NOTCH1 mutations influence survival in chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients.

BACKGROUND: NOTCH1 PEST domain mutations in chronic lymphocytic leukemia have recently been shown to be of prognostic relevance. Both NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 are constitutively activated in B-cell CLL but not expressed in normal B cells and may be involved in survival and resistance to apoptosis in CLL. We screened for mutations in different parts of both NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 genes and related the changes to survival and other known risk factors.
METHODS: In a cohort of 209 CLL patients, we used single strand conformation analysis to determine which of the samples carrying the NOTCH mutations and direct dideoxy sequencing was used to determine the exact nucleotide changes. Kaplan-Meier curves and log rank test were used to determine overall survival for NOTCH1 mutated cases and Cox regression analysis was used to calculate hazardous ratios.
RESULTS: In the present study, we found NOTCH1 PEST domain mutations in 6.7% of the cases. A shorter overall survival was found in patients with NOTCH1 mutations compared to wildtype (p = 0.049). Further, we also examined the extracellular and the heterodimerisation domains of the NOTCH1 gene and the PEST domain and heterodimerisation domain of the NOTCH2 gene, but no mutations were found in these regions. NOTCH1 mutations were most commonly observed in patients with unmutated IGHV gene (10/14), and associated with a more aggressive disease course. In addition, NOTCH1 mutations were almost mutually exclusive with TP53 mutations. In the combined group of NOTCH1 (6.7%) or TP53 (6.2%) mutations, a significant difference in overall survival compared to the wildtype NOTCH1 and TP53 was found (p = 0.002).
CONCLUSIONS: Both NOTCH1 and TP53 mutations seem to be independent predictive markers for worse outcome in CLL-patients and this study emphasizes the contention that NOTCH1 mutations is a novel risk marker.

Background

Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is a heterogeneous disease with variable clinical course characterized by a monoclonal progressive accumulation of mature CD5+ B-lymphocytes avoiding apoptosis. Some patients with an indolent disease need no or little treatment while others have a more adverse disease at diagnosis. No common genetic lesion, which causes the disease, has been found [1], but recurrent mutations in CLL involve TP53 and ATM, and novel mutations in the NOTCH1, SF3B1, MYD88, BIRC3 and FBXW7 genes have been identified through next generation sequencing [2]. The CLL cases may be divided in two major groups regarding to mutated (M) or unmutated (UM) immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region gene (IGHV) where patients with an unmutated IGHV clone have a more adverse prognosis than patients with mutated IGHV gene [3,4]. By the means of FISH analysis, different chromosomal aberrations as deletion in 11q, 13q, 17p or trisomy 12 are found in about 80% of tumor cells in the CLL-patients [5].

Recently, NOTCH1 mutations were found to be predictor of poor prognosis in CLL [6-11]. Furthermore a study of Rosati et al. [12] showed that NOTCH1 and NOTCH2, together with their ligands Jagged1 –and 2 are constitutively activated in B-CLL cells but not in normal B cells, suggesting that NOTCH signaling is involved in survival and resistance to apoptosis in CLL.

The NOTCH receptor is a membrane bound protein that consists of an extracellular, transmembrane and intracellular domain that can be released upon ligand interaction and transactivate target genes. The NOTCH signal pathway is activated by a ligand on a neighboring cell and plays an essential role in controlling proliferation, differentiation and survival. Following the receptor-ligand binding, the NOTCH receptor first undergoes a S2 proteolytic cleavage by ADAM proteinase in the extracellular domain, which then is followed by a S3 cleavage by a γ-secretase complex in the transmembrane domain releasing the intracellular NOTCH domain that translocates to the nucleus where it interacts with a transcription complex and acts as a transcriptional activator for multiple target genes [13]. The C-terminal part of the intracellular domain consists of a PEST region that is important for proteasomal degradation of the NOTCH receptor by binding to FBXW7, an E3 ubiquitin ligase, to limit duration of the NOTCH activity. A CT deletion in the C-terminal region results in removal of the PEST domain, a truncated NOTCH protein, and impaired NOTCH degradation and constitutive transcriptional activation of NOTCH target genes in CLL [7,14].

In the present study we have screened for mutations in different parts of both the NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 gene in a cohort of 209 CLL-patients. There is a high structural similarity between NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 genes and recent NOTCH2 gain-of-function mutations are found in B-cell lymphomas [15]. Further, as NOTCH2 is involved in overexpression of CD23, one of the hallmarks of CLL [16], it prompted us to screen both the NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 genes for genetic alterations. Mutations were only found in the PEST region in the NOTCH1 gene in our cohort and emerged as an independent factor of poor overall survival and disease stage, in addition to TP53 mutations and IGHV gene status.

