BACKGROUND: Studies have demonstrated that relative value units (RVUs) do not appropriately reflect cognitive effort or time spent in patient care, but RVU continues to be used as a standardized system to track productivity. It is unknown how well RVU reflects the effort of acute care surgeons. Our objective was to determine if RVUs adequately reflect increased surgeon effort required to treat emergent versus elective patients receiving similar procedures. METHODS: A retrospective analysis using The American College of Surgeons' National Surgical Quality Improvement Program 2011 data set was conducted. The control group consisted of patients undergoing elective colectomy, hernia repair, or biliary procedures as identified by Current Procedural Terminology. Comparison was made to emergent cases after being stratified to laparoscopic or open technique. Generalized linear models and logistic regression were used to assess specific outcomes, controlling for demographics and comorbidities of interest. The RVUs, operative time, and length of stay (LOS) were primary variables, with major/minor complications, mortality, and readmissions being evaluated as the relevant outcomes. RESULTS: A total of 442,149 patients in the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program underwent one of the operative procedures of interest; 27,636 biliary (91% laparoscopic; 8.5% open), 28,722 colorectal (40.3% laparoscopic, 59.7% open), and 31,090 hernia (26.6% laparoscopic, 73.4% open) operations. Emergent procedures were found to have average RVU values that were identical to their elective case counterparts. Complication rates were higher and LOS were increased in emergent cases. Odds ratios for complications and readmissions in emergent cases were twice those of elective procedures. Mortality was skewed toward emergent cases. CONCLUSION: Our data indicate that the emergent operative management for various procedures is similarly valued despite increased LOS, more complications, higher mortality risk, and subsequently increased physician attention. Our findings suggest that the RVU system for acute care surgeons may need to be reevaluated to better capture the additional work involved in emergent patient care.
BACKGROUND: Studies have demonstrated that relative value units (RVUs) do not appropriately reflect cognitive effort or time spent in patient care, but RVU continues to be used as a standardized system to track productivity. It is unknown how well RVU reflects the effort of acute care surgeons. Our objective was to determine if RVUs adequately reflect increased surgeon effort required to treat emergent versus elective patients receiving similar procedures. METHODS: A retrospective analysis using The American College of Surgeons' National Surgical Quality Improvement Program 2011 data set was conducted. The control group consisted of patients undergoing elective colectomy, hernia repair, or biliary procedures as identified by Current Procedural Terminology. Comparison was made to emergent cases after being stratified to laparoscopic or open technique. Generalized linear models and logistic regression were used to assess specific outcomes, controlling for demographics and comorbidities of interest. The RVUs, operative time, and length of stay (LOS) were primary variables, with major/minor complications, mortality, and readmissions being evaluated as the relevant outcomes. RESULTS: A total of 442,149 patients in the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program underwent one of the operative procedures of interest; 27,636 biliary (91% laparoscopic; 8.5% open), 28,722 colorectal (40.3% laparoscopic, 59.7% open), and 31,090 hernia (26.6% laparoscopic, 73.4% open) operations. Emergent procedures were found to have average RVU values that were identical to their elective case counterparts. Complication rates were higher and LOS were increased in emergent cases. Odds ratios for complications and readmissions in emergent cases were twice those of elective procedures. Mortality was skewed toward emergent cases. CONCLUSION: Our data indicate that the emergent operative management for various procedures is similarly valued despite increased LOS, more complications, higher mortality risk, and subsequently increased physician attention. Our findings suggest that the RVU system for acute care surgeons may need to be reevaluated to better capture the additional work involved in emergent patient care.
Authors: Laura K Altom; Christopher W Snyder; Stephen H Gray; Laura A Graham; Catherine C Vick; Mary T Hawn Journal: Am Surg Date: 2011-08 Impact factor: 0.688
Authors: Raul A Rivera; Mai T Nguyen; Jorge I Martinez-Osorio; Matthew F McNeill; Sayed K Ali; Ishak A Mansi Journal: Am J Surg Date: 2012-07-06 Impact factor: 2.565
Authors: Gwendolyn M van der Wilden; Ulrich Schmidt; Yuchiao Chang; Edward A Bittner; J Perren Cobb; George C Velmahos; Hasan B Alam; Marc A de Moya; David R King Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2013-02 Impact factor: 3.313
Authors: David A Klima; Rita A Brintzenhoff; Neal Agee; Amanda Walters; B Todd Heniford; Gamal Mostafa Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2011-10-06 Impact factor: 2.192
Authors: Marine Coste; Vineet Aggarwal; Neil V Shah; David Kim; Omar K Hariri; Louis M Day; Scott C Pascal; Jaydev B Mistry; William P Urban; William R Aibinder; Arvind G Von Keudell; Nishant Suneja Journal: Arch Bone Jt Surg Date: 2021-07
Authors: Angela Ingraham; Jessica Schumacher; Sara Fernandes-Taylor; Dou-Yan Yang; Laura Godat; Alan Smith; Ronald Barbosa; Chris Cribari; Ali Salim; Thomas Schroeppel; Kristan Staudenmayer; Marie Crandall; Garth Utter Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2022-01-01 Impact factor: 3.697
Authors: Nipun Sodhi; Sarah E Dalton; Luke J Garbarino; Peter A Gold; Nicolas S Piuzzi; Jared M Newman; Anton Khlopas; Assem A Sultan; Morad Chughtai; Michael A Mont Journal: Ann Transl Med Date: 2019-02
Authors: Andrew Brennan; Kimberlee Gauvreau; Jean Connor; Cheryl O'Connell; Sthuthi David; Melvin Almodovar; James DiNardo; Puja Banka; John E Mayer; Audrey C Marshall; Lisa Bergersen Journal: Pediatr Cardiol Date: 2014-08-12 Impact factor: 1.655
Authors: Suresh K Nayar; Richard L Skolasky; Dawn M LaPorte; Ryan M Zimmerman; Aviram M Giladi; Umasuthan Srikumaran Journal: Clin Orthop Surg Date: 2021-01-07
Authors: John Joseph Carney; Erik Gerlach; Mark Plantz; Peter Raymond Swiatek; Jeremy Marx; Matthew Saltzman; Guido Marra Journal: Clin Shoulder Elb Date: 2022-01-10