Natalie Joseph-Williams1, Glyn Elwyn2, Adrian Edwards3. 1. Cochrane Institute of Primary Care and Public Health, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK. Electronic address: josephnj1@cf.ac.uk. 2. The Dartmouth Center for Health Care Delivery Science, Dartmouth College, Hanover, USA. 3. Cochrane Institute of Primary Care and Public Health, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To systematically review patient-reported barriers and facilitators to shared decision making (SDM) and develop a taxonomy of patient-reported barriers. METHODS: Systematic review and thematic synthesis. Study findings/results for each included paper were extracted verbatim and entered into qualitative software for inductive analysis. RESULTS: Electronic and follow-up searches yielded 2956 unique references; 289 full-text articles were retrieved, of which 45 articles from 44 unique studies met inclusion criteria. Key descriptive themes were grouped under two broad analytical themes: how the healthcare system is organized (4 descriptive themes) and what happens during the decision-making interaction (4 descriptive themes, 10 sub-themes). Predominant emergent themes related to patients' knowledge and the power imbalance in the doctor-patient relationship. Patients need knowledge and power to participate in SDM - knowledge alone is insufficient and power is more difficult to attain. CONCLUSION: Many barriers are potentially modifiable, and can be addressed by attitudinal changes at the levels of patient, clinician/healthcare team, and the organization. The results support the view that many patients currently can't participate in SDM, rather than they won't participate because they do not want to. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Future implementation efforts should address patient-reported factors together with known clinician-reported barriers and the wider organizational context.
OBJECTIVE: To systematically review patient-reported barriers and facilitators to shared decision making (SDM) and develop a taxonomy of patient-reported barriers. METHODS: Systematic review and thematic synthesis. Study findings/results for each included paper were extracted verbatim and entered into qualitative software for inductive analysis. RESULTS: Electronic and follow-up searches yielded 2956 unique references; 289 full-text articles were retrieved, of which 45 articles from 44 unique studies met inclusion criteria. Key descriptive themes were grouped under two broad analytical themes: how the healthcare system is organized (4 descriptive themes) and what happens during the decision-making interaction (4 descriptive themes, 10 sub-themes). Predominant emergent themes related to patients' knowledge and the power imbalance in the doctor-patient relationship. Patients need knowledge and power to participate in SDM - knowledge alone is insufficient and power is more difficult to attain. CONCLUSION: Many barriers are potentially modifiable, and can be addressed by attitudinal changes at the levels of patient, clinician/healthcare team, and the organization. The results support the view that many patients currently can't participate in SDM, rather than they won't participate because they do not want to. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Future implementation efforts should address patient-reported factors together with known clinician-reported barriers and the wider organizational context.
Authors: Marya Gwadz; Charles M Cleland; Elizabeth Applegate; Mindy Belkin; Monica Gandhi; Nadim Salomon; Angela Banfield; Noelle Leonard; Marion Riedel; Hannah Wolfe; Isaiah Pickens; Kelly Bolger; DeShannon Bowens; David Perlman; Donna Mildvan Journal: AIDS Behav Date: 2015-10
Authors: Leslie P Scheunemann; Natalie C Ernecoff; Praewpannarai Buddadhumaruk; Shannon S Carson; Catherine L Hough; J Randall Curtis; Wendy G Anderson; Jay Steingrub; Bernard Lo; Michael Matthay; Robert M Arnold; Douglas B White Journal: JAMA Intern Med Date: 2019-05-01 Impact factor: 21.873
Authors: Lauren J Taylor; Michael J Nabozny; Nicole M Steffens; Jennifer L Tucholka; Karen J Brasel; Sara K Johnson; Amy Zelenski; Paul J Rathouz; Qianqian Zhao; Kristine L Kwekkeboom; Toby C Campbell; Margaret L Schwarze Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2017-06-01 Impact factor: 14.766
Authors: Elizabeth M Schoenfeld; Connor Houghton; Pooja M Patel; Leanora W Merwin; Kye P Poronsky; Anna L Caroll; Carol Sánchez Santana; Maggie Breslin; Charles D Scales; Peter K Lindenauer; Kathleen M Mazor; Erik P Hess Journal: Acad Emerg Med Date: 2020-02-16 Impact factor: 3.451
Authors: Kimberly A Fisher; Andy S L Tan; Daniel D Matlock; Barry Saver; Kathleen M Mazor; Arwen H Pieterse Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2018-08-06
Authors: Jada G Hamilton; Sarah E Lillie; Dana L Alden; Laura Scherer; Megan Oser; Christine Rini; Miho Tanaka; John Baleix; Mikki Brewster; Simon Craddock Lee; Mary K Goldstein; Robert M Jacobson; Ronald E Myers; Brian J Zikmund-Fisher; Erika A Waters Journal: J Behav Med Date: 2016-08-26