Calvin C Kuo1, William J Robb. 1. San Francisco Orthopaedic Residency Program, St Mary's Medical Center, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The prevention of medical and surgical harm remains an important public health problem despite increased awareness and implementation of safety programs. Successful introduction and maintenance of surgical safety programs require both surgeon leadership and collaborative surgeon-hospital alignment. Documentation of success of such surgical safety programs in orthopaedic practice is limited. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We describe the scope of orthopaedic surgical patient safety issues, define critical elements of orthopaedic surgical safety, and outline leadership roles for orthopaedic surgeons needed to establish and sustain a culture of safety in contemporary healthcare systems. METHODS: We identified the most common causes of preventable surgical harm based on adverse and sentinel surgical events reported to The Joint Commission. A comprehensive literature review through a MEDLINE(®) database search (January 1982 through April 2012) to identify pertinent orthopaedic surgical safety articles found 14 articles. Where gaps in orthopaedic literature were identified, the review was supplemented by 22 nonorthopaedic surgical references. Our final review included 36 articles. RESULTS: Six important surgical safety program elements needed to eliminate preventable surgical harm were identified: (1) effective surgical team communication, (2) proper informed consent, (3) implementation and regular use of surgical checklists, (4) proper surgical site/procedure identification, (5) reduction of surgical team distractions, and (6) routine surgical data collection and analysis to improve the safety and quality of surgical patient care. CONCLUSIONS: Successful surgical safety programs require a culture of safety supported by all six key surgical safety program elements, active surgeon champions, and collaborative hospital and/or administrative support designed to enhance surgical safety and improve surgical patient outcomes. Further research measuring improvements from such surgical safety systems in orthopaedic care is needed.
BACKGROUND: The prevention of medical and surgical harm remains an important public health problem despite increased awareness and implementation of safety programs. Successful introduction and maintenance of surgical safety programs require both surgeon leadership and collaborative surgeon-hospital alignment. Documentation of success of such surgical safety programs in orthopaedic practice is limited. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We describe the scope of orthopaedic surgical patient safety issues, define critical elements of orthopaedic surgical safety, and outline leadership roles for orthopaedic surgeons needed to establish and sustain a culture of safety in contemporary healthcare systems. METHODS: We identified the most common causes of preventable surgical harm based on adverse and sentinel surgical events reported to The Joint Commission. A comprehensive literature review through a MEDLINE(®) database search (January 1982 through April 2012) to identify pertinent orthopaedic surgical safety articles found 14 articles. Where gaps in orthopaedic literature were identified, the review was supplemented by 22 nonorthopaedic surgical references. Our final review included 36 articles. RESULTS: Six important surgical safety program elements needed to eliminate preventable surgical harm were identified: (1) effective surgical team communication, (2) proper informed consent, (3) implementation and regular use of surgical checklists, (4) proper surgical site/procedure identification, (5) reduction of surgical team distractions, and (6) routine surgical data collection and analysis to improve the safety and quality of surgical patient care. CONCLUSIONS: Successful surgical safety programs require a culture of safety supported by all six key surgical safety program elements, active surgeon champions, and collaborative hospital and/or administrative support designed to enhance surgical safety and improve surgical patient outcomes. Further research measuring improvements from such surgical safety systems in orthopaedic care is needed.
Authors: Liane R Ginsburg; You-Ta Chuang; Whitney Blair Berta; Peter G Norton; Peggy Ng; Deborah Tregunno; Julia Richardson Journal: Health Serv Res Date: 2010-03-10 Impact factor: 3.402
Authors: Julia Neily; Peter D Mills; Yinong Young-Xu; Brian T Carney; Priscilla West; David H Berger; Lisa M Mazzia; Douglas E Paull; James P Bagian Journal: JAMA Date: 2010-10-20 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Sonal Arora; Louise Hull; Nick Sevdalis; Tanya Tierney; Debra Nestel; Maria Woloshynowych; Ara Darzi; Roger Kneebone Journal: Am J Surg Date: 2010-01 Impact factor: 2.565
Authors: Sallie J Weaver; Michael A Rosen; Deborah DiazGranados; Elizabeth H Lazzara; Rebecca Lyons; Eduardo Salas; Stephen A Knych; Margie McKeever; Lee Adler; Mary Barker; Heidi B King Journal: Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf Date: 2010-03
Authors: Aaron S Fink; Allan V Prochazka; William G Henderson; Debra Bartenfeld; Carsie Nyirenda; Alexandra Webb; David H Berger; Kamal Itani; Thomas Whitehill; James Edwards; Mark Wilson; Cynthia Karsonovich; Patricia Parmelee Journal: J Am Coll Surg Date: 2010-06 Impact factor: 6.113
Authors: Philip F Stahel; Allison L Sabel; Michael S Victoroff; Jeffrey Varnell; Alan Lembitz; Dennis J Boyle; Ted J Clarke; Wade R Smith; Philip S Mehler Journal: Arch Surg Date: 2010-10
Authors: Eefje N de Vries; Hubert A Prins; Rogier M P H Crolla; Adriaan J den Outer; George van Andel; Sven H van Helden; Wolfgang S Schlack; M Agnès van Putten; Dirk J Gouma; Marcel G W Dijkgraaf; Susanne M Smorenburg; Marja A Boermeester Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2010-11-11 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Julia Neily; Peter D Mