Chen Cao1, Wenjun Jiang, Buying Wang, Jianhuo Fang, Jidong Lang, Geng Tian, Jingkun Jiang, Ting F Zhu. 1. PTN (Peking University-Tsinghua University-National Institute of Biological Sciences) Joint Graduate Program, Center for Synthetic and Systems Biology, TNLIST, MOE Key Laboratory of Bioinformatics, School of Life Sciences, Tsinghua University , Beijing 100084, People's Republic of China.
Abstract
Particulate matter (PM) air pollution poses a formidable public health threat to the city of Beijing. Among the various hazards of PM pollutants, microorganisms in PM2.5 and PM10 are thought to be responsible for various allergies and for the spread of respiratory diseases. While the physical and chemical properties of PM pollutants have been extensively studied, much less is known about the inhalable microorganisms. Most existing data on airborne microbial communities using 16S or 18S rRNA gene sequencing to categorize bacteria or fungi into the family or genus levels do not provide information on their allergenic and pathogenic potentials. Here we employed metagenomic methods to analyze the microbial composition of Beijing's PM pollutants during a severe January smog event. We show that with sufficient sequencing depth, airborne microbes including bacteria, archaea, fungi, and dsDNA viruses can be identified at the species level. Our results suggested that the majority of the inhalable microorganisms were soil-associated and nonpathogenic to human. Nevertheless, the sequences of several respiratory microbial allergens and pathogens were identified and their relative abundance appeared to have increased with increased concentrations of PM pollution. Our findings may serve as an important reference for environmental scientists, health workers, and city planners.
Particulate matter (PM) air pollution poses a formidable public health threat to the city of Beijing. Among the various hazards of PM pollutants, microorganisms in PM2.5 and PM10 are thought to be responsible for various allergies and for the spread of respiratory diseases. While the physical and chemical properties of PM pollutants have been extensively studied, much less is known about the inhalable microorganisms. Most existing data on airborne microbial communities using 16S or 18S rRNA gene sequencing to categorize bacteria or fungi into the family or genus levels do not provide information on their allergenic and pathogenic potentials. Here we employed metagenomic methods to analyze the microbial composition of Beijing's PM pollutants during a severe January smog event. We show that with sufficient sequencing depth, airborne microbes including bacteria, archaea, fungi, and dsDNA viruses can be identified at the species level. Our results suggested that the majority of the inhalable microorganisms were soil-associated and nonpathogenic to human. Nevertheless, the sequences of several respiratory microbial allergens and pathogens were identified and their relative abundance appeared to have increased with increased concentrations of PM pollution. Our findings may serve as an important reference for environmental scientists, health workers, and city planners.
As an international
megacity with a population of over 20 million,
Beijing has been suffering from frequent smog events in recent years.[1−5] Since the official daily monitoring data became available in 1999,
particulate matter has been shown to be a major air pollutant in Beijing,[1] and its impact to the public health may be profound.[1,4] Categorized by PM2.5 and PM10 (particulate
matter with nominal mean aerodynamic diameters of ≤2.5 and
≤10 μm, respectively), PM pollutants of different sizes
deposit and affect different regions of the respiratory tract: when
inhaled, coarse particles (PM2.5–10) deposit primarily
in the head airways, while fine particles (PM2.5) are more
likely to penetrate and deposit deeper in the tracheobronchial and
alveolar regions.[6] Historical data suggest
that exposure to such atmospheric particulate matter is linked to
increases in morbidity and mortality, and decreases in life expectancy.[7,8]During the period of January 10–14, 2013, the city
of Beijing,
along with the rest of the mideastern region of China experienced
a massive, severe smog event.[2] The highest
daily average PM2.5 concentration in Beijing measured greater
than 500 μg/m3 at times (20-fold higher than the
WHO guideline value), raising serious public health concerns. Wide-spread
respiratory irritation symptoms (e.g., “Beijing cough”)
and significant increases of outpatient cases related to respiratory
