58) | 14.6–14.8 |
| Lower Middle | 181.5–183.1 (1.99–2.01) | 88.6–96.3 (0.97–1.06) | 169.0–174.0 |
| Upper Middle | 310.1–296.5 (1.17–1.23) | 142.2–150.3 (0.56–0.60) | 569.2–602.6 |
| LMICs | 520.4–508.5 (1.44–1.47) | 245–261.4 (0.69–0.74) | 758.0–786.3 |
| High | 95.5–94.2 (0.22–0.23) | 39–50.3 (0.09–0.12) | 329.2–348.6 |
| World | 616–602.7 (0.78–0.80) | 284–311.7 (0.37–0.40) | 1,106.6–1,115.5 |
Economic benefit is reported as a range. Economic benefit calculated by the human capital approach is reported without discounting or age weighting (0,0,0), and with discounting of 3% and age weighting to a peak at age 25 years, or β = 0.04 (3,1, β). The percentage of the total GNI for each income group is reported in parentheses below the range of estimates. Economic benefit calculated by the VSL approach is reported only with discounting of 3% and age weighting to a peak at two-thirds the standard life expectancy at birth, or β = 0.017 [3,1,].