Methods

Patients

In this study, peripheral blood from 209 CLL patients (145 men and 64 women) was collected between 1996 and 2006 at the Department of Hematology, Linköping University Hospital. Mononuclear cells were isolated by Ficoll-Paque gradient centrifugation and genomic DNA was extracted by proteinase K digestion and stored frozen until used as earlier described [17]. The samples were collected either at the time of diagnosis or prior to the first treatment. For all patients, follow-up data were available, and for 106 live patients the median follow-up time was 6.8 years (range 1.6-14.9 years). The median age at diagnosis was 62.5 years (range 38.3-87.0 years). The immunophenotype and the Binet staging system were according to the IWCLL guidelines [18]. The immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region genes (IGHV) and TP53 gene status were analysed and reported in an earlier study [17]. Informed consent was obtained from the patients and the study was approved by the regional ethical committee (Dnr 02–459) in Linköping and conducted in accordance with the ethical guidelines of the Helsinki Declaration.

NOTCH mutation status detection

The NOTCH1 mutations status were analyzed for the extracellular region (exon 6, 7, 8, 11, 12 and 13), the heterodimerisation domain (exon 26, 27) and the PEST region (exon 34) and the NOTCH2 was only analyzed for mutations in the heterodimerisation and the PEST domains by PCR amplification followed by single strand conformation analysis (SSCA) according to the original protocol [19] and direct dideoxy sequencing to determine the exact nucleotide change and compared to corresponding NOTCH1 and NOTCH2 germline sequence (NM_017617.3 and NM_024408.3 respectively). Primer sequences are shown in Table 1.

Table 1

Primer sequences

Gene-exon-segment	Application	Forward primer	Reverse primer	Product size/bp	TA/°C
Notch1- 26-a	PCR/SSCA	AGCCCCCTGTACGACCAGTA	CTTGCGCAGCTCCTCCTC	283	63.5
Notch1- 26-b	PCR/SSCA	ACACGGCCAGCAGATGAT	GAGAGTTGCGGGGATTGAC	231	57.1
Notch1- 27	PCR/SSCA	GTGGCGTCATGGGCCTCA	TAGCAACTGGCACAAACAGC	342	63.2
Notch1- 34a	PCR/SSCA	AACCACCTGCCTGGGATG	CGCATTGACCATTCAAACTG	232	57.1
Notch1- 34b	PCR/SSCA	GGGCCCTGAATTTCACTGT	AGGCCCTGGTAGCTCATCAT	229	60
Notch1- 34c	PCR/SSCA	GCTGCACAGTAGCCTTGCT	CTGAGCTCACGCCAAGGT	224	58
Notch1- 34d	PCR/SSCA	ACATCCAGCAGCAGCAAAG	GTGGGACCAGCGAGGATG	222	58
Notch1- 34e	PCR/SSCA	CACTATTCTGCCCCAGGAGA	CAGTCGGAGACGTTGGAATG	234	58
Notch1- 34f	PCR/SSCA	ACAGCTACTCCTCGCCTGTG	AAGGCTTGGGAAAGGAAGC	248	58
Notch1-6	PCR/SSCA	GCAGCTGCCCGGGGCCGACA	TCAGGCCTGGCCCATGTGA	330	62
Notch1-7	PCR/SSCA	ATGCCTGGCCAGGGGCCGT	TCGACTTCTCATCGGTTCT	273	58
Notch1-8	PCR/SSCA	CCGATGGGGGTGGTGTGCAGT	TGCCCAGCCTCGACTCGGTT	331	63
Notch1-11	PCR/SSCA	AGTCCTAAGTCTTCCTGTGCC	AGGCCCGCCCTGCCCACT	325	65
Notch1-12	PCR/SSCA	AGGACTGACCGACACGTG	TCTGAGCACAGTGCAGTCA	183	53
Notch1-13	PCR/SSCA	TGGGCGCTGGGCCTCGGA	ACTGATGTGTCCCCATGA	268	54
Gene-exon-segment	Application	Forward primer	Reverse primer	Product size/bp	TA/°C
Notch2- 26-1	PCR/SSCA	TTCTCTGCTTCCCCTTACCT	TTAATGCGCAGGTTGGTGT	250	54.1
Notch2- 26-2	PCR/SSCA	TGGTATTGATGCCACCTGAA	GCCTTGAAGTTCAGAAACCAA	240	54.1
Notch2- 27	PCR/SSCA	TACCCCCATCTCTCCTCCTC	AATTGTTCCCCCAATTGACA	250	55.2
Notch2- 34-1	PCR/SSCA	TCCCCTGTTGATTCCCTAGA	CACAATGTGGTGGTGGGATA	249	55.2
Notch2- 34-2	PCR/SSCA	GCACTGTGCTTCCCTCAGT	CTGCCTTTAGGGATGAGCTG	298	55.2
Notch2- 34-3	PCR/SSCA	ACCCATCCTGGCATAGCTC	TAGGCTGGGAGAATGGTCTG	287	55.2
Notch2- 34-4	PCR/SSCA	TTTGCCCAGTGTGGCTTT	GGTGATGAACTTGACCACTG	249	57.1
Notch2- 34-5	PCR/SSCA	ACACCCAGTCACAGTGGTCA	TGTCTCTACACTGGAGGTGGAC	242	61.6