diseases have been reported.[2] Here we asked
the question of what microorganisms, particularly inhalable allergens
and pathogens, are in Beijing’s PM2.5 and PM10 pollutants and what potential effects they may have on the
public health during severe smog events like this.The public
health effects of PM, particularly those of PM2.5, have
been well documented in the literature.[9,10] While
the physical and chemical properties of PM2.5 and PM10 pollutants have been extensively studied, relatively less
is known about inhalable biological particles such as bacteria, fungi,
viruses, pollens, and cell debris in the micrometer to submicrometer
size range. It has been suggested that materials of biological origin
may contribute as much as 25% to the atmospheric aerosol,[11] and they are responsible for various diseases
and allergies. The abundance of airborne bacteria measured from 104 to 106 cells per m3, depending on the
environment.[12] While culture-based methods
have been used to detect airborne microorganisms,[13] they are constrained to the identification of a limited
number of cultivatable species. Although the use of amplicon-based
(e.g., 16S or 18S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene) sequencing and related
techniques have allowed us to detect both cultivatable and noncultivatable
microorganisms (although DNA from cell debris may also be detected)
and categorize the microbial populations in airborne particles,[12,14−17] it has been challenging to sequence the fine, inhalable PM2.5 samples (which are more relevant to human health) due to the low
DNA yield, unless with amplification of the extracted DNA.[18] Yet amplicon-based sequencing methods often
result in biases,[19] and most importantly,
they are generally limited to categorizing bacteria or fungi at the
family or genus level (without the use of marker genes).[16,20] Because microbial species within the same family or genus may differ
significantly in pathogenic potential, the discovery of microbial
allergens and pathogens requires the identification of bacteria, fungi,
and viruses at the species or even strain level.[21] Thus, microbial metagenomic sequencing represents a powerful
alternative for studying complex microbial communities,[22] particularly for its ability to discover clinically
relevant microbes at the species level.[23]
Materials and Methods
Particulate Matter Collection
PM2.5 and
PM10 samples were collected from the roof top of the Environmental
Science Building (40°0′17″N, 116°19′34″E,
∼10 m above the ground, ∼20 m and ∼690 m from
the nearest river and hospital, respectively) at Tsinghua University,
an area without major pollution sources nearby. This site has been
used to monitor PM2.5 pollution in Beijing since 1999.[24−26] Sampling was conducted by three high volume air samplers (Thermo
Electron Corp., MA, U.S.), two of which were equipped with PM2.5 fractionating inlets, the third one being equipped with
a PM10 fractionating inlet. Ambient air was drawn at an
average flow rate of 1.13 m3/min for 23 h (10:00 AM to
9:00 AM the next day) per sampling day from January 8 to January 14
(including January 8 as a nonsmog control, according to the Chinese
Class II Standard), resulting in approximately 1559 m3 of
air flow-through per sampling day. Particulate matter with aerodynamic
diameters of ≤2.5 and ≤10 μm were collected on
20.32 × 25.4 cm2 Tissuquartz filters (PALL, NY, U.S.)
with 99.9% typical aerosol retention. All the filters were sterilized
by baking in a Muffle furnace at 500 °C for 5 h prior to sampling.
Each sterilized filter was packaged in sterilized aluminum foil and
stored in a sealed bag until being loaded into the filter cartridge.
The filter holder and all the tools used for changing new filters
were cleaned with 75% ethanol or autoclaved every day to avoid contamination.
The net weight of each filter was recorded at mg accuracy before and
after sampling. The concentrations of PM2.5 and PM10 at our sampling site were estimated by the net weight of
each sample (average weight of the two PM2.5 samples) divided
by the 23 h flow-through volume per sampling day (to avoid microbial
contamination, samples were not kept under 45% relative humidity at
20 °C as typically required for PM measurements). A 47 mm diameter
filter punch was taken from the PM10 sample and one of
the PM2.5 samples each day for chemical component and elemental
analyses. The filter punches were kept in size adaptive chambers and
stored at −20 °C. All other samples were stored at −80
°C until downstream analyses were performed.
