BACKGROUND: Medical interactions between Black patients and non-Black physicians are less positive and productive than racially concordant ones and contribute to racial disparities in the quality of health care. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether an intervention based on the common ingroup identity model, previously used in nonmedical settings to reduce intergroup bias, would change physician and patient responses in racially discordant medical interactions and improve patient adherence. IINTERVENTION: Physicians and patients were randomly assigned to either a common identity treatment (to enhance their sense of commonality) or a control (standard health information) condition, and then engaged in a scheduled appointment. DESIGN: Intervention occurred just before the interaction. Patient demographic characteristics and relevant attitudes and/or behaviors were measured before and immediately after interactions, and 4 and 16 weeks later. Physicians provided information before and immediately after interactions. PARTICIPANTS: Fourteen non-Black physicians and 72 low income Black patients at a Family Medicine residency training clinic. MAIN MEASURES: Sense of being on the same team, patient-centeredness, and patient trust of physician, assessed immediately after the medical interactions, and patient trust and adherence, assessed 4 and 16 weeks later. KEY RESULTS: Four and 16 weeks after interactions, patient trust of their physician and physicians in general was significantly greater in the treatment condition than control condition. Sixteen weeks after interactions, adherence was also significantly greater. CONCLUSIONS: An intervention used to reduce intergroup bias successfully produced greater Black patient trust of non-Black physicians and adherence. These findings offer promising evidence for a relatively low-cost and simple intervention that may offer a means to improve medical outcomes of racially discordant medical interactions. However, the sample size of physicians and patients was small, and thus the effectiveness of the intervention should be further tested in different settings, with different populations of physicians and other health outcomes.
BACKGROUND: Medical interactions between Black patients and non-Black physicians are less positive and productive than racially concordant ones and contribute to racial disparities in the quality of health care. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether an intervention based on the common ingroup identity model, previously used in nonmedical settings to reduce intergroup bias, would change physician and patient responses in racially discordant medical interactions and improve patient adherence. IINTERVENTION: Physicians and patients were randomly assigned to either a common identity treatment (to enhance their sense of commonality) or a control (standard health information) condition, and then engaged in a scheduled appointment. DESIGN: Intervention occurred just before the interaction. Patient demographic characteristics and relevant attitudes and/or behaviors were measured before and immediately after interactions, and 4 and 16 weeks later. Physicians provided information before and immediately after interactions. PARTICIPANTS: Fourteen non-Black physicians and 72 low income Black patients at a Family Medicine residency training clinic. MAIN MEASURES: Sense of being on the same team, patient-centeredness, and patient trust of physician, assessed immediately after the medical interactions, and patient trust and adherence, assessed 4 and 16 weeks later. KEY RESULTS: Four and 16 weeks after interactions, patient trust of their physician and physicians in general was significantly greater in the treatment condition than control condition. Sixteen weeks after interactions, adherence was also significantly greater. CONCLUSIONS: An intervention used to reduce intergroup bias successfully produced greater Black patient trust of non-Black physicians and adherence. These findings offer promising evidence for a relatively low-cost and simple intervention that may offer a means to improve medical outcomes of racially discordant medical interactions. However, the sample size of physicians and patients was small, and thus the effectiveness of the intervention should be further tested in different settings, with different populations of physicians and other health outcomes.
Authors: John F Dovidio; Louis A Penner; Terrance L Albrecht; Wynne E Norton; Samuel L Gaertner; J Nicole Shelton Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2008-05-26 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Lisa A Cooper; Debra L Roter; Kathryn A Carson; Mary Catherine Beach; Janice A Sabin; Anthony G Greenwald; Thomas S Inui Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2012-03-15 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Tessa V West; Samuel L Gaertner; Terrance L Albrecht; Rhonda K Dailey; Tsveti Markova Journal: J Exp Soc Psychol Date: 2010-03-01
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Donald Edmondson; Rhonda K Dailey; Tsveti Markova; Terrance L Albrecht; Samuel L Gaertner Journal: J Black Psychol Date: 2009-05-01
Authors: Lauren M Hamel; Robert Chapman; Mary Malloy; Susan Eggly; Louis A Penner; Anthony F Shields; Michael S Simon; Justin F Klamerus; Charles Schiffer; Terrence L Albrecht Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2015-09-21 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Michelle van Ryn; Rachel R Hardeman; Sean M Phelan; Sara E Burke; Julia Przedworski; Michele L Allen; Diana J Burgess; Jennifer Ridgeway; Richard O White; John F Dovidio Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2014-07-10
Authors: Louis A Penner; Felicity W K Harper; John F Dovidio; Terrance L Albrecht; Lauren M Hamel; Nicole Senft; Susan Eggly Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2017-08-30 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Richard Gonzalez; Terrance L Albrecht; Robert Chapman; Tanina Foster; Felicity W K Harper; Nao Hagiwara; Lauren M Hamel; Anthony F Shields; Shirish Gadgeel; Michael S Simon; Jennifer J Griggs; Susan Eggly Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2016-06-20 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Louis A Penner; John F Dovidio; Nao Hagiwara; Tanina Foster; Terrance L Albrecht; Robert A Chapman; Susan Eggly Journal: J Health Care Poor Underserved Date: 2016