Literature DB >> 23793025

Genome-wide meta-analysis identifies new susceptibility loci for migraine.

Verneri Anttila1,2,3,4, Bendik S Winsvold1,5, Padhraig Gormley1, Tobias Kurth6,7,8, Francesco Bettella9, George McMahon10, Mikko Kallela11, Rainer Malik12, Boukje de Vries13, Gisela Terwindt14, Sarah E Medland15, Unda Todt16, Wendy L McArdle10, Lydia Quaye17, Markku Koiranen18, M Arfan Ikram19,20,21, Terho Lehtimäki22, Anine H Stam14, Lannie Ligthart23,24, Juho Wedenoja25, Ian Dunham26, Benjamin M Neale3,4, Priit Palta1,2, Eija Hamalainen1,2, Markus Schürks27, Lynda M Rose8, Julie E Buring8, Paul M Ridker8,28, Stacy Steinberg9, Hreinn Stefansson9, Finnbogi Jakobsson29, Debbie A Lawlor10, David M Evans10, Susan M Ring10, Markus Färkkilä11, Ville Artto11, Mari A Kaunisto2,30, Tobias Freilinger12,31, Jean Schoenen32, Rune R Frants13, Nadine Pelzer14, Claudia M Weller13, Ronald Zielman14, Andrew C Heath33, Pamela A F Madden33, Grant W Montgomery15, Nicholas G Martin15, Guntram Borck16, Hartmut Göbel34, Axel Heinze34, Katja Heinze-Kuhn34, Frances M K Williams17, Anna-Liisa Hartikainen35, Anneli Pouta18,35,36, Joyce van den Ende19, Andre G Uitterlinden37, Albert Hofman38, Najaf Amin19, Jouke-Jan Hottenga23, Jacqueline M Vink23, Kauko Heikkilä25, Michael Alexander39,40, Bertram Muller-Myhsok41,42, Stefan Schreiber43,44, Thomas Meitinger45,46, Heinz Erich Wichmann47,48,49, Arpo Aromaa50, Johan G Eriksson30,50,51,52,53, Bryan Traynor54, Daniah Trabzuni55,56, Elizabeth Rossin3,4,57, Kasper Lage3,4,58,59,60, Suzanne B R Jacobs4, J Raphael Gibbs54,55, Ewan Birney26, Jaakko Kaprio2,61,25, Brenda W Penninx62,24,63,64, Dorret I Boomsma23, Cornelia van Duijn19, Olli Raitakari65,66, Marjo-Riitta Jarvelin67,18,68,36, John-Anker Zwart5, Lynn Cherkas17, David P Strachan69, Christian Kubisch16, Michel D Ferrari14, Arn M J M van den Maagdenberg13,14, Martin Dichgans12,42, Maija Wessman2,30, George Davey Smith10, Kari Stefansson9,70, Mark J Daly3,4, Dale R Nyholt15, Daniel Chasman8,28, Aarno Palotie1,2,4.   

Abstract

Migraine is the most common brain disorder, affecting approximately 14% of the adult population, but its molecular mechanisms are poorly understood. We report the results of a meta-analysis across 29 genome-wide association studies, including a total of 23,285 individuals with migraine (cases) and 95,425 population-matched controls. We identified 12 loci associated with migraine susceptibility (P<5×10(-8)). Five loci are new: near AJAP1 at 1p36, near TSPAN2 at 1p13, within FHL5 at 6q16, within C7orf10 at 7p14 and near MMP16 at 8q21. Three of these loci were identified in disease subgroup analyses. Brain tissue expression quantitative trait locus analysis suggests potential functional candidate genes at four loci: APOA1BP, TBC1D7, FUT9, STAT6 and ATP5B.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2013        PMID: 23793025      PMCID: PMC4041123          DOI: 10.1038/ng.2676

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Nat Genet        ISSN: 1061-4036            Impact factor:   38.330


Migraine is the most common brain disorder, affecting approximately 14% of the adult population, but its molecular mechanisms are poorly understood. We report the results of a meta-analysis across 29 genome-wide association studies, including a total of 23 285 migraine cases and 95 425 population-matched controls. We identified 12 loci associated with migraine susceptibility (P < 5 × 10−8). Five loci are new (near AJAP1 on 1p36, near TSPAN2 on 1p13, within FHL5 on 6q16, within c7orf10 on 7p14, and near MMP16 on 8q21). Three of these loci were identified in disease subgroup analyses. Brain tissue eQTL analysis suggests potential functional candidate genes at four loci: APOA1BP, TBC1D7, FUT9, STAT6, and ATP5B. Recently, significant progress has been made in the identification of common genetic variants associated with migraine susceptibility through genome-wide association (GWA) studies of clinic-based migraine with aura (MA) patients[1], migraineurs from the general population[2,3], and clinic-based migraine without aura (MO) patients[4]. To further elucidate the genetic susceptibility of migraine, we performed a meta-analysis of 23 285 individuals with migraine from 29 clinic- and population-based studies (Fig. 1, Supplementary Fig. 1, Supplementary Note). These include 5 175 cases from five clinic-based patient collections, matched to 13 972 population-based controls (Supplementary Table 1), as well as 18 110 cases from 14 population-based studies and 81 453 migraine-free or control individuals from the same studies (Supplementary Table 2). Results from GWA studies of the five clinic-based collections[1,4] and four of the population-based collections[2,3] have been previously reported (Supplementary Fig. 2).
Figure 1

Description of the studies comprising the International Migraine Genetics Meta-analysis Consortium, and their sample contributions to each analysis

Each coloured box corresponds to one analysed phenotype and lists the total number of cases and controls, as well as the sample contributions of individual cohorts. Participation in each analysis depended on the availability of the data in question and the recruitment method.