DNA Extraction
To overcome the issue of low yield during
genomic DNA extraction, several technical improvements were made to
optimize the extraction of high-quality DNA from PM samples. Considering
the different DNA yield of PM2.5 and PM10 samples,
1/4 of PM10 filter (a total of ∼103.04 cm2) and 1 and 3/4 of the PM2.5 filters (a total of ∼721.28
cm2) from each sampling day were used for DNA extraction.
The filters were cut into 8.96 ×11.5 cm2 pieces and
were placed in 50 mL centrifuge tubes filled with sterilized 1X PBS
buffer. The PM samples were then pelleted at 4 °C by centrifugation
at 200g for 2 h. After gentle vortexing, the resuspension
was filtered with a 0.2 μm Supor 200 PES Membrane Disc Filter
(PALL, NY, U.S.), which was then cut into small pieces and used for
DNA extraction using the MO-BIO PowerSoil DNA isolation kit (Carlsbad,
CA, U.S.). All the steps mentioned above were carried out in a clean
bench. Scissors, forceps, and filter funnels were all sterilized before
use. The samples were then heated to 65 °C in PowerBead Tubes
for 10 min followed by vortexing for 2 min. The remaining steps of
the extraction were performed according to the standard MO-BIO PowerSoil
DNA isolation protocol except for the column purification step, which
was replaced with magnetic bead purification (Agencourt AMPure XP,
Beckman, CA, U.S.) for improved yield. Genomic DNA quality and concentration
were analyzed by gel electrophoresis and a fluorescent dsDNA-binding
dye assay (Qubit Fluorometer, Life Technologies, CA, U.S.). Blank
control samples were collected by placing a sterilized filter inside
of the sampler without operation for 23 h, and treated similarly as
above. DNA extraction of blank control samples resulted in DNA concentrations
below the detection limit of our instruments, and library generation
efforts failed to generate useable sequencing libraries. All the extracted
DNA samples were stored at −80 °C until further use.
Sequencing and Phylogenetic Analysis
The Illumina MiSeq
(for library validation) and HiSeq 2000 sequencing systems (Illumina,
CA, U.S.) were used for sequencing, and the library preparation kits
were purchased from New England Biolabs (MA, U.S.). Sequencing library
construction and template preparation were performed according to
the NEB library preparation protocols. We constructed a paired-end
library with insert size of ∼500 bp for each sample. An aliquot
of 5 ng DNA from each sample was used as the starting amount (except
for 3 samples, the total quantities of DNA of which were less than
5 ng, Supporting Information (SI), Table
S1) for library preparation in order to ensure sample consistency.
In order to minimize possible bias introduced by PCR, 12 cycles were
performed during PCR amplification. Each sample was barcoded and equal
quantities of barcoded libraries were used for sequencing (for index
sequences, see SI Table S1). Adaptor contamination
and low-quality reads were discarded from the raw data. In total,
∼98 Gb sequence with a uniform read length of 90 bp was obtained
and an average of ∼7 Gb high-quality HiSeq sequences were generated
from each sample (SI Table S1). The rarefaction
curve (analyzed by the Metagenomics RAST server (MG-RAST, release
3.3))[27] suggested that the sequencing depth
of the HiSeq data was sufficient to capture most of the microorganisms
but not the MiSeq data (average data set of 683Mb) (SI Figure S1). MetaPhlAn (Metagenomic Phylogenetic Analysis)[28] was used to estimate the relative abundance
of bacteria and archaea with unique clade-specific genes at the species
level (SI Figures S2 and S3). The Illumina
HiSeq reads were aligned to a cohort of nonredundant NCBI complete
genomes (2637 complete genomes, including bacteria, fungi, archaea,
and viruses) using the Short Oligonucleotide Analysis Package (SOAP)
alignment tool (release 2.21t)[29] to profile
the common core species. We used a 90% identity threshold for bacteria,
archaea, and fungi, and 100% identity for viruses due to their smaller
genome sizes. Genome coverage was calculated using the SOAP.coverage
package (version 2.7.7). Only uniquely aligned reads were used in
the analysis. Bacterial, fungal, and viral species with coverage of
≥5%, ≥0.5% (average alignment of all chromosomes), and
≥1%, respectively, in either PM2.5 or PM10 samples of 7 consecutive sampling days were listed in SI Table S2. The genome-size-normalized relative
abundance of these species was calculated based on the number of aligned
reads normalized by the species’ genome size (SI Figure S4 and Table S3). The variations of the hit abundance
of species across 7 sampling days were estimated based on the hit
numbers normalized by number of total aligned reads (SI Figure S5). The Greengenes 16S rRNA gene database[30] was used for 16S rRNA phylogenetic analysis
with the following alignment parameters: >97% identity, minimal
alignment
40 bp. DNA sequence data have been deposited in MG-RAST (http://metagenomics.anl.gov/) at the following URL: http://metagenomics.anl.gov/linkin.cgi?project=3756.
