Annular dilatation and loss of sino-tubular junction in aneurysmatic aorta: implications on leaflet quality at the time of surgery. A finite element study.

OBJECTIVES: In the belief that stress is the main determinant of leaflet quality deterioration, we sought to evaluate the effect of annular and/or sino-tubular junction dilatation on leaflet stress. A finite element computer-assisted stress analysis was used to model four different anatomic conditions and analyse the consequent stress pattern on the aortic valve.
METHODS: Theoretical models of four aortic root configurations (normal, with dilated annulus, with loss of sino-tubular junction and with both dilatation simultaneously) were created with computer-aided design technique. The pattern of stress and strain was then analysed by means of finite elements analysis, when a uniform pressure of 100 mmHg was applied to the model. Analysis produced von Mises charts (colour-coded, computational, three-dimensional stress-pattern graphics) and bidimensional plots of compared stress on arc-linear line, which allowed direct comparison of stress in the four different conditions.
RESULTS: Stresses both on the free margin and on the 'belly' of the leaflet rose from 0.28 MPa (normal conditions) to 0.32 MPa (+14%) in case of isolated dilatation of the sino-tubular junction, while increased to 0.42 MPa (+67%) in case of isolated annular dilatation, with no substantial difference whether sino-tubular junction dilatation was present or not.
CONCLUSIONS: Annular dilatation is the key element determining an increased stress on aortic leaflets independently from an associated sino-tubular junction dilatation. The presence of annular dilatation associated with root aneurysm greatly decreases the chance of performing a valve sparing procedure without the need for additional manoeuvres on leaflet tissue. This information may lead to a refinement in the optimal surgical strategy.