| Literature DB >> 24625637 |
Sam Watts1, Geraldine Leydon, Brian Birch, Philip Prescott, Lily Lai, Susan Eardley, George Lewith.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To systematically review the literature pertaining to the prevalence of depression and anxiety in patients with prostate cancer as a function of treatment stage.Entities:
Keywords: MENTAL HEALTH; STATISTICS & RESEARCH METHODS
Mesh:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24625637 PMCID: PMC3963074 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-003901
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Figure 1PRISMA flow diagram.
Key features of the included studies
| Author | Year | Location | Sample size | Participant age | Cancer stage | Treatment stage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ene | 2006 | Sweden | 123 | 63.1 | No data provided | Pretreatment to Post-treatment |
| Pirl | 2008 | USA | 50 | 62 | Advanced | Pre and On-treatment |
| Sharpley | 2007 | Australia | 195 | 69.2 | Localised | Post-treatment |
| Bisson | 2002 | Wales | 83 | 64.5 | Mixed | Pretreatment |
| Dirkson | 2009 | USA | 51 | 73.4 | Mixed | On-treatment |
| Dale | 2009 | USA | 67 | 67.9 | No data provided | Pretreatment (but all participants had received prior primary therapy) |
| Gabershagen | 2007 | Germany | 115 | 64.1 | Localised | Pretreatment |
| Gabershagen | 2009 | Germany | 84 | 62.8 | Mixed | Pretreatment to post-treatment |
| Hervouet | 2005 | Canada | 861 | 67.9 | Mixed | Post-treatment |
| Monga | 1999 | USA | 36 | 66 | Localised | Pretreatment to On-treatment to Post-treatment |
| Monga | 2005 | USA | 40 | 67.8 | Localised | Pretreatment to On-treatment to Post-treatment |
| Pirl | 2002 | USA | 45 | 69.4 | Localised and Metastatic | On-treatment |
| Savard | 2005 | Canada | 327 | 66 | localised | Post-treatment |
| Stone | 2000 | England | 62 | 69 | Mixed | On-treatment |
| Soloway | 2004 | USA | 103 | 62 | No data provided | Pretreatment |
| Steineck | 2002 | Finland | 326 | 64.5 | Localised | Post-treatment |
| Symon | 2006 | USA | 50 | 59.9 | Localised | Pretreatment to Post-treatment |
| Sharpley | 2007 | Australia | 183 | 69.2 | Localised | Post-treatment |
| Sharpley | 2009 | Australia | 150 | 69.8 | Localised | Post-treatment |
| van Tol-Geerdink | 2006 | Holland | 118 | 70 | Localised | Pretreatment |
| Van den Berg | 2009 | Holland | 129 | 64.9 | Localised | On-treatment (active surveillance) |
| Van den Berg | 2010 | Holland | 129 | 64.6 | Localised | On-treatment (active surveillance) |
| Monga | 2001 | USA | 40 | 67.6 | Localised | Pretreatment to Post-treatment |
| Korfage | 2006 | Holland | 299 | 65.4 | Mixed | Pretreatment Post-treatment |
| Bitsika | 2009 | Australia | 381 | No data | Localised | Post-treatment |
| Nordin | 2001 | Sweden | 118 | No data | Localised & Advanced | Pretreatment |
| Burnet | 2007 | England | 329 | 68.8 | Localised | On-treatment and post-treatment |
Overview of study characteristics
| All studies | Pretreatment studies | On-treatment studies | Post-treatment studies | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Study samples (patient numbers) | 4494 | 1707 | 723 | 3087 |
| Participant ages | 66.3 (3.3) | 64.8 (2.9) | 67.6 (3.3) | 66.9 (2.4) |
| Number of patients with localised PCa | 3270 | 1299 | 563 | 2236 |
| Number of patients with advanced PCa | 513 | 162 | 72 | 441 |
| Number of patients with metastatic PCa | 87 | 58 | 40 | 7 |
PCa, prostate cancer.
The number of prostate cancer patients being treated and undertaking each treatment modality
| Radical prostatectomy | Radiotherapy (EBRT & brachytherapy) | Hormone Therapy (orchiectomy and ADT) | Chemotherapy | Active surveillance or watchful waiting | Newly diagnosed (no treatment yet selected) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 924 | 1578 | 264 | 24 | 418 | 304 |
ADT, androgen deprivation therapy; EBRT, external beam radiotherapy.
Questionnaires utilised, frequency of use and cut-off scores utilised
| Questionnaire name | Frequency of use | Clinical cut-off scores utilised |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS) | 13 | HADS-A: ≥8 |
| HADS-D: ≥8 | ||
| Beck depression inventory (BDI) | 6 | ≥10 |
| Self rating anxiety scale (SAS) | 4 | ≥36 |
| Self rating depression scale (SDS) | 4 | ≥40 |
| Centre for epidemiologic studies depression scale (CES-D) | 4 | ≥15 |
| Stait-Trait Anxiety Scale (STAI) | 4 | ≥44 |
| Memorial anxiety scale for prostate cancer (MAX-PC) | 3 | ≥27 |
Figure 2Pretreatment depression and anxiety % prevalence.
Figure 3On-treatment depression and anxiety % prevalence.
Figure 4Post-treatment depression and anxiety % prevalence.
Figure 5Depression and anxiety % prevalence across treatments.