Analysis of Original Bacteria Habitats
The Greengenes
16S rRNA gene database[30] was used for assigning
the HiSeq reads at >97% identity threshold (only uniquely aligned
reads were used for following calculations). All of the Greengenes
database sequences with available information of bacteria habitats
were classified into the four categories without overlaps. In addition,
the 16S sequences of previous studies on high-altitude[16] and urban airborne bacteria of Milan[14] and New York[17] were
assigned to the same habitat categories and compared to our results
(SI Figure S6).
Results
Sequence of
the Airborne Metagenome
We sought to sequence
the metagenome of inhalable airborne microorganisms in Beijing’s
PM2.5 and PM10 pollutants, after having overcome
the technical issues involved in high-volume PM2.5 and
PM10 sample collection, DNA extraction, and library generation
(for details of the DNA extraction methods, see Materials
and Methods). PM2.5 and PM10 samples
collected at a Beijing Tsinghua PM monitoring site (40°0′17″N,
116°19′34″E) from January 8–14, 2013, during
which period Beijing’s PM2.5 and PM10 pollution indexes rapidly deteriorated from healthy to record-high
hazardous levels, were used for sequencing (Figure 1A, SI Figures S7–S9 and
Table S4; air temperatures are typically low in January in Beijing,
creating a unique high PM, low temperature environment). The Illumina
HiSeq data from a total of 7 daily PM2.5 and 7 PM10 samples is more than 1000-fold larger than those of three previous
studies on airborne bacteria combined,[14,16,17] from which original sequence data were publicly available
(SI Table S1). By aligning to the Greengenes
16S rRNA gene database[30] at a 97% identity
threshold, we discovered 255 more bacteria genera than those identified
by the three previous studies (SI Figure
S10 and Table S5). Overall, the PM2.5 samples contained
86.1% bacterial, 13.0% eukaryotic, 0.8% archaeal, and 0.1% viral reads,
while the PM10 samples contained 80.8% bacterial, 18.3%
eukaryotic, 0.8% archaeal, and 0.1% viral reads (Figure 1B). The higher relative abundance of eukaryotic reads (which
included those from fungi, plants, algae, and animal debris), as well
as the higher alpha diversity (a measurement of species diversity)
found in PM10 compared with those of PM2.5 samples
(Figure 1C), may in part be attributed to the
fact that the aerodynamic diameters of many fungal spore agglomerates
were between 2.5 and 10 μm.[31−33] Principal component
analysis (PCA) of the microbial relative abundance (Figure 1D and SI Table S6) and
dinucleotide frequency (SI Figure S11)
suggested that the metagenomes of airborne microbes were distinct
from those of other environments, though relatively more related to
the soil metagenomes.
Figure 1
Characteristics of the collected PM samples and sequenced
metagenomes.
(A) Daily average PM2.5 and PM10 concentrations
estimated from the collected samples during January 8–14, 2013.
(B) Relative abundance of the MG-RAST taxonomic hits at the domain
level in PM2.5 and PM10 samples. (C) Estimated
average alpha diversity of the PM2.5 and PM10 samples (error bars represent SD of the 7 daily PM2.5 and 7 PM10 samples, respectively). (D) Principal component
analysis of the relative abundance of microorganisms at the phylum
level of the 14 sequenced PM metagenomes (red) compared to those of
other environments (other colors).
