BACKGROUND: Conducting total thyroidectomy (TT) or subtotal thyroidectomy (ST) in patients with Graves' disease remains controversial. We performed a meta-analysis based on the published randomized controlled trials to evaluate the complications of TT vs ST. METHODS: We searched multiple electronic databases for prospective, randomized, controlled trials related to safety and effectiveness of TT vs ST. Relative risk (RR) was estimated with 95% confidence interval (CI) based on an intention-to-treat analysis. We considered the following outcomes: recurrent hyperthyroidism, ophthalmopathy progression, temporary and permanent hypoparathyroidism, temporary and permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy (RLNP) and post-operative bleeding. RESULTS: Four trials with 674 patients (342 with TT, 332 with ST) were analysed. Although the overall rates of ophthalmopathy progression were similar between TT and ST (RR 0·92, 95% CI = 0·50-1·71; P = 0·80), TT was associated with a significant reduction in recurrent hyperthyroidism (RR 0·14, 95% CI = 0·05-0·41; P < 0·01). The pooled RR of post-operative bleeding for TT was similar to that for ST (RR 0·32, 95% CI = 0·05-1·96; P = 0·22). However, comparing with ST, the RR of temporary hypoparathyroidism was significantly higher for TT (RR 2·66, 95% CI = 1·89-3·73; P < 0·01). There was no significant difference in permanent hypoparathyroidism (RR 2·30, 95% CI = 0·78-6·76; P = 0·13), temporary (RR 1·08, 95% CI = 0·47-2·48; P = 0·85) and permanent RLNP (RR 1·54, 95% CI = 0·41-5·73; P = 0·52) between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: With regard to ophthalmopathy progression, post-operative bleeding, permanent hypoparathyroidism, temporary and permanent RLNP, TT is consistent with ST in patients with Graves' disease. However, TT is associated with a reduced incidence of recurrent hyperthyroidism and results in an increase in temporary hypoparathyroidism. Therefore, TT should be proposed for the treatment of Graves' disease.
BACKGROUND: Conducting total thyroidectomy (TT) or subtotal thyroidectomy (ST) in patients with Graves' disease remains controversial. We performed a meta-analysis based on the published randomized controlled trials to evaluate the complications of TT vs ST. METHODS: We searched multiple electronic databases for prospective, randomized, controlled trials related to safety and effectiveness of TT vs ST. Relative risk (RR) was estimated with 95% confidence interval (CI) based on an intention-to-treat analysis. We considered the following outcomes: recurrent hyperthyroidism, ophthalmopathy progression, temporary and permanent hypoparathyroidism, temporary and permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy (RLNP) and post-operative bleeding. RESULTS: Four trials with 674 patients (342 with TT, 332 with ST) were analysed. Although the overall rates of ophthalmopathy progression were similar between TT and ST (RR 0·92, 95% CI = 0·50-1·71; P = 0·80), TT was associated with a significant reduction in recurrent hyperthyroidism (RR 0·14, 95% CI = 0·05-0·41; P < 0·01). The pooled RR of post-operative bleeding for TT was similar to that for ST (RR 0·32, 95% CI = 0·05-1·96; P = 0·22). However, comparing with ST, the RR of temporary hypoparathyroidism was significantly higher for TT (RR 2·66, 95% CI = 1·89-3·73; P < 0·01). There was no significant difference in permanent hypoparathyroidism (RR 2·30, 95% CI = 0·78-6·76; P = 0·13), temporary (RR 1·08, 95% CI = 0·47-2·48; P = 0·85) and permanent RLNP (RR 1·54, 95% CI = 0·41-5·73; P = 0·52) between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: With regard to ophthalmopathy progression, post-operative bleeding, permanent hypoparathyroidism, temporary and permanent RLNP, TT is consistent with ST in patients with Graves' disease. However, TT is associated with a reduced incidence of recurrent hyperthyroidism and results in an increase in temporary hypoparathyroidism. Therefore, TT should be proposed for the treatment of Graves' disease.
Authors: Hyungju Kwon; Jin Wook Yi; Ra-Yeong Song; Young Jun Chai; Su-jin Kim; June Young Choi; Kyu Eun Lee Journal: World J Surg Date: 2016-03 Impact factor: 3.352
Authors: Vishnu Sundaresh; Juan P Brito; Zhen Wang; Larry J Prokop; Marius N Stan; Mohammad H Murad; Rebecca S Bahn Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2013-07-03 Impact factor: 5.958
Authors: Mariam Kourime; Sheena McGowan; Mabrouka Al Towati; S Faisal Ahmed; Graham Stewart; Scott Williamson; Iain Hunter; Malcolm D C Donaldson Journal: Arch Dis Child Date: 2017-12-21 Impact factor: 3.791
Authors: Jinyoung Kim; Min Sun Choi; Jun Park; Hyunju Park; Hye Won Jang; Jun-Ho Choe; Jung-Han Kim; Jee Soo Kim; Young Seok Cho; Joon Young Choi; Tae Hyuk Kim; Jae Hoon Chung; Sun Wook Kim Journal: Thyroid Date: 2021-07-21 Impact factor: 6.568