Jennifer Watermeyer1. 1. Health Communication Research Unit, School of Human and Community Development, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Talking with a child about their HIV status is a complex, emotionally laden and difficult task for caregivers and healthcare providers. Disclosure is an important process which may have psychosocial and health benefits. Despite existing guidelines and materials, disclosure does not always happen for various reasons. OBJECTIVE: This qualitative study explored a healthcare team's perspectives and experiences about disclosure practices. METHODS: Three focus groups were conducted with a total of 23 healthcare providers at a paediatric clinic in South Africa. The data were analysed using principles of thematic analysis. RESULTS: Results confirm the complexity of the disclosure process and highlight confusion, hesitancy and ethical dilemmas regarding disclosure practices. Tensions were noted within the team which seem linked to professional hierarchies. Counsellors and nurses preferred an indirect approach of encouraging caregivers to disclose to their children and providing psychosocial support, while doctors tended to become more directly involved in disclosing to children out of a sense of duty, legal responsibilities and knowledge of the child's rights. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates how the complexities of disclosure with children and adolescents bring about additional challenges for healthcare teams. The legal and ethical implications as well as the roles and responsibilities of healthcare providers with disclosure remain unclear. Several recommendations for practice and policy emerge from this study, related particularly to the need for clarification of disclosure guidelines and legal implications. Implications for the healthcare team are also discussed.
BACKGROUND: Talking with a child about their HIV status is a complex, emotionally laden and difficult task for caregivers and healthcare providers. Disclosure is an important process which may have psychosocial and health benefits. Despite existing guidelines and materials, disclosure does not always happen for various reasons. OBJECTIVE: This qualitative study explored a healthcare team's perspectives and experiences about disclosure practices. METHODS: Three focus groups were conducted with a total of 23 healthcare providers at a paediatric clinic in South Africa. The data were analysed using principles of thematic analysis. RESULTS: Results confirm the complexity of the disclosure process and highlight confusion, hesitancy and ethical dilemmas regarding disclosure practices. Tensions were noted within the team which seem linked to professional hierarchies. Counsellors and nurses preferred an indirect approach of encouraging caregivers to disclose to their children and providing psychosocial support, while doctors tended to become more directly involved in disclosing to children out of a sense of duty, legal responsibilities and knowledge of the child's rights. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates how the complexities of disclosure with children and adolescents bring about additional challenges for healthcare teams. The legal and ethical implications as well as the roles and responsibilities of healthcare providers with disclosure remain unclear. Several recommendations for practice and policy emerge from this study, related particularly to the need for clarification of disclosure guidelines and legal implications. Implications for the healthcare team are also discussed.
Authors: Lara M E Vaz; Suzanne Maman; Eugenia Eng; Oscar A Barbarin; Tomi Tshikandu; Frieda Behets Journal: J Dev Behav Pediatr Date: 2011-05 Impact factor: 2.225
Authors: Amina Abubakar; Fons J R Van de Vijver; Ronald Fischer; Amin S Hassan; Joseph K Gona; Judith Tumaini Dzombo; Grace Bomu; Khamis Katana; Charles R Newton Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2016-02-29 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Adellah Sariah; Joan Rugemalila; Magreat Somba; Anna Minja; Margareth Makuchilo; Edith Tarimo; David Urassa; Helen Siril Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2016-10-13 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Seth Christopher Yaw Appiah; Inge Kroidl; Michael Hoelscher; Olena Ivanova; Jonathan Mensah Dapaah Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2019-02-18 Impact factor: 3.390