BACKGROUND: Despite the putative advantages conferred by closed-suction drains (CSDs), the widespread utilization of post-operative drains has been questioned due to concerns regarding both efficacy and safety, particularly with respect to the risk of surgical site infection (SSI). Although discipline-specific reports exist delineating risk factors associated with SSI as they relate to the presence of CSDs, there are no broad summary studies to examine this issue in depth. METHODS: The pertinent medical literature exploring the relationship between CSDs and SSI across multiple surgical disciplines was reviewed. RESULTS: Across most surgical disciplines, studies to evaluate the risk of SSI associated with routine post-operative CSD have yielded conflicting results. A few studies do suggest an increased risk of SSI associated with drain placement, but are usually associated with open drainage and not the use of CSDs. No studies whatsoever attribute a decrease in the incidence of SSI (including organ/space SSI) to drain placement. CONCLUSIONS: Until additional, rigorous randomized trials are available to address the issue definitively, we recommend judicious use and prompt, timely removal of CSDs. Given that the evidence is scant and weak to suggest that CSD use is associated with increased risk of SSI, there is no justification for the prolongation of antibiotic prophylaxis to "cover" an indwelling drain.
BACKGROUND: Despite the putative advantages conferred by closed-suction drains (CSDs), the widespread utilization of post-operative drains has been questioned due to concerns regarding both efficacy and safety, particularly with respect to the risk of surgical site infection (SSI). Although discipline-specific reports exist delineating risk factors associated with SSI as they relate to the presence of CSDs, there are no broad summary studies to examine this issue in depth. METHODS: The pertinent medical literature exploring the relationship between CSDs and SSI across multiple surgical disciplines was reviewed. RESULTS: Across most surgical disciplines, studies to evaluate the risk of SSI associated with routine post-operative CSD have yielded conflicting results. A few studies do suggest an increased risk of SSI associated with drain placement, but are usually associated with open drainage and not the use of CSDs. No studies whatsoever attribute a decrease in the incidence of SSI (including organ/space SSI) to drain placement. CONCLUSIONS: Until additional, rigorous randomized trials are available to address the issue definitively, we recommend judicious use and prompt, timely removal of CSDs. Given that the evidence is scant and weak to suggest that CSD use is associated with increased risk of SSI, there is no justification for the prolongation of antibiotic prophylaxis to "cover" an indwelling drain.
Authors: P Benedetti-Panici; F Maneschi; G Cutillo; G D'Andrea; V S di Palumbo; M Conte; G Scambia; S Mancuso Journal: Gynecol Oncol Date: 1997-06 Impact factor: 5.482
Authors: G Schoretsanitis; J Melissas; E Sanidas; M Christodoulakis; J G Vlachonikolis; D D Tsiftsis Journal: Am Surg Date: 1998-08 Impact factor: 0.688
Authors: Gabrielle A LaBove; Gregory Rd Evans; Brian Biggerstaff; Brandon K Richland; Seung Ah Lee; Derek A Banyard; Nima Khoshab Journal: JPRAS Open Date: 2020-11-30
Authors: D Wouters; G Cavallaro; Kristian K Jensen; B East; B Jíšová; L N Jorgensen; M López-Cano; V Rodrigues-Gonçalves; C Stabilini; F Berrevoet Journal: Front Surg Date: 2022-07-13
Authors: Joseph D Bozzay; Patrick F Walker; David W Schechtman; Faraz Shaikh; Laveta Stewart; David R Tribble; Matthew J Bradley Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2020-08-29 Impact factor: 2.192
Authors: Rachel L O'Donnell; Georgios Angelopoulos; James P Beirne; Ioannis Biliatis; Helen Bolton; Melissa Bradbury; Elaine Craig; Ketan Gajjar; Michelle L Mackintosh; Wendy MacNab; Thumuluru Kavitha Madhuri; Mark McComiskey; Eva Myriokefalitaki; Claire L Newton; Nithya Ratnavelu; Sian E Taylor; Amudha Thangavelu; Sarah A Rhodes; Emma J Crosbie; Richard J Edmondson; Yee-Loi Louise Wan Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2019-01-24 Impact factor: 2.692