Characteristics of the collected PM samples and sequenced
metagenomes.
(A) Daily average PM2.5 and PM10 concentrations
estimated from the collected samples during January 8–14, 2013.
(B) Relative abundance of the MG-RAST taxonomic hits at the domain
level in PM2.5 and PM10 samples. (C) Estimated
average alpha diversity of the PM2.5 and PM10 samples (error bars represent SD of the 7 daily PM2.5 and 7 PM10 samples, respectively). (D) Principal component
analysis of the relative abundance of microorganisms at the phylum
level of the 14 sequenced PM metagenomes (red) compared to those of
other environments (other colors).
Bacteria Were the Most Abundant Airborne Prokaryotic Microorganisms
and the Majority of Them Were Terrestrial-Related
Bacteria
appeared to be the most abundant prokaryotic microorganisms in PM2.5 and PM10 pollutants. To identify the prokaryotic
species and to estimate their relative abundance, we used the Metagenomic
Phylogenetic Analysis (MetaPhlAn) toolbox[28] to reveal a picture of complex bacteria and archaea community (Figure 2A and SI Figure S2).
We show that the most abundant phyla were Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria,
Chloroflexi, Firmicutes, Bacteroidetes, and Euryarchaeota (relative
abundance ≥1%). At the species level, 1315 distinct bacterial
and archaeal species were identified from the 14 samples. An unclassified
bacterium in the nitrogen fixing, filamentous bacteria genus Frankia
appeared to be the most abundant (Figure 2A
and SI Figure S3). The most abundant classified
bacterial species appeared to be Geodermatophilus obscurus, a bacterium commonly found in dry soil environments (SI Table S7). By aligning to the Greengenes 16S
database, categorized by terrestrial, fecal, freshwater, and marine-associated
bacteria (see Materials and Methods), we show
that the majority (>85%) of the categorized bacteria in the collected
PM2.5 and PM10 samples were related to fecal
and terrestrial sources (Figure 2B and SI Figure S6). The proportion of bacteria from
terrestrial-related sources appeared to be higher than those identified
from the three previous studies (Figure 2C
and SI Figure S6).[14,16,17] This may in part be attributed to the lack
of vegetation coverage and abundance of dry, exposed soil, and construction
sites in the city of Beijing and its surrounding areas, especially
during the winter seasons. In addition, while the proportion of freshwater
and marine-associated bacteria remained relatively constant, the fraction
of fecal-associated bacteria appeared to have increased (from 4.5%
to as high as 11.4% in PM2.5 samples) (Figure 2B) with progressively increased concentrations of
PM pollution.
Figure 2
Bacterial and archaeal species in PM samples and their
original
habitats. (A) Phylogenetic tree of the bacteria and archaea identified
from PM2.5 samples, analyzed by MetaPhlAn. The sizes of
the nodes correspond to the relative abundance at the corresponding
levels in the cohort. The family, genus, and species levels of the
most abundant order Actinomycetales are plotted.
Only nodes with ≥1% relative abundance are labeled. (B) Original
habitats of the identified bacteria in daily PM2.5 and
PM10 samples, categorized by terrestrial, fecal, freshwater,
and marine sources. (C) Bacterial and archaeal species in Beijing's
PM samples were pooled and compared with those identified from the
GRIP high-altitude, Milan urban, and New York subway studies.
Bacterial and archaeal species in PM samples and their
original
habitats. (A) Phylogenetic tree of the bacteria and archaea identified
from PM2.5 samples, analyzed by MetaPhlAn. The sizes of
the nodes correspond to the relative abundance at the corresponding
levels in the cohort. The family, genus, and species levels of the
most abundant order Actinomycetales are plotted.
Only nodes with ≥1% relative abundance are labeled. (B) Original
habitats of the identified bacteria in daily PM2.5 and
PM10 samples, categorized by terrestrial, fecal, freshwater,
and marine sources. (C) Bacterial and archaeal species in Beijing's
PM samples were pooled and compared with those identified from the
GRIP high-altitude, Milan urban, and New York subway studies.