In addition to the primary meta-analysis using all available genotype data, three subgroup analyses were performed in those cohorts where sufficient additional clinical information was available (Supplementary Table 3). The first two subgroups consisted of migraine cases fulfilling the International Headache Society diagnostic criteria[5] for either MA or MO. The third subgroup included only the clinic-based samples, under the hypothesis that they represent a group of migraineurs more enriched for severe migraines than cases identified from the general population. Results from the primary meta-analysis and the three subgroups identify 142 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), at a total of 12 loci, to be significantly associated with migraine susceptibility (Table 1, Supplementary Fig. 3,4). Eight of those loci contain SNPs that lie within a known transcript. In addition, 1 168 SNPs at 134 loci (Supplementary Table 4) showed suggestive association to migraine, again combining the primary analysis and the three subgroup analyses. The single most significant P value overall was observed for rs11172113 in the primary analysis (P value 2.69 × 10−19; Fig. 2a, Table 1) at the LRP1 locus on 12q13.
Table 1

Results of the association analyses

SNPChrPositionLocationGeneMinor alleleMAFP-valueOR (95% CI)q/p-value I 2 Group or subgroup with the lowest p-valueAdditional significance in
rs265189913,073,572Genic PRDM16 * C0.413.28 × 10−141.09 (1.07-1.12)0.21420%All samples
rs1091543714,082,866Intergenic near AJAP1 G0.362.81 × 10−80.86 (0.82-0.91)0.10847%Clinics only
rs121344931115,479,469Intergenic near TSPAN2 A0.466.71 × 10−141.14 (1.10-1.18)0.48014%All samples
rs22743161154,712,866Genic MEF2D * C0.373.14 × 10−81.07 (1.04-1.09)0.02145%All samples
rs75772622234,483,608Genic TRPM8 * A0.103.27 × 10−130.87 (0.84-0.90)0.07033%All samplesClinics only, MO only
rs6790925330,455,089Intergenic near TGFBR2 * T0.382.16 × 10−81.15 (1.10-1.21)0.7800%Clinics only
rs9349379613,011,943Genic PHACTR1 * G0.402.81 × 10−100.86 (0.82-0.90)0.4430%MO onlyAll samples
rs13208321696,967,075Genic FHL5 A0.222.15 × 10−121.18 (1.13-1.24)0.1680%All samplesMO only
rs4379368740,432,725Genic c7orf10 T0.121.46 × 10−91.11 (1.08-1.15)0.4412%All samplesMO only
rs10504861889,617,048Intergenic near MMP16 T0.161.32 × 10−80.86 (0.81-0.90)0.7550%MO only
rs64782419118,292,450Genic ASTN2 * A0.381.04 × 10−91.16 (1.11-1.22)0.6460%Clinics onlyAll samples
rs111721131255,813,550Genic LRP1 * C0.432.69 × 10−190.90 (0.88-0.92)0.18822%All samplesMO only

When multiple subgroups show significant association, P values and odds ratios (OR) are shown for the analysis with the lowest P value. ORs reported for the minor allele. Chromosomal positions are based on NCBI build 36. In the Location and Gene columns, SNPs located within the gene transcript (‘Genic’) list that gene, while for intergenic SNPs (‘Intergenic’) the gene reported for that locus is listed.

Previously identified migraine locus. MAF – minor allele frequency. q/p value - P value from Cochran’s heterogeneity statistic. I2 – heterogeneity index. MO – migraine without aura.

Figure 2

Manhattan plot of the results of the meta-analysis

Results of the meta-analysis of all migraine cases, of any migraine subtype or recruiting method, versus all available controls, adjusting for gender. Red dots indicate SNPs with significant (< 5 × 10−8) P values.

