PURPOSE: To compare 2 strategies, stage-matched nursing and community intervention (SMN+CI) and community intervention (CI) alone in changing cardiovascular risk factors in up to 3 behavioral areas: diet, physical activity, and/or smoking among rural women. METHODS: A 14-month, multisite randomized controlled trial of 117 rural women was conducted. Transtheoretical model was used in identification of stage of change and development of the SMN+CI nursing interventions. A social-ecological model was used to address issues of rurality in the development of interventions. FINDINGS: The SMN + CI group was superior on 4 outcomes. There were significant increases in 2 measures of dietary intake; improvement in dietary stage of change for fruits and vegetables; and reduced diastolic blood pressure (DBP) in the SMN + CI group. After log transformation DBP significance was lost. The CI group had a significant reduction in change in total cholesterol; however, significance was lost after control for the initiation of lipid lowering medications. There was a significant reduction in Framingham risk scores pre- to postintervention, regardless of group. CONCLUSIONS: There continues to be a need to improve cardiovascular risk factors in rural women. There should be an exploration of whether intensified dose and fidelity of the intervention strategies of diet and physical activity are effective in improving anthropometric and laboratory values. Further investigation is warranted into factors influencing the pre- to postreduction in Framingham risk scores.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To compare 2 strategies, stage-matched nursing and community intervention (SMN+CI) and community intervention (CI) alone in changing cardiovascular risk factors in up to 3 behavioral areas: diet, physical activity, and/or smoking among rural women. METHODS: A 14-month, multisite randomized controlled trial of 117 rural women was conducted. Transtheoretical model was used in identification of stage of change and development of the SMN+CI nursing interventions. A social-ecological model was used to address issues of rurality in the development of interventions. FINDINGS: The SMN + CI group was superior on 4 outcomes. There were significant increases in 2 measures of dietary intake; improvement in dietary stage of change for fruits and vegetables; and reduced diastolic blood pressure (DBP) in the SMN + CI group. After log transformation DBP significance was lost. The CI group had a significant reduction in change in total cholesterol; however, significance was lost after control for the initiation of lipid lowering medications. There was a significant reduction in Framingham risk scores pre- to postintervention, regardless of group. CONCLUSIONS: There continues to be a need to improve cardiovascular risk factors in rural women. There should be an exploration of whether intensified dose and fidelity of the intervention strategies of diet and physical activity are effective in improving anthropometric and laboratory values. Further investigation is warranted into factors influencing the pre- to postreduction in Framingham risk scores.
Authors: F E Thompson; V Kipnis; A F Subar; S M Krebs-Smith; L L Kahle; D Midthune; N Potischman; A Schatzkin Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2000-06 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Annie L Culver; Ira S Ockene; Raji Balasubramanian; Barbara C Olendzki; Deidre M Sepavich; Jean Wactawski-Wende; Joann E Manson; Yongxia Qiao; Simin Liu; Philip A Merriam; Catherine Rahilly-Tierny; Fridtjof Thomas; Jeffrey S Berger; Judith K Ockene; J David Curb; Yunsheng Ma Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2012-01-09
Authors: Linda Bullock; Kevin D Everett; Patricia Dolan Mullen; Elizabeth Geden; Daniel R Longo; Richard Madsen Journal: Matern Child Health J Date: 2008-05-22
Authors: Frances E Thompson; Douglas Midthune; Amy F Subar; Lisa L Kahle; Arthur Schatzkin; Victor Kipnis Journal: Public Health Nutr Date: 2004-12 Impact factor: 4.022
Authors: Rebecca A Seguin-Fowler; David Strogatz; Meredith L Graham; Galen D Eldridge; Grace A Marshall; Sara C Folta; Kristin Pullyblank; Miriam E Nelson; Lynn Paul Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2020-05-07 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: Kristin Pullyblank; David Strogatz; Sara C Folta; Lynn Paul; Miriam E Nelson; Meredith Graham; Grace A Marshall; Galen Eldridge; Stephen A Parry; Sean Mebust; Rebecca A Seguin Journal: J Rural Health Date: 2019-03-13 Impact factor: 4.333
Authors: Stacey L Schepens Niemiec; Jeanine Blanchard; Cheryl L P Vigen; Jenny Martínez; Laura Guzmán; Alyssa Concha; Michelle Fluke; Mike Carlson Journal: Prim Health Care Res Dev Date: 2018-05-06 Impact factor: 1.458