Yin Paradies1, Mandy Truong, Naomi Priest. 1. Centre for Citizenship and Globalisation, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Burwood Hwy, Burwood, 3125, Victoria, Australia, yin.paradies@deakin.edu.au.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although considered a key driver of racial disparities in healthcare, relatively little is known about the extent of interpersonal racism perpetrated by healthcare providers, nor is there a good understanding of how best to measure such racism. OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews worldwide evidence (from 1995 onwards) for racism among healthcare providers; as well as comparing existing measurement approaches to emerging best practice, it focuses on the assessment of interpersonal racism, rather than internalized or systemic/institutional racism. METHODS: The following databases and electronic journal collections were searched for articles published between 1995 and 2012: Medline, CINAHL, PsycInfo, Sociological Abstracts. Included studies were published empirical studies of any design measuring and/or reporting on healthcare provider racism in the English language. Data on study design and objectives; method of measurement, constructs measured, type of tool; study population and healthcare setting; country and language of study; and study outcomes were extracted from each study. RESULTS: The 37 studies included in this review were almost solely conducted in the U.S. and with physicians. Statistically significant evidence of racist beliefs, emotions or practices among healthcare providers in relation to minority groups was evident in 26 of these studies. Although a number of measurement approaches were utilized, a limited range of constructs was assessed. CONCLUSION: Despite burgeoning interest in racism as a contributor to racial disparities in healthcare, we still know little about the extent of healthcare provider racism or how best to measure it. Studies using more sophisticated approaches to assess healthcare provider racism are required to inform interventions aimed at reducing racial disparities in health.
BACKGROUND: Although considered a key driver of racial disparities in healthcare, relatively little is known about the extent of interpersonal racism perpetrated by healthcare providers, nor is there a good understanding of how best to measure such racism. OBJECTIVES: This paper reviews worldwide evidence (from 1995 onwards) for racism among healthcare providers; as well as comparing existing measurement approaches to emerging best practice, it focuses on the assessment of interpersonal racism, rather than internalized or systemic/institutional racism. METHODS: The following databases and electronic journal collections were searched for articles published between 1995 and 2012: Medline, CINAHL, PsycInfo, Sociological Abstracts. Included studies were published empirical studies of any design measuring and/or reporting on healthcare provider racism in the English language. Data on study design and objectives; method of measurement, constructs measured, type of tool; study population and healthcare setting; country and language of study; and study outcomes were extracted from each study. RESULTS: The 37 studies included in this review were almost solely conducted in the U.S. and with physicians. Statistically significant evidence of racist beliefs, emotions or practices among healthcare providers in relation to minority groups was evident in 26 of these studies. Although a number of measurement approaches were utilized, a limited range of constructs was assessed. CONCLUSION: Despite burgeoning interest in racism as a contributor to racial disparities in healthcare, we still know little about the extent of healthcare provider racism or how best to measure it. Studies using more sophisticated approaches to assess healthcare provider racism are required to inform interventions aimed at reducing racial disparities in health.
Authors: J B McKinlay; R B Burns; R Durante; H A Feldman; K M Freund; B S Harrow; J T Irish; L E Kasten; M A Moskowitz Journal: J Eval Clin Pract Date: 1997-02 Impact factor: 2.431
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Tessa V West; Samuel L Gaertner; Terrance L Albrecht; Rhonda K Dailey; Tsveti Markova Journal: J Exp Soc Psychol Date: 2010-03-01
Authors: Vickie L Shavers; Pebbles Fagan; Dionne Jones; William M P Klein; Josephine Boyington; Carmen Moten; Edward Rorie Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2012-05 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Helen C Kales; Harold W Neighbors; Marcia Valenstein; Frederic C Blow; John F McCarthy; Rosalinda V Ignacio; Kiran K-K Taylor; Leah Gillon; Alan M Mellow Journal: J Am Geriatr Soc Date: 2005-05 Impact factor: 5.562
Authors: K A Schulman; J A Berlin; W Harless; J F Kerner; S Sistrunk; B J Gersh; R Dubé; C K Taleghani; J E Burke; S Williams; J M Eisenberg; J J Escarce Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1999-02-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Ejim Sule; Ryan M Sutton; Debbie Jones; Ramel Moore; Imaculata Igbo; Lovell A Jones Journal: J Racial Ethn Health Disparities Date: 2017-01-11
Authors: Robert L Williams; Crystal Romney; Miria Kano; Randy Wright; Betty Skipper; Christina M Getrich; Andrew L Sussman; Stephen J Zyzanski Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2015-01-27 Impact factor: 5.128