A) All migraine (23 285 cases, 95 425 controls)

B) Clinic-based studies only (5 175 cases, 13 972 controls)

C) Migraine with aura (5 118 cases, 74 239 controls)

D) Migraine without aura (7 107 cases, 69 427 controls)

Five of the 12 genome-wide significant loci are new (near AJAP1, near TSPAN2, FHL5, c7orf10, and near MMP16), while seven confirm previously reported migraine loci (PRDM16[, near TGFBR2[, and LRP1[). All seven previously reported loci seen in this study remained significant (all p < 6.25 × 10−3, correcting for eight previously reported loci) in analyses that exclude samples used in previous reports[1,2,4] (Supplementary Fig. 5 and Supplementary Table 5). Among the newly identified loci, two contain SNPs with significant association that are located within known transcripts. On 6q16, FHL5 encodes a transcription factor that regulates cAMP responsive elements CREM and CREB[6], which play a role in synaptic plasticity[7] and memory formation[8]. The locus also overlaps KIAA0776, which encodes a hypothetical protein also known as UFL1. On 7p14, mutations in c7orf10 have been found in phenotypically mild or even clinically asymptomatic forms of glutaric aciduria type III[9], a rare metabolic abnormality leading to persistent excretion of glutaric acid. The novel loci on 1p36, 1p13, and 8q21 are located outside known transcripts. On 1p36, rs10915437 is located approximately 500 kb telomeric from AJAP1 and approximately 300kb centromeric from a gene cluster encoding the apoptosis-related proteins DFFB and TP73 as well as centrosomal protein CEP104. AJAP1 is expressed in brain (Supplementary Fig. 6) and has been associated with tumor invasion and regulation of metalloproteinase activity[10]. On 1p13, rs12134493 is located 87 kb 5′ of TSPAN2, a member of the tetraspanin family, encoding a cell surface protein that mediates signal transduction events involved in the regulation of cell development, activation, growth and motility[11]. TSPAN2 has further been shown to act as a regulator of metalloproteinase activity[11]. On 8q21, rs10504861 is located 200 kb telomeric from matrix metalloproteinase MMP16. Members of the metalloproteinase family are widely expressed in human tissues and are involved in the breakdown of extracellular matrix in normal physiological processes. Notably, the protein encoded by MMP16 (MT-MMP2) cleaves LRP1[12], encoded by a previously reported migraine gene[2]. In addition, MMP16 has recently been shown to be involved in basal NgR1 (Nogo-66 receptor) shedding in cortical neurons, thereby increasing axonal and synaptic plasticity[13]. Four of the twelve loci (near AJAP1, near TGFBR2, PHACTR1, near MMP16), including two of the novel associations, were identified exclusively in the subgroup analyses (Table 1 and Supplementary Table 4). Two of the loci (rs9349379 in PHACTR1 on 6p21, and rs10504861 near MMP16 on 8q21) reached genome-wide significance only in MO, while no SNPs reached genome-wide significance in MA (Fig. 2c, d). The lowest P value in MA was with SNP rs7015657 (p = 7.88 × 10−8), which is located approximately 582 kb 3′ from GFRA2, a member of the glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor family. A similar subgroup analysis was performed in only those samples that originate from specialized migraine clinics. Two loci with suggestive association in the primary analysis, rs6790925 (near TGFBR2) and rs6478241 (ASTN2), reached genome-wide significance in the clinic-based subgroup (Table 1 and Supplementary Tables 6,7). All of the 12 genome-wide significant loci associated with migraine had larger estimated effect sizes in the clinic-based subgroup compared to the primary (All) analysis (Supplementary Table 6, 7). A two-tailed binomial test shows the chance of observing larger effects at all 12 loci is significantly different from that expected by chance (P = 4.88 × 10−4). Among all reported loci (P <1 × 10−5), only the clinic-based group showed a number of associated SNPs with higher effect sizes (OR > 1.2) at low frequency (MAF < 0.05; Supplementary Fig. 7). Thus, clinic-based migraine samples may represent a promising subgroup to help prioritise loci in the search for low frequency variants with moderate effects. Overall, among the 146 loci identified, twice as many have causative minor alleles over protective ones (with the ratio increasing towards the lower minor allele frequencies). To explore the biological context for the identified loci we examined the properties of the most proximal genes to the 12 genome-wide significant top SNPs (Table 1). In expression data from 55 269 samples profiled using the Affymetrix HG-U133 Plus 2.0 microarray (including 1 990 brain and 384 endothelial samples), 11 of the 12 genes nearest to the identified loci (all except FHL5) were at least moderately (>20% of samples of the tissue showing a normalized log2 expression value greater than 6; see Methods) expressed in disease-relevant brain regions (Supplementary Fig. 6). In contrast, only TGFBR2 and MEF2D show moderate or greater expression in the endothelial samples. Possibly reflecting known co-morbidity between migraine and cardiovascular disease[14], two of the 12 most proximal genes (TGFBR2 and PHACTR1) have also been associated with cardiovascular traits: TGFBR2 mutations have been reported to cause monogenic Marfan’s syndrome[15] and to be involved in abdominal aortic aneurysms[16], while PHACTR1 is associated with early onset myocardial infarction[17]. TSPAN2[18], MEF2D[19], TRPM8[20], TGFBR2[21], PHACTR1[22], MMP16[23], ASTN2[24], and LRP1[25] have been suggested to have functions in synaptic formation or regulation; PRDM16 has been linked to oxidative stress response, and AJAP1 in maintaining tissue borders (Supplementary Fig. 8). To identify possible non-proximity based genes underlying these associations, we examined eQTL data among 394 samples of brain tissue from the North American Brain Expression Consortium and the UK Brain Expression Consortium. Among the 12 regions with significant association to migraine, four were found to contain significant eQTLs (see Methods) among the SNP-probe pairs within the tested brain samples (four in the frontal cortex, one in the cerebellum; Table 2). On chromosome 1, rs12136718 is an eQTL for APOA1BP, rather than the gene closest to it, MEF2D. APOA1BP is widely expressed and is potentially linked with cholesterol efflux from cells[26]. On chromosome 6, rs35128104 is an eQTL for FUT9, encoding α1,3-fucosyl transferase IX. The FUT9 enzyme synthesizes the Lewis X (Lex) carbohydrate structure, which has been implicated in neurite outgrowth in several types of brain neuronal cells[27-29]. At the chromosome 12 locus, two different eQTLs in brain tissue were found within the peak, for STAT6 (rs4559) and for ATP5B (rs113953523), the former at a very robust P-value (2.16 × 10−22). The STAT genes are known for transducing activation signals to transcription factors in macrophages[30], and STAT6 phosphorylation has recently been shown to sense oxidative stress in astrocytes resulting in prostaglandin release[31]. A second eQTL gene at the same locus, ATP5B, is the β subunit of the mitochondrial ATP synthase, but a potential specific role in neuronal or vascular cells is not known. Finally, on chromosome 6, rs9349379 is an eQTL in cerebellar tissue for TBC1D7, that potentially down regulates the tuberous sclerosis gene, TSC1, through a positive regulation of the mTOR-signalling pathway[32]. In the central nervous system, TSC1/2 signalling contributes to neural connectivity via its multi-faceted roles[33]. Based on the available data it is not possible to decide whether a gene identified by the eQTL analysis or the gene closest to the strongest positional association is the most relevant gene contributing to migraine pathogenesis.
Table 2

