Milou S C Sep1, Mara van Osch1, Liesbeth M van Vliet1, Ellen M A Smets2, Jozien M Bensing3. 1. NIVEL (Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research), Utrecht, The Netherlands. 2. Department of Medical Psychology, Academic Medical Centre, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands. 3. NIVEL (Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research), Utrecht, The Netherlands; Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands. Electronic address: j.bensing@nivel.nl.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The diagnosis of incurable cancer may evoke physiological arousal in patients. Physiological arousal can negatively impact patients' recall of information provided in the medical consultation. We aim to investigate whether clinicians' affective communication during a bad news consultation will decrease patients' physiological arousal and will improve recall. METHODS:Healthy women (N=50), acting as analogue patients, were randomly assigned to watch one out of the two versions of a scripted video-vignette of a bad news consultation in which clinician's communication differed: standard vs. affective communication. Participants' skin conductance levels were obtained during video-watching, and afterwards their recall was assessed. RESULTS: While the diagnosis increased skin conductance levels in all analogue patients, skin conductance levels during the remainder of the consultation decreased more in the affective communication condition than in the standard condition. Analogue patients' recall was significantly higher in the affective condition. CONCLUSION: Breaking bad news evokes physiological arousal. Affective communication can decrease this evoked physiological arousal and might be partly responsible for analogue patients' enhanced information recall. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Although our findings need to be translated to clinical patients, they suggest that clinicians need to deal with patients' emotions before providing additional medical information.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: The diagnosis of incurable cancer may evoke physiological arousal in patients. Physiological arousal can negatively impact patients' recall of information provided in the medical consultation. We aim to investigate whether clinicians' affective communication during a bad news consultation will decrease patients' physiological arousal and will improve recall. METHODS: Healthy women (N=50), acting as analogue patients, were randomly assigned to watch one out of the two versions of a scripted video-vignette of a bad news consultation in which clinician's communication differed: standard vs. affective communication. Participants' skin conductance levels were obtained during video-watching, and afterwards their recall was assessed. RESULTS: While the diagnosis increased skin conductance levels in all analogue patients, skin conductance levels during the remainder of the consultation decreased more in the affective communication condition than in the standard condition. Analogue patients' recall was significantly higher in the affective condition. CONCLUSION: Breaking bad news evokes physiological arousal. Affective communication can decrease this evoked physiological arousal and might be partly responsible for analogue patients' enhanced information recall. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Although our findings need to be translated to clinical patients, they suggest that clinicians need to deal with patients' emotions before providing additional medical information.
Authors: Susan C Pitt; Elizabeth Wendt; Megan C Saucke; Corrine I Voils; Jason Orne; Cameron L Macdonald; Nadine P Connor; Rebecca S Sippel Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2019-07-12 Impact factor: 2.192
Authors: M Nardelli; A Greco; O P Danzi; C Perlini; F Tedeschi; E P Scilingo; L Del Piccolo; G Valenza Journal: Med Biol Eng Comput Date: 2018-07-14 Impact factor: 2.602
Authors: Sanne L van der Steen; Diewertje Houtman; Iris M Bakkeren; Robert-Jan H Galjaard; Marike G Polak; Jan J Busschbach; Aad Tibben; Sam R Riedijk Journal: Eur J Hum Genet Date: 2018-10-08 Impact factor: 4.246
Authors: Fay J Hlubocky; Tamara G Sher; David Cella; Kristen E Wroblewski; Jeffery Peppercorn; Christopher K Daugherty Journal: JCO Oncol Pract Date: 2021-02