Literature DB >> 23598760

Reporting the level of evidence in the Canadian Journal of Plastic Surgery: Why is it important?

Achilleas Thoma1, Teegan A Ignacy, Yu Kit Li, Christopher J Coroneos.   

Abstract

The levels of evidence (LOE) table has been increasingly used by many surgical journals and societies to emphasize the importance of proper study design. Since their origin, LOE have evolved to consider multiple study designs and also the rigour of not only the study type but multiple aspects of its design. The use of LOE aids readers in appraising the literature while encouraging clinical researchers to produce high-quality evidence. The current article discusses the benefits and limitations of the LOE, as well as the LOE of articles published in the Canadian Journal of Plastic Surgery (CJPS). Along with an assessment of the LOE in the CJPS, the authors have provided recommendations to improve the quality and readability of articles published in the CJPS.

Keywords:  Evidence; Levels of evidence, quality; Literature review; Plastic surgery; Research methodology

Year:  2012        PMID: 23598760      PMCID: PMC3307675          DOI: 10.1177/229255031202000113

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Can J Plast Surg        ISSN: 1195-2199


  24 in total

Review 1.  The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials.

Authors:  D Moher; K F Schulz; D Altman
Journal:  JAMA       Date:  2001-04-18       Impact factor: 56.272

2.  The quality of reporting of randomized trials in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery from 1988 through 2000.

Authors:  Mohit Bhandari; Robin R Richards; Sheila Sprague; Emil H Schemitsch
Journal:  J Bone Joint Surg Am       Date:  2002-03       Impact factor: 5.284

3.  Grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations.

Authors:  David Atkins; Dana Best; Peter A Briss; Martin Eccles; Yngve Falck-Ytter; Signe Flottorp; Gordon H Guyatt; Robin T Harbour; Margaret C Haugh; David Henry; Suzanne Hill; Roman Jaeschke; Gillian Leng; Alessandro Liberati; Nicola Magrini; James Mason; Philippa Middleton; Jacek Mrukowicz; Dianne O'Connell; Andrew D Oxman; Bob Phillips; Holger J Schünemann; Tessa Tan-Torres Edejer; Helena Varonen; Gunn E Vist; John W Williams; Stephanie Zaza
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2004-06-19

Review 4.  AGREE II: advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in health care.

Authors:  Melissa C Brouwers; Michelle E Kho; George P Browman; Jako S Burgers; Francoise Cluzeau; Gene Feder; Béatrice Fervers; Ian D Graham; Jeremy Grimshaw; Steven E Hanna; Peter Littlejohns; Julie Makarski; Louise Zitzelsberger
Journal:  CMAJ       Date:  2010-07-05       Impact factor: 8.262

5.  An emerging consensus on grading recommendations?

Authors:  Gordon Guyatt; Gunn Vist; Yngve Falck-Ytter; Regina Kunz; Nicola Magrini; Holger Schunemann
Journal:  ACP J Club       Date:  2006 Jan-Feb

6.  Milestones on the long road to knowledge.

Authors:  Fiona Godlee
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2007-01-06

7.  Empirical evidence of bias in treatment effect estimates in controlled trials with different interventions and outcomes: meta-epidemiological study.

Authors:  Lesley Wood; Matthias Egger; Lise Lotte Gluud; Kenneth F Schulz; Peter Jüni; Douglas G Altman; Christian Gluud; Richard M Martin; Anthony J G Wood; Jonathan A C Sterne
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2008-03-03

8.  Levels of evidence in research published in The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American Volume) over the last thirty years.

Authors:  Shane Hanzlik; Raman C Mahabir; Richard C Baynosa; Kayvan T Khiabani
Journal:  J Bone Joint Surg Am       Date:  2009-02       Impact factor: 5.284

9.  Evidence-based plastic surgery: controlled trials in three plastic surgical journals (1990 to 2005).

Authors:  Arash Momeni; Axel Becker; Gerd Antes; Markus K Diener; Markus Diener; Anette Blümle; Anette Bluemle; Bjoern G Stark
Journal:  Ann Plast Surg       Date:  2009-03       Impact factor: 1.539

10.  A detailed analysis of level I evidence (randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses) in five plastic surgery journals to date: 1978 to 2009.

Authors:  James E McCarthy; Abhishek Chatterjee; T Gregory McKelvey; Elisabeth M G Jantzen; Carolyn L Kerrigan
Journal:  Plast Reconstr Surg       Date:  2010-11       Impact factor: 4.730

View more
  3 in total

1.  The performance and publication of cost-utility analyses in plastic surgery: Making our specialty relevant.

Authors:  Achilleas Thoma; Teegan A Ignacy; Natalia Ziolkowski; Sophocles Voineskos
Journal:  Can J Plast Surg       Date:  2012

2.  Evidence-based medicine: The Canadian Journal of Plastic Surgery's future.

Authors:  Edward W Buchel
Journal:  Can J Plast Surg       Date:  2012

Review 3.  Citation classics in general medical journals: assessing the quality of evidence; a systematic review.

Authors:  Suhaib Js Ahmad; Ahmed R Ahmed; Karl Friedrich Kowalewski; Felix Nickel; Kamran Rostami; Claire J Stocker; Sherif M Hakky; Rami Archid; Douglas McWhinnie; Ata Mohajer-Bastami; Dionysis Skiadopoulos Seimenis; Sami Ahmad; Sami Mansour; Mohamed H Ahmed; Dushyant Mital; Aristomenis K Exadaktylos
Journal:  Gastroenterol Hepatol Bed Bench       Date:  2020
  3 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.