Significant eQTLs observed in 394 samples of two different brain tissue at loci significantly associated with migraine

Frontal cortex
ChrPosition (bp)LocusProbeGene nameSNPs with sign.eQTL withprobeSNP withlowest eQTLp-valueLowest eQTLp-valueHighest LDwith reportedSNPSNPs with sign.eQTL withprobe
1154,830,352 MEF2D ILMN_1729533 APOA1BP 1 rs12136718 2.18 × 10−5 0.38 0
613,413,333 PHACTR1 ILMN_1661622 TBC1D7 0--- 1
696,769,539 FHL5 ILMN_1878007 FUT9 2 rs35128104 5.96 × 10−5 0.74 0
1255,775,568 LRP1 ILMN_1763198 STAT6 40 rs4559 2.16 × 10−22 1 -
1255,318,337 LRP1 ILMN_1772132 ATP5B 1 rs113953523 1.62 × 10−4 0.39 0

-Chr – chromosome. All basepair positions are given for build 36/hg18. ‘Highest LD…’ column indicates the maximum extent of LD observed between a significant eQTL SNP-probe pair (see Methods), and a SNP passing the reporting threshold (p< × 10−5) for association with migraine. Due to multiple overlapping signals, the HLA region has been excluded from the analysis.

In a hypersensitivity site analysis, associated SNPs in the migraine loci were found to occur significantly more often in DNAse I hypersensitivity sites in a number of tissues (Supplementary Fig. 9). This suggests that the loci associated with migraine are enriched for actively transcribed regions, supporting a regulatory role for the variants. Both neuronal and vascular tissue types carry an enriched set of sites within the detected loci. In addition, querying the RegulomeDB (see URLs) showed that several of the associated SNPs were found to overlap directly with known transcription factor binding motifs (Supplementary Table 8). The number of significantly associated loci is still modest to form a broad understanding of the disease susceptibility, and any proposed functional hypothesis from the identified loci must thus be taken with caution. Some functional hypotheses could be inferred from the results of this study, as the majority of the identified loci harbour genes that can be linked to neuronal function. The eQTL analysis further supported that regulatory effects in brain tissue may underlie several of the association signals. However, the lack of replication across brain regions suggests that our ability to use the eQTL data to pinpoint the functionally most significant gene within the locus is limited. The observed difference between the number of significant loci in the MO and MA groups (6 vs 0, respectively; Fig. 2c, d) despite reasonably similar sample sizes was somewhat unexpected. MA has been shown to have a considerably higher heritability estimate and sibling recurrence risk than MO (3.8 vs 1.9), and has thus been considered to be the more heritable of the two common migraine types[34]. One possible explanation could be that the genetic susceptibility to MA is mediated more by rare variants with larger effect sizes, although this remains speculative. Another explanation for the difference may be a higher degree of heterogeneity among the MA cases (due to genetically distinct subgroups, for example). No common variants specifically predisposing to aura were identified by this study (the lowest observed P-value was p = 7.88 × 10−8). In summary, we conducted a large migraine meta-analysis and identified 12 loci associated with migraine susceptibility, including five loci not previously associated with migraine, as well as 134 additional suggestive loci. An eQTL analysis of brain tissue highlighted a further five genes potentially implicated in migraine susceptibility. Two of the 12 loci were observed only in the clinic-based sample group, possibly suggesting more specificity to severe migraine headache, and two only in the MO group. Seven previously reported loci for migraine susceptibility were replicated in independent samples in this study. The difference in the number of identified loci and the strength of association suggest that the genetic background of MA is considerably less influenced by common variants than that of MO, contrary to previous expectations. Finally, while pathway analysis of the 146 loci showed no concentration in any particular pathway or tissue, eight of the 12 identified loci are located in or immediately outside genes with known function in synaptic or neuronal regulation and several of them exert regulatory control on one another.

