David S Goldberg1, Scott D Halpern, Peter P Reese. 1. Department of Medicine, Division of Gastroenterology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA. david.goldberg@uphs.upenn.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: We sought to assess consent rates for organ donation from potential brain-dead donors, and to identify factors associated with variation in consent for donation that could guide the development of targeted interventions to increase organ consent rates. DESIGN, SETTING, AND SUBJECTS: We used data provided by the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network to analyze the 35,823 organ procurement organization-reported eligible deaths (potential brain-dead donors ≤ 70 yr of age) from January 1, 2008, to October 31, 2011. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Excluding cases where donation authorization was based on prior patient documentation (e.g., donor registry), consent was obtained on 21,601 (68.9%), not obtained on 8,727 (27.8%), and not requested on 1,080 (3.4%) eligible deaths. There were substantial differences in consent rates among racial/ethnic groups (77.0% in whites, 67.5% in Hispanics, 54.9% in blacks, and 48.1% in Asians) and organ procurement organizations (median [interquartile range]: 72.4% [67.5-87.3]). In generalized estimating equation models, with whites and patients ages 18-39 yr as the respective reference groups, consent for donation was less likely to be obtained among Hispanics (odds ratio 0.54; 95% confidence interval 0.44-0.65), blacks (odds ratio 0.35; 95% confidence interval 0.31-0.39), Asians (odds ratio 0.31; 95% confidence interval 0.25-0.37), and eligible donors ages 55-64 (odds ratio 0.72; 95% confidence interval 0.67-0.77), and ≥ 65 yr (odds ratio 0.58; 95% confidence interval 0.52-0.64). CONCLUSIONS: In presenting the first published analyses of consent rates among all eligible deaths, this study confirms smaller and regional studies that showed significant differences in consent rates between whites and racial/ethnic minorities (blacks, Hispanics, and Asians). The study also identifies considerable variation in consent rates between age groups and between organ procurement organizations. Critical care physicians are usually the front-line providers for potential brain-dead donors and their next-of-kin, and these data highlight the need for further research to identify the causes of variation in consent rates and mechanisms to increase rates where appropriate.
OBJECTIVES: We sought to assess consent rates for organ donation from potential brain-dead donors, and to identify factors associated with variation in consent for donation that could guide the development of targeted interventions to increase organ consent rates. DESIGN, SETTING, AND SUBJECTS: We used data provided by the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network to analyze the 35,823 organ procurement organization-reported eligible deaths (potential brain-dead donors ≤ 70 yr of age) from January 1, 2008, to October 31, 2011. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Excluding cases where donation authorization was based on prior patient documentation (e.g., donor registry), consent was obtained on 21,601 (68.9%), not obtained on 8,727 (27.8%), and not requested on 1,080 (3.4%) eligible deaths. There were substantial differences in consent rates among racial/ethnic groups (77.0% in whites, 67.5% in Hispanics, 54.9% in blacks, and 48.1% in Asians) and organ procurement organizations (median [interquartile range]: 72.4% [67.5-87.3]). In generalized estimating equation models, with whites and patients ages 18-39 yr as the respective reference groups, consent for donation was less likely to be obtained among Hispanics (odds ratio 0.54; 95% confidence interval 0.44-0.65), blacks (odds ratio 0.35; 95% confidence interval 0.31-0.39), Asians (odds ratio 0.31; 95% confidence interval 0.25-0.37), and eligible donors ages 55-64 (odds ratio 0.72; 95% confidence interval 0.67-0.77), and ≥ 65 yr (odds ratio 0.58; 95% confidence interval 0.52-0.64). CONCLUSIONS: In presenting the first published analyses of consent rates among all eligible deaths, this study confirms smaller and regional studies that showed significant differences in consent rates between whites and racial/ethnic minorities (blacks, Hispanics, and Asians). The study also identifies considerable variation in consent rates between age groups and between organ procurement organizations. Critical care physicians are usually the front-line providers for potential brain-dead donors and their next-of-kin, and these data highlight the need for further research to identify the causes of variation in consent rates and mechanisms to increase rates where appropriate.
Authors: Akinlolu O Ojo; Richard E Pietroski; Kevin O'Connor; Joshua J McGowan; David M Dickinson Journal: Am J Transplant Date: 2005-04 Impact factor: 8.086
Authors: T Shafer; R P Wood; C T Van Buren; G Guerriero; K Davis; D A Reyes; H Sullivan; T Levert-Cole Journal: Transplant Proc Date: 1997-12 Impact factor: 1.066
Authors: Francis L Delmonico; Ellen Sheehy; William H Marks; Prabhakar Baliga; Joshua J McGowan; John C Magee Journal: Am J Transplant Date: 2005-04 Impact factor: 8.086
Authors: Ellen Sheehy; Suzanne L Conrad; Lori E Brigham; Richard Luskin; Phyllis Weber; Mark Eakin; Lawrence Schkade; Lawrence Hunsicker Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2003-08-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: H M Nathan; B E Jarrell; B Broznik; R Kochik; B Hamilton; S Stuart; T Ackroyd; M Nell Journal: Transplantation Date: 1991-01 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Amanda M Rosenblum; Alvin Ho-Ting Li; Leo Roels; Bryan Stewart; Versha Prakash; Janice Beitel; Kimberly Young; Sam Shemie; Peter Nickerson; Amit X Garg Journal: Transpl Int Date: 2012-04-16 Impact factor: 3.782
Authors: Elizabeth M Sonnenberg; Jesse Y Hsu; Peter P Reese; David Goldberg; Peter L Abt Journal: Transplantation Date: 2019-10-21 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Ashley Y Choi; Oliver K Jawitz; Vignesh Raman; Samantha E Halpern; John C Haney; Jacob A Klapper; Matthew G Hartwig Journal: Ann Thorac Surg Date: 2020-05-31 Impact factor: 4.330
Authors: Natasha Gupta; Jacqueline M Garonzik-Wang; Ralph J Passarella; Megan L Salter; Lauren M Kucirka; Babak J Orandi; Andrew H Law; Dorry L Segev Journal: Clin Transplant Date: 2014-03-27 Impact factor: 2.863
Authors: I E Hall; B Schröppel; M D Doshi; J Ficek; F L Weng; R D Hasz; H Thiessen-Philbrook; P P Reese; C R Parikh Journal: Am J Transplant Date: 2015-03-11 Impact factor: 8.086