Most Abundant Bacterial,
Fungal, and Viral Species in PM2.5 and PM10
Since not only bacteria, but
also fungi and viruses are responsible for various humanallergies
and diseases, we sought to identify the microbial species including
fungi and viruses (which are currently not supported by the MetaPhlAn
toolbox) in PM2.5 and PM10 pollutants. We employed
the Short Oligonucleotide Analysis Package (SOAP) alignment tool[29] to align the HiSeq reads from each sample to
a cohort of 2637 nonredundant species of NCBI complete genomes, including
bacteria, archaea, fungi, and viruses. At a 90% identity threshold
and ≥5% coverage of the complete bacterial genomes (for a typical
bacterial genome of 4 Mb, it corresponds to a minimal alignment length
of ∼200 kb, >100-fold longer than the 16S rRNA gene and
thus
provides more confidence) or ≥0.5% coverage for fungal genomes,
the 48 most abundant bacterial and 2 fungal species were identified
(SI Table S2). Because of the smaller genome
size of viruses, we used a more stringent alignment strategy (i.e.,
100% identity and ≥1% coverage), and 3 most abundant viral
species were identified. We next estimated the genome-size-normalized
relative abundance (defined as the number of unique hit reads normalized
by genome size) of each species within the most common ones (SI Table S3) and analyzed the daily variations
of their relative abundance during the 7 sampling days (Figure 3). Consistent with the MetaPhlAn results, the soil-associated
bacteria G. obscurus appeared to be the most abundant
classified bacterial species (with an average genome coverage of ∼42.7%
and relative abundance of ∼14.6% in the PM2.5 samples),
followed by Modestobacter marinus, Blastococcus
saxobsidens, Kocuria rhizophila, and Micrococcus luteus, all of which are commonly found in soil
habitats and some with the abilities to survive under “tough”
(e.g., UV radiation) conditions (SI Table
S7). Although the relative abundance of most of the bacterial species
remained stable during the 7 sampling days, as was found in previous
studies,[12,34] some showed considerable variations. For
example, the relative abundance of Thermobifida fusca, an important bacterial degrader of plant cell walls and commonly
found in decaying organic matter (SI Table
S7), increased ∼5-fold from an average of 0.7% during the first
2 less polluted days to an average of 3.7 ± 2.5% in the 5 heavily
polluted days in PM2.5 samples (SI Figures S4 and S12).
Figure 3
Box plot of the daily variations of the relative abundance
of 48
most common bacterial, 2 fungal, and 3 viral species in PM samples.
Boxes correspond to the interquartile range between the 25th and 75th
percentiles, and the central lines represent the 50th percentile.
Whiskers correspond to the lowest and highest values no more than
1.5 times the interquartile range from the box, while dots are the
outliers beyond the whiskers. PM2.5 samples are labeled
pink and PM10 are black.
Box plot of the daily variations of the relative abundance
of 48
most common bacterial, 2 fungal, and 3 viral species in PM samples.
Boxes correspond to the interquartile range between the 25th and 75th
percentiles, and the central lines represent the 50th percentile.
Whiskers correspond to the lowest and highest values no more than
1.5 times the interquartile range from the box, while dots are the
outliers beyond the whiskers. PM2.5 samples are labeled
pink and PM10 are black.