Methods

Overall study design

For this meta-analysis, we used SNP marker data from 23 285 cases and 95 425 controls of European descent from 29 studies, including five clinic-based studies compared to population-matched control samples with unknown migraine status, as well as 14 entirely population-based cohorts. Four of the population-based cohorts (the B58C, NFBC, Young Finns and FinnTwin; see Supplementary Note for further details) were birth cohorts. The datasets for the meta-analysis included previously genotyped genome-wide association (GWA) study data from migraine-specific studies by the International Headache Genetics Consortium (see URLs) studies and the Women’s Genome Health Study, as well as a number of pre-existing population-based GWA studies (for complete list of references, see Supplementary Table 2). Local research ethics committees approved the individual studies, and informed consent was obtained from all participants when necessary (see the Supplementary Materials for full details of ethics and consent procedures for each study). Additional details on sample recruitment and phenotypes and summary details for each collection are given in the Supplementary Note and in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. Genome-wide SNP genotyping was performed independently in each cohort with the use of various standard genotyping technologies, and imputed for each study with reference to HapMap release 21 or 22 CEU phased genotypes[35].

Study phenotypes

The primary phenotype analysed was migraine of any type, regardless of source. This was followed by a subgroup analysis consisting of 1) analysing only the clinical samples, 2) only samples satisfying criteria for MA, and 3) for MO. Population-based samples were not analysed genome-wide as a subgroup, due to forming 78% of cases and 85% of controls in the main analysis, but associations were calculated for the significant SNPs for comparative purposes. In the clinical cohorts, headache specialist has assigned a migraine diagnosis based on direct or telephone interview or through the use of an extensive questionnaire. For the population studies, migraine status for individuals in a study sample has been determined by a questionnaire (see Supplementary Note).

Statistical analysis of GWA study data

Each study contributed summary statistic data from an association analysis performed using a frequentist additive model based on an expected allelic dosage model for SNP markers, adjusting for gender (using either SNPTEST or ProbABEL [see URLs]). SNPs were filtered on per-study level based on inclusion criteria of MAF>0.1% and imputation quality measures of IA > 0.6 (IMPUTE 2[36]) or r2 > 0.3 (MACH[37]). Four of the included studies contain novel genotyping (HUNT) or imputation (the Finnish, German and Dutch MA studies and HUNT). In the meta-analysis, combined association data for ~2.3 million imputed and genotyped autosomal SNPs were analysed in a fixed-effects model using GWAMA. At this stage, SNPs with a heterogeneity coefficient I exceeding 75% or presence in only four or fewer studies were filtered out. In the meta-analysis, there was little evidence for population stratification at the study level (each genomic inflation factor λ≤ 1.1), though moderate inflation was observed at the meta-analysis level (λ = 1.15; Supplementary Fig. 4). For estimating genome-wide significance, we used the commonly accepted threshold of 5 × 10−8 for primary loci [38], and 1 × 10−5 for secondary loci, in accordance with the reporting threshold for the GWAS catalog[39]. At secondary loci, to limit spurious associations, at least two SNPs were required to pass the significance threshold within a 50kb window. We also estimated the robustness of this threshold using the false discovery rate method of Benjamini & Hochberg[40], showing that the P value threshold corresponding to FDR<0.05 was 2.33 × 10−5. The quantile-quantile plot (Supplementary Fig. 4) of the meta-analysis P values showed a marked excess of association signals well beyond those expected by chance below the suggestive reporting threshold. The significant loci were visualized using the LocusZoom interface[41]. For the heterogeneity analyses for migraine type, due to shared controls in some of the sets, the available study samples were divided into as equally-sized groups in terms of effective study size as possible, and then the data was analysed using the gender heterogeneity analysis method [42] (–sex option) of GWAMA[43], with a dummy variable coding for MA and MO instead of gender. For the heterogeneity analyses for gender, the same method was used to compare P values from males-only and females-only analyses.

Pathway analyses

MAGENTA - The MAGENTA software[44] was used to conduct an analysis to evaluate whether P values for association with migraine are enriched to particular biological networks, using pathway lists from GO, PANTHER, INGENUITY, KEGG, REACTOME and BIOCARTA. In the gene set enrichment analysis, P values were estimated via 10,000 permutations of genes evaluated at 75th FDR percentile (due to assumption of high polygenicity), manually corrected to account for FDR across all pathway sets. DAPPLE - Using a refined database of high-confidence protein-protein interactions (InWeb[45,46]) we used DAPPLE [47] to assess the amount of physical interactions connecting the genes within 50 kb of the 146 reported migraine loci, as well as an analysis of only the 16 proteins from the 12 genome-wide significant loci. Both direct and indirect (through 1st order common interaction partners) were measured and compared to a random expectation over 10,000 permutations, and the resulting network was plotted. GRAIL - The GRAIL web interface [48] was used to explore similarities in published PubMed articles (August 2012 freeze), using data from HapMap release 22 CEU and gene size correction set to on. From the GRAIL results, only genes with significant (P value<0.05) are shown, and the list of similar genes was capped at genes within the top 200 highest ranks.