TP53 and IGHV gene status detection

TP53 gene mutation analysis was performed for exons 5–8 (the DNA binding domains) by the PCR-single strand conformation analysis (SSCA) technique and samples displaying mobility shifts were sequenced with the dideoxy termination method to confirm the nucleotide changes.

The IGHV gene mutational status was performed by PCR amplification on genomic DNA by using specific VH/JH primers [20], followed by DNA sequencing of both forward and reverse strands. To determine the IGHV gene identity the sequences were aligned by using the IMGT/V-QUEST database (http://imgt.org), ≥ 98% identity to the corresponding germline sequence was considered as an unmutated IGHV gene.

Statistical analysis

Kaplan-Meier curves were used to show the overall survival and the log-rank test was used to compare the survival between the groups. To calculate hazard ratios (HR) the Cox proportional hazard model (Cox-regression) was used. For all statistical analyses Stata v12.1 was used (StataCorp LP, College Station, TX, USA). P-values less than 0.05 were considered significant. Overall survival was measured from date of diagnosis until the last follow-up or death.

Results and discussion

NOTCH1 heterozygous mutations in the PEST domain occurred in a frequency of 14 out of 209 patients (6.7%) in our study. Thirteen of the mutations correspond to a 2-bp frameshift deletion, c.7541_7542delCT and one is a novel GT deletion at c.6988_6989delGT, both generating frameshift mutations, with subsequent stopcodon and truncated proteins eliminating the PEST domain. The Kaplan-Meier curve for the CLL-patients with NOTCH1 mutations revealed a shorter overall survival (OS) compared to NOTCH1 wildtype patients (p = 0.049) (Figure 1). Clinical and biological characteristics of the CLL patients in relation to the NOTCH1 status are summarized in Table 2. Our study showed a similarity to other CLL studies, which have reported NOTCH1 PEST domain mutations in 4.7% - 12.2% [6-11].

Figure 1

Kaplan-Meier survival curves displaying a significant difference between patients with mutation (n = 14) and wildtype (n = 195) (p = 0.049).

Table 2

Clinical and biological characteristics of the 209 CLL-patients

			NOTCH1
	Total		Wildtype		Mutated
	n	%	n	%	n	%	P value
Number of patients	209		195		14
Sex							0.67
male	145	69	136	70	9	64
female	64	31	59	30	5	36
Binet stage							0.11
A	101	48	98	50	3	21
B/C	91	44	82	42	9	64
Not determined	17	8	15	8	2	14
Treatment							0.22
yes	182	87	168	86	14	100
no	20	10	20	10	0	0
Not determined	7	3	7	4	0	0
IGHV status							0.22
Mutated	64	31	61	31	3	21
Unmutated	123	59	113	58	10	71
Not determined	22	10	21	11	1	7
TP 53 status							0.88
wild-type	196	94	183	94	13	93
mutated	13	6	12	6	1	7

T cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL) display high frequency of activating NOTCH1 mutations including the extracellular heterodimerisation domain, in addition to elimination C-terminal PEST region mutations [21]. Studies in head and neck cancer have also identified mutations in the extracellular epiderminal growth factor repeat domain in the NOTCH1 gene [22]. These studies prompted us to screen for mutations in those parts of the NOTCH1 gene, but no mutations could be detected. NOTCH2 has a role in marginal zone B cell fate decision, similar to the critical role for NOTCH1 in determing the T-cell fate [13]. NOTCH2 mutations are found in the C-terminal part close to the PEST region in splenic marginal zone lymphoma [23,24], but we did not find any mutations in the PEST region or heterodimerisation domain of the NOTCH2 gene in our cohort.

