OBJECTIVE: Functional magnetic resonance imaging is sensitive to the variation in language network patterns. Large populations are needed to rigorously assess atypical patterns, which, even in neurological populations, are a minority. METHODS: We studied 220 patients with focal epilepsy and 118 healthy volunteers who performed an auditory description decision task. We compared a data-driven hierarchical clustering approach to the commonly used a priori laterality index (LI) threshold (LI < 0.20 as atypical) to classify language patterns within frontal and temporal regions of interest. We explored (n = 128) whether IQ varied with different language activation patterns. RESULTS: The rate of atypical language among healthy volunteers (2.5%) and patients (24.5%) agreed with previous studies; however, we found 6 patterns of atypical language: a symmetrically bilateral, 2 unilaterally crossed, and 3 right dominant patterns. There was high agreement between classification methods, yet the cluster analysis revealed novel correlations with clinical features. Beyond the established association of left-handedness, early seizure onset, and vascular pathology with atypical language, cluster analysis identified an association of handedness with frontal lateralization, early seizure onset with temporal lateralization, and left hemisphere focus with a unilateral right pattern. Intelligence quotient was not significantly different among patterns. INTERPRETATION: Language dominance is a continuum; however, our results demonstrate meaningful thresholds in classifying laterality. Atypical language patterns are less frequent but more variable than typical language patterns, posing challenges for accurate presurgical planning. Language dominance should be assessed on a regional rather than hemispheric basis, and clinical characteristics should inform evaluation of atypical language dominance. Reorganization of language is not uniformly detrimental to language functioning.
OBJECTIVE: Functional magnetic resonance imaging is sensitive to the variation in language network patterns. Large populations are needed to rigorously assess atypical patterns, which, even in neurological populations, are a minority. METHODS: We studied 220 patients with focal epilepsy and 118 healthy volunteers who performed an auditory description decision task. We compared a data-driven hierarchical clustering approach to the commonly used a priori laterality index (LI) threshold (LI < 0.20 as atypical) to classify language patterns within frontal and temporal regions of interest. We explored (n = 128) whether IQ varied with different language activation patterns. RESULTS: The rate of atypical language among healthy volunteers (2.5%) and patients (24.5%) agreed with previous studies; however, we found 6 patterns of atypical language: a symmetrically bilateral, 2 unilaterally crossed, and 3 right dominant patterns. There was high agreement between classification methods, yet the cluster analysis revealed novel correlations with clinical features. Beyond the established association of left-handedness, early seizure onset, and vascular pathology with atypical language, cluster analysis identified an association of handedness with frontal lateralization, early seizure onset with temporal lateralization, and left hemisphere focus with a unilateral right pattern. Intelligence quotient was not significantly different among patterns. INTERPRETATION: Language dominance is a continuum; however, our results demonstrate meaningful thresholds in classifying laterality. Atypical language patterns are less frequent but more variable than typical language patterns, posing challenges for accurate presurgical planning. Language dominance should be assessed on a regional rather than hemispheric basis, and clinical characteristics should inform evaluation of atypical language dominance. Reorganization of language is not uniformly detrimental to language functioning.
Authors: Elizabeth R Sowell; Paul M Thompson; Christiana M Leonard; Suzanne E Welcome; Eric Kan; Arthur W Toga Journal: J Neurosci Date: 2004-09-22 Impact factor: 6.167
Authors: Xiaozhen You; Malek Adjouadi; Magno R Guillen; Melvin Ayala; Armando Barreto; Naphtali Rishe; Joseph Sullivan; Dennis Dlugos; John Vanmeter; Drew Morris; Elizabeth Donner; Bruce Bjornson; Mary Lou Smith; Byron Bernal; Madison Berl; William D Gaillard Journal: Hum Brain Mapp Date: 2011-05 Impact factor: 5.038
Authors: D W Loring; K J Meador; G P Lee; A M Murro; J R Smith; H F Flanigin; B B Gallagher; D W King Journal: Neuropsychologia Date: 1990 Impact factor: 3.139
Authors: Jagriti Arora; Kenneth Pugh; Michael Westerveld; Susan Spencer; Dennis D Spencer; R Todd Constable Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2009-06-01 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: L R Rosenberger; J Zeck; M M Berl; E N Moore; E K Ritzl; S Shamim; S L Weinstein; J A Conry; P L Pearl; S Sato; L G Vezina; W H Theodore; W D Gaillard Journal: Neurology Date: 2009-05-26 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Silvia B Bonelli; Pamela J Thompson; Mahinda Yogarajah; Christian Vollmar; Robert H W Powell; Mark R Symms; Andrew W McEvoy; Caroline Micallef; Matthias J Koepp; John S Duncan Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2012-03-16 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Leigh N Sepeta; Madison M Berl; Marko Wilke; Xiaozhen You; Meera Mehta; Benjamin Xu; Sara Inati; Irene Dustin; Omar Khan; Alison Austermuehle; William H Theodore; William D Gaillard Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2015-12-23 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Xiaozhen You; Ashley N Zachery; Eleanor J Fanto; Gina Norato; Sierra C Germeyan; Eric J Emery; Leigh N Sepeta; Madison M Berl; Chelsea L Black; Edythe Wiggs; Kareem Zaghloul; Sara K Inati; William D Gaillard; William H Theodore Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2019-02-11 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Rachel Rolinski; Alison Austermuehle; Edythe Wiggs; Shubhi Agrawal; Leigh N Sepeta; William D Gaillard; Kareem A Zaghloul; Sara K Inati; William H Theodore Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2019-02-11 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Yu-Hsuan A Chang; Nobuko Kemmotsu; Kelly M Leyden; N Erkut Kucukboyaci; Vicente J Iragui; Evelyn S Tecoma; Leena Kansal; Marc A Norman; Rachelle Compton; Tobin J Ehrlich; Vedang S Uttarwar; Anny Reyes; Brianna M Paul; Carrie R McDonald Journal: Brain Lang Date: 2017-04-20 Impact factor: 2.381
Authors: Matthew N DeSalvo; Naoaki Tanaka; Linda Douw; Catherine L Leveroni; Bradley R Buchbinder; Douglas N Greve; Steven M Stufflebeam Journal: Radiology Date: 2016-07-28 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Anas Salah Eddin; Jin Wang; Wensong Wu; Saman Sargolzaei; Bruce Bjornson; Richard A Jones; William D Gaillard; Malek Adjouadi Journal: Hum Brain Mapp Date: 2014-07-31 Impact factor: 5.038