Overlap with DNAse I hypersensitivity sites

The positions of SNPs from migraine-associated loci were overlapped with DNase 1 ‘hotspot’ regions from the ENCODE project that mark generalized chromatin accessibility mapped for each of 125 diverse cell lines and tissues[49]. To assess the significance of overlap for the set of SNPs as a whole, 100 background sets of SNPs were chosen from the genome so that each migraine associated SNP was matched in each set by a SNP within the same decile for minor allele frequency, distance to the nearest transcription start site and GC content of the 100 base region surrounding the SNP. The background SNP sets were overlapped with the DNase 1 hotspots, and the enrichment for overlap with the migraine associated SNP set expressed as the Z score relative to the distribution of background SNP set overlaps on a per cell line basis. In addition migraine associated SNPs were analysed for other overlap with ENCODE data including transcription factor motifs using RegulomeDB (http://regulome.stanford.edu)[50].

Tissue-based gene expression analysis

For the tissue analysis, a microarray-based analysis of gene expression was performed on a dataset of 55 269 samples in the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) database that were measured on the Affymetrix U133 Plus 2.0 Array. Each sample in the raw expression data was first linearly transformed using a modified invariant set normalization method[51] on a set of eighty control genes with stable expression on U133 Plus 2.0. The expression data was log2 transformed to stabilize the variance and expression distribution. Finally, the data were quantile-normalized[52] to match the expression distribution of each sample. Expression values for genes with multiple probe sets were calculated by taking the median value of all probe sets for that gene. Following normalization, a log2 expression value of 4 is considered baseline and log2 expression values greater than 6 are considered expressed. Sample annotations were curated based on GEO descriptions provided by depositors. To account for variation in the number of samples representing each tissue in the dataset, expression of a gene was plotted to show the fraction of samples of a tissue that exceeds a log2 expression value of 6, with higher fractions indicating more ubiquitous expression in the tissue in question.

eQTL analysis

Based on the meta-analysis results for association with migraine, 146 regions of interest were queried against the expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) results from the North American Brain Expression and UK Brain Expression Consortium studies (GEO # GSE36192, dbGaP # phs000249). These eQTL results are based on Cerebellum and Frontal Cortex tissue mRNA expression levels from 394 human subjects (see Supplementary methods). Of the 146 associated regions 134 were represented in the eQTL analysis. Within these regions 831 mRNA expression traits and 222 668 cis SNP/expression trait pairs were considered in Cerebellum and 864 mRNA expression traits and 230 660 cis SNP/expression trait pairs were considered in within the Frontal Cortex. 45 SNPs within the migraine associated loci were found to have significant correlation (evaluated at FDR-corrected threshold; 0.0001668 for frontal cortex and 0.0002187 for cerebellum) with the expression of 12 mRNA transcripts in both the Cerebellum and the Frontal Cortex. A more detailed methods description can be found in Supplementary Materials. The extent of linkage disequilibrium between SNPs associated with migraine and the SNPs in the tested eQTL SNP-probe pairs was evaluated using SNAP (see URLs).
  51 in total

1.  A human phenome-interactome network of protein complexes implicated in genetic disorders.

Authors:  Kasper Lage; E Olof Karlberg; Zenia M Størling; Páll I Olason; Anders G Pedersen; Olga Rigina; Anders M Hinsby; Zeynep Tümer; Flemming Pociot; Niels Tommerup; Yves Moreau; Søren Brunak
Journal:  Nat Biotechnol       Date:  2007-03       Impact factor: 54.908

2.  Astrocytes, but not microglia, rapidly sense H₂O₂via STAT6 phosphorylation, resulting in cyclooxygenase-2 expression and prostaglandin release.

Authors:  Soo Jung Park; Jee Hoon Lee; Hee Young Kim; Youn Hee Choi; Jung Sup Park; Young Ho Suh; Sang Myun Park; Eun-hye Joe; Ilo Jou
Journal:  J Immunol       Date:  2012-04-13       Impact factor: 5.422

3.  Genome-wide association analysis identifies susceptibility loci for migraine without aura.

Authors:  Tobias Freilinger; Verneri Anttila; Boukje de Vries; Rainer Malik; Mikko Kallela; Gisela M Terwindt; Patricia Pozo-Rosich; Bendik Winsvold; Dale R Nyholt; Willebrordus P J van Oosterhout; Ville Artto; Unda Todt; Eija Hämäläinen; Jèssica Fernández-Morales; Mark A Louter; Mari A Kaunisto; Jean Schoenen; Olli Raitakari; Terho Lehtimäki; Marta Vila-Pueyo; Hartmut Göbel; Erich Wichmann; Cèlia Sintas; Andre G Uitterlinden; Albert Hofman; Fernando Rivadeneira; Axel Heinze; Erling Tronvik; Cornelia M van Duijn; Jaakko Kaprio; Bru Cormand; Maija Wessman; Rune R Frants; Thomas Meitinger; Bertram Müller-Myhsok; John-Anker Zwart; Markus Färkkilä; Alfons Macaya; Michel D Ferrari; Christian Kubisch; Aarno Palotie; Martin Dichgans; Arn M J M van den Maagdenberg
Journal:  Nat Genet       Date:  2012-06-10       Impact factor: 38.330

4.  Biochemical and structural characterization of apolipoprotein A-I binding protein, a novel phosphoprotein with a potential role in sperm capacitation.