Mutations in the TP53 gene are associated with poor prognosis in CLL [25]. Mutations in the NOTCH1 gene are almost mutually exclusive with mutations in the TP53 gene with or without 17p or 11q deletions, only one sample harbored mutations in both NOTCH1 and TP53. Combined, NOTCH1 (6.7%) and TP53 (6.2%) mutations represent 12.9% of the patients in this cohort and indicated a significant worse survival as compared to wildtype NOTCH1 and TP53 (Log rank analysis, p = 0.002) (Figure 2). NOTCH1 mutations may appear together with trisomy 12 [26,27], and in our cohort, trisomy 12 was found in 15/152 patients by BAC (bacterial artificial chromosome) microarray analysis and two of these carried NOTCH1 mutation; this association was not significant (p = 0.56). By univariate analysis, the HR for death increased to 2.27 (1.32-3.91; 95% confidence interval) for tumors mutated in NOTCH1 or TP53 compared to NOTCH1 and TP53 wildtype tumors (p = 0.003) (Table 3). At the molecular level there seems to be an intriguing and complex link between p53 and NOTCH1. P53 induce NOTCH1 expression and seems to initiate an anti-apoptotic feedback mechanism with subsequent increased cell survival that may limit p53 promoting therapy with e.g. nutlins [28,29]. NOTCH signaling blockade by γ-secretase inhibitors to stimulate apoptosis may be considered to be of therapeutic value at least for wt p53 CLL patients [28].

Figure 2

A significant difference in overall survival between patients with or mutations (n = 26) and CLL with non-mutated and (n = 183(p = 0.002).

Table 3

Analysis for overall survival

	N	HR	95% CI	P	HR1	95%CI	P
Wildtype NOTCH1 and TP53	183	1			1
Mutated NOTCH1 or TP53	26	2.27	1.32-3.91	0.003	2.16	1.25-3.72	0.006
Wildtype NOTCH1	195	1			1
Mutated NOTCH1	14	2.04	0.98-4.25	0.056	1.80	0.86-3.76	0.12
Wildtype TP53	196	1			1
Mutated TP53	13	2.54	1.17-5.54	0.019	2.54	1.17-5.53	0.002

HR, hazard ratio; CI, confidence interval.

1Adjusted for age and sex.

Among CLL patients with a mutated NOTCH1 gene 10/14 (71%) had an unmutated IGHV gene in contrast to 113/195 (58%) with a wildtype NOTCH1 gene, a difference that did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.22) (Figure 3 and Table 2). CLL with NOTCH1 mutations seemed to be more progressive, with a high frequency of unmutated IGHV gene and advanced Binet stages, indicating a more aggressive disease course.

Figure 3

Distribution of mutations among IGHV gene status and gene status. Ten of fourteen cases with mutated NOTCH1 gene are found in the unmutated IGHV gene group and only one patient has both NOTCH1 mutation and TP53 mutation.

Five patients in this cohort had NOTCH1 mutation at the time of diagnosis. For these patients the median time to first treatment was 101 days (range 21 to 145 days). For the whole group the median time from diagnosis to the first treatment was 438 days (range 0–6021 days). Further and expected, all patients with NOTCH1 mutations identified at diagnosis had the more advanced Binet stages B and C, a tendency that due to few observations did not reach significance (p = 0.11) (Table 2). The frequency of NOTCH1 mutations is also reported to be significantly higher in Richter syndrome, i.e., a progression of CLL into diffuse large lymphoma with often dismal outcome [8,30], however our cohort contained no information on the prevalence of Richter syndrome.

It is now recommended to perform TP53 mutation analysis in patients with CLL as TP53 mutations occur in about 5% of cases in absence of 17p deletion and represent an independent prognostic factor associated with worse outcome [31]. CLL patients with 17p deletion and/or TP53 mutations are strongly associated with refractory disease, and also activated NOTCH1 mutations were recently suggested to cause refractoriness to fludarabine [8,9,32].

Conclusions

Our study confirms other recent reports that NOTCH1 mutation eliminating the PEST domain, has a prognostic value as a novel risk marker in CLL similar to TP53 mutations. Thus both NOTCH1 and TP53 mutation may be an indication for earlier and more active treatment or as an indicator for transplantation therapy.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors’ contributions

KW collected data, performed experiments, analyzed and interpreted data, wrote the manuscript; RKD performed experiments, analyzed and interpreted data; JU performed experiments, analyzed and interpreted data; RG performed experiments and interpreted data; GJ interpreted data; MF performed statistical analysis; ML designed experiments; PS designed experiments, wrote the manuscript. All authors were involved in writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/13/274/prepub