Microbial Allergens and Pathogens in the PM2.5 and
PM10 Samples
Among the identified microbial species,
several are known to cause humanallergies and respiratory diseases,
including Streptococcus pneumoniae, Aspergillus
fumigatus, and human adenovirus C (with average genome coverage
of 2.0%, 14.5%, and 6.5%, respectively). Among them, S. pneumoniae is the most common cause for community-acquired pneumonia (CAP),
having been isolated from nearly 50% of CAP cases.[35] Its representation within the entire bacteria community
(analyzed by MetaPhlAn) was 0.012% in PM2.5 samples and
0.017% in PM10 samples, and the normalized number of hit
reads (hit abundance) appeared to have increased by ∼2 fold
from an average of 0.024% during the first 2 less polluted days to
an average of 0.05 ± 0.02% in the 5 heavily polluted days in
PM2.5 samples (Figure 4A). A. fumigatus, likely collected in the form of spores, is
known as a major fungal allergen and opportunistic pathogen that causes
airway or lung invasion in immunodeficientpatients.[36] Its average hit abundance was found to be higher in PM10 than in PM2.5 samples (4.5% vs 1.7%), most likely
because the aerodynamic diameters of the fungal spore agglomerates
are between 2.5 and 10 μm.[37] The
hit abundance of A. fumigates also appeared to be
correlated with the increase of PM pollution levels, increasing ∼4-fold
from an average of 1.5% during the first 2 less polluted days to an
average of 5.8 ± 1.8% in the 5 heavily polluted days in PM10 samples (Figure 4B). To confirm the
existence of A. fumigatus in our samples, we cultured
the fungus and validated its existence by sequencing the 18S rRNA
gene and a species-specific gene (gliI) (SI Table S8), as well as SEM imaging (SI Figure S13). Human adenovirus, a dsDNA virus
that accounts for 5–10% of upper and lower respiratory tract
infections in children,[38] was also found
(with 100% sequence matched to human adenovirus C in all 14 samples).
The hit abundance of adenovirus in our samples also appeared to have
increased during the heavily polluted days, though with more daily
variations than those of S. pneumonia and A. fumigates (SI Figure S5).
Figure 4
Daily
variations of the normalized hit abundance of microbial pathogens
and allergens in the collected PM2.5 and PM10 samples. (A) S. pneumoniae and (B) A. fumigatus.
Daily
variations of the normalized hit abundance of microbial pathogens
and allergens in the collected PM2.5 and PM10 samples. (A) S. pneumoniae and (B) A. fumigatus.
Chemical Composition Analysis
of the PM Pollutants
To put our findings in the context of
aerosol chemistry, we analyzed
the organic and elemental carbon, water-soluble ions, and elemental
composition of the collected samples (SI Tables S9–S11). We found that sulfate, ammonium, nitrate,
and organic matter were among the most abundant, and altogether their
relative abundance in PM2.5 and PM10 samples
were 80% and 71% (w/w), respectively. These results, as well as the
high weight ratio of PM2.5 to PM10 (∼0.7),
suggested that secondary formation of fine particles likely led to
the high PM concentrations during this smog event.[26] Additionally, the high relative humidity (SI Figure S8) during the period may have contributed to particle
growth through water uptake and promoting aqueous redox chemistry
(e.g., the oxidation of sulfur dioxide to sulfate). This also suggested
that most of the particles were rich in water content during the polluted
days and thus would favor the survival of microbes.[39]
Discussion
PM pollution has been
studied extensively in the context of aerosol
chemistry and physics,[24,26] and statistical correlations
between PM pollution and decreased life expectancy have been made.[8] So far, no specific components of PM have been
conclusively shown to be harmless.[40] In
particular, much less is understood about what microorganisms are
in the PM pollutants. Previous studies have shown that bioaerosols
containing pathogens are responsible for the spread of respiratory
diseases,[41,42] and thus it is crucial to understand the
composition of airborne microbes at the species level and to identify
the potential microbial allergens and pathogens. Most of the clinically
relevant studies on inhalable pathogens were conducted in hospital
environments,[42−45] yet in Beijing, a significant increase of outpatient cases related
to respiratory diseases during the same severe PM pollution period
studied here has been reported.[2] Our results
have provided sequence-based evidence for the existence of inhalable
microbial allergen and pathogen species in an open environment, and
suggested that high PM pollution may pose health threats to the susceptible
population (e.g., the elderlies and the immunodeficient). Besides,
information on the original habitats of airborne bacteria provides
important insights for understanding the source of the biological
particles, and may be used as a reference for future urban planning
efforts to reduce PM pollution and the spread of airborne microbial
allergens and pathogens. In future studies, clinical samples (e.g.,
sputum samples from respiratory diseasepatients) during severely
polluted and unpolluted days can be obtained, and the sequence information
can be compared to those from collected PM samples for comparison.