Authors:  Kula N Jha; Igor A Shumilin; Laura C Digilio; Olga Chertihin; Heping Zheng; Gerd Schmitz; Pablo E Visconti; Charles J Flickinger; Wladek Minor; John C Herr
Journal:  Endocrinology       Date:  2008-01-17       Impact factor: 4.736

5.  Genome-wide association study of migraine implicates a common susceptibility variant on 8q22.1.

Authors:  Verneri Anttila; Hreinn Stefansson; Mikko Kallela; Unda Todt; Gisela M Terwindt; M Stella Calafato; Dale R Nyholt; Antigone S Dimas; Tobias Freilinger; Bertram Müller-Myhsok; Ville Artto; Michael Inouye; Kirsi Alakurtti; Mari A Kaunisto; Eija Hämäläinen; Boukje de Vries; Anine H Stam; Claudia M Weller; Axel Heinze; Katja Heinze-Kuhn; Ingrid Goebel; Guntram Borck; Hartmut Göbel; Stacy Steinberg; Christiane Wolf; Asgeir Björnsson; Gretar Gudmundsson; Malene Kirchmann; Anne Hauge; Thomas Werge; Jean Schoenen; Johan G Eriksson; Knut Hagen; Lars Stovner; H-Erich Wichmann; Thomas Meitinger; Michael Alexander; Susanne Moebus; Stefan Schreiber; Yurii S Aulchenko; Monique M B Breteler; Andre G Uitterlinden; Albert Hofman; Cornelia M van Duijn; Päivi Tikka-Kleemola; Salli Vepsäläinen; Susanne Lucae; Federica Tozzi; Pierandrea Muglia; Jeffrey Barrett; Jaakko Kaprio; Markus Färkkilä; Leena Peltonen; Kari Stefansson; John-Anker Zwart; Michel D Ferrari; Jes Olesen; Mark Daly; Maija Wessman; Arn M J M van den Maagdenberg; Martin Dichgans; Christian Kubisch; Emmanouil T Dermitzakis; Rune R Frants; Aarno Palotie
Journal:  Nat Genet       Date:  2010-08-29       Impact factor: 38.330

6.  Genome-wide analysis of MEF2 transcriptional program reveals synaptic target genes and neuronal activity-dependent polyadenylation site selection.

Authors:  Steven W Flavell; Tae-Kyung Kim; Jesse M Gray; David A Harmin; Martin Hemberg; Elizabeth J Hong; Eirene Markenscoff-Papadimitriou; Daniel M Bear; Michael E Greenberg
Journal:  Neuron       Date:  2008-12-26       Impact factor: 17.173

7.  A large-scale analysis of tissue-specific pathology and gene expression of human disease genes and complexes.

Authors:  Kasper Lage; Niclas Tue Hansen; E Olof Karlberg; Aron C Eklund; Francisco S Roque; Patricia K Donahoe; Zoltan Szallasi; Thomas Skøt Jensen; Søren Brunak
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2008-12-22       Impact factor: 11.205

8.  Increased familial risk and evidence of genetic factor in migraine.

Authors:  M B Russell; J Olesen
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  1995-08-26

9.  The low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein LRP is regulated by membrane type-1 matrix metalloproteinase (MT1-MMP) proteolysis in malignant cells.

Authors:  Dmitri V Rozanov; Elizabeth Hahn-Dantona; Dudley K Strickland; Alex Y Strongin
Journal:  J Biol Chem       Date:  2003-11-25       Impact factor: 5.157

10.  Astrocyte-induced synaptogenesis is mediated by transforming growth factor β signaling through modulation of D-serine levels in cerebral cortex neurons.

Authors:  Luan Pereira Diniz; Juliana Carvalho Almeida; Vanessa Tortelli; Charles Vargas Lopes; Pedro Setti-Perdigão; Joice Stipursky; Suzana Assad Kahn; Luciana Ferreira Romão; Joari de Miranda; Soniza Vieira Alves-Leon; Jorge Marcondes de Souza; Newton G Castro; Rogério Panizzutti; Flávia Carvalho Alcantara Gomes
Journal:  J Biol Chem       Date:  2012-10-10       Impact factor: 5.157

View more
  142 in total

Review 1.  Properties, regulation, pharmacology, and functions of the K₂p channel, TRESK.