Furthermore, PM exposure studies on animal models can be performed
to characterize the effects of PM-associated allergens and pathogens,
leading to better understandings of their pathogenicity.Using
the current methods, we were able to identify bacterial,
archaeal, fungal, and dsDNA viral species in the collected PM samples.
Cultivation was used to verify the existence of A. fumigatus. We also attempted to culture other bacteria and fungi species,
but not all were successfully cultured (data not shown) since some
species were slow-growing or difficult to culture, and the samples
were stored at −80 °C before use. RNA viruses such as
rhinovirus and influenza virus are undoubtedly important viral agents
that affect the public health. Yet in our experience, it appeared
to be technically challenging to extract sufficient quantities of
RNA for reverse transcription and sequencing from PM samples containing
various RNA-degrading containments such as divalent cations. Low-bias
preamplification techniques may be used to generate sufficient libraries
for the sequencing of RNA viruses in PM samples in future studies.[46] As for humandsDNA viruses, human adenovirus
C appeared to be the most abundant in our PM samples based on our
sequencing results. More importantly, the current study was limited
by the daily sampling capacity and availability of sampling sites,
as well as the trade-off between obtaining high-depth sequence data
for species-level characterization vs more sampling days (98 Gb data
from 14 samples). In particular, though PM pollution levels are typically
high in the winter of Beijing, low temperatures are often associated
with lower overall microbial abundance compared to warmer seasons.
Thus, future longitudinal and multiple location studies to identify
airborne microorganisms should be performed to compare with our current
results and to provide better insights on the increased incidences
of respiratory diseases during urban smog events, and to correlate
with meteorological data, chemical components, and clinically obtained
pathogen samples. Additionally, the establishment of a monitoring
network for airborne microbes can be invaluable during outbreaks of
deadly respiratory diseases. Information on the abundance of particular
airborne pathogens and their regional and seasonal variations will
be of particular importance for the prevention of respiratory diseases
at a public scale, in areas such as vaccine design and distribution,
as well as for understanding the spread of drug resistant respiratory
pathogens.
Authors: Eoin L Brodie; Todd Z DeSantis; Jordan P Moberg Parker; Ingrid X Zubietta; Yvette M Piceno; Gary L Andersen Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2006-12-20 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Robert M Bowers; Nicholas Clements; Joanne B Emerson; Christine Wiedinmyer; Michael P Hannigan; Noah Fierer Journal: Environ Sci Technol Date: 2013-10-22 Impact factor: 9.028
Authors: Natasha DeLeon-Rodriguez; Terry L Lathem; Luis M Rodriguez-R; James M Barazesh; Bruce E Anderson; Andreas J Beyersdorf; Luke D Ziemba; Michael Bergin; Athanasios Nenes; Konstantinos T Konstantinidis Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2013-01-28 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Charles E Robertson; Laura K Baumgartner; J Kirk Harris; Kristen L Peterson; Mark J Stevens; Daniel N Frank; Norman R Pace Journal: Appl Environ Microbiol Date: 2013-03-29 Impact factor: 4.792
Authors: Anne Straumfors; Oda A H Foss; Janina Fuss; Steen K Mollerup; Håvard Kauserud; Sunil Mundra Journal: Appl Environ Microbiol Date: 2019-10-16 Impact factor: 4.792
Authors: Min Gao; Tianlei Qiu; Ruizhi Jia; Meilin Han; Yuan Song; Xuming Wang Journal: Environ Sci Pollut Res Int Date: 2014-10-11 Impact factor: 4.223
Authors: Blake Hanson; Yanjiao Zhou; Eddy J Bautista; Bruce Urch; Mary Speck; Frances Silverman; Michael Muilenberg; Wanda Phipatanakul; George Weinstock; Erica Sodergren; Diane R Gold; Joanne E Sordillo Journal: Environ Sci Process Impacts Date: 2016-05-23 Impact factor: 4.238