Authors:  Péter Enyedi; Gábor Czirják
Journal:  Pflugers Arch       Date:  2014-11-05       Impact factor: 3.657

Review 2.  Genome-wide association studies of late-onset cardiovascular disease.

Authors:  J Gustav Smith; Christopher Newton-Cheh
Journal:  J Mol Cell Cardiol       Date:  2015-04-11       Impact factor: 5.000

3.  Common Variant Burden Contributes to the Familial Aggregation of Migraine in 1,589 Families.

Authors:  Padhraig Gormley; Mitja I Kurki; Marjo Eveliina Hiekkala; Kumar Veerapen; Paavo Häppölä; Adele A Mitchell; Dennis Lal; Priit Palta; Ida Surakka; Mari Anneli Kaunisto; Eija Hämäläinen; Salli Vepsäläinen; Hannele Havanka; Hanna Harno; Matti Ilmavirta; Markku Nissilä; Erkki Säkö; Marja-Liisa Sumelahti; Jarmo Liukkonen; Matti Sillanpää; Liisa Metsähonkala; Seppo Koskinen; Terho Lehtimäki; Olli Raitakari; Minna Männikkö; Caroline Ran; Andrea Carmine Belin; Pekka Jousilahti; Verneri Anttila; Veikko Salomaa; Ville Artto; Markus Färkkilä; Heiko Runz; Mark J Daly; Benjamin M Neale; Samuli Ripatti; Mikko Kallela; Maija Wessman; Aarno Palotie
Journal:  Neuron       Date:  2018-05-03       Impact factor: 17.173

4.  Migrane: new susceptibility loci associated with migraine.

Authors:  Bryony Jones
Journal:  Nat Rev Neurol       Date:  2013-07-09       Impact factor: 42.937

5.  Meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies identifies 1q22 as a susceptibility locus for intracerebral hemorrhage.

Authors:  Daniel Woo; Guido J Falcone; William J Devan; W Mark Brown; Alessandro Biffi; Timothy D Howard; Christopher D Anderson; H Bart Brouwers; Valerie Valant; Thomas W K Battey; Farid Radmanesh; Miriam R Raffeld; Sylvia Baedorf-Kassis; Ranjan Deka; Jessica G Woo; Lisa J Martin; Mary Haverbusch; Charles J Moomaw; Guangyun Sun; Joseph P Broderick; Matthew L Flaherty; Sharyl R Martini; Dawn O Kleindorfer; Brett Kissela; Mary E Comeau; Jeremiasz M Jagiella; Helena Schmidt; Paul Freudenberger; Alexander Pichler; Christian Enzinger; Björn M Hansen; Bo Norrving; Jordi Jimenez-Conde; Eva Giralt-Steinhauer; Roberto Elosua; Elisa Cuadrado-Godia; Carolina Soriano; Jaume Roquer; Peter Kraft; Alison M Ayres; Kristin Schwab; Jacob L McCauley; Joanna Pera; Andrzej Urbanik; Natalia S Rost; Joshua N Goldstein; Anand Viswanathan; Eva-Maria Stögerer; David L Tirschwell; Magdy Selim; Devin L Brown; Scott L Silliman; Bradford B Worrall; James F Meschia; Chelsea S Kidwell; Joan Montaner; Israel Fernandez-Cadenas; Pilar Delgado; Rainer Malik; Martin Dichgans; Steven M Greenberg; Peter M Rothwell; Arne Lindgren; Agnieszka Slowik; Reinhold Schmidt; Carl D Langefeld; Jonathan Rosand
Journal:  Am J Hum Genet       Date:  2014-03-20       Impact factor: 11.025

Review 6.  Animal models of chronic migraine.

Authors:  Robin James Storer; Weera Supronsinchai; Anan Srikiatkhachorn
Journal:  Curr Pain Headache Rep       Date:  2015-01

Review 7.  Drosophila and experimental neurology in the post-genomic era.

Authors:  Joshua M Shulman
Journal:  Exp Neurol       Date:  2015-03-24       Impact factor: 5.330

8.  Inhibition of Neuroinflammation by AIBP: Spinal Effects upon Facilitated Pain States.

Authors:  Sarah A Woller; Soo-Ho Choi; Eun Jung An; Hann Low; Dina A Schneider; Roshni Ramachandran; Jungsu Kim; Yun Soo Bae; Dmitri Sviridov; Maripat Corr; Tony L Yaksh; Yury I Miller
Journal:  Cell Rep       Date:  2018-05-29       Impact factor: 9.423

Review 9.  CGRP as a neuropeptide in migraine: lessons from mice.

Authors:  Andrew F Russo
Journal:  Br J Clin Pharmacol       Date:  2015-07-14       Impact factor: 4.335

10.  Genome-wide association study for age-related hearing loss (AHL) in the mouse: a meta-analysis.

Authors:  Jeffrey Ohmen; Eun Yong Kang; Xin Li; Jong Wha Joo; Farhad Hormozdiari; Qing Yin Zheng; Richard C Davis; Aldons J Lusis; Eleazar Eskin; Rick A Friedman
Journal:  J Assoc Res Otolaryngol       Date:  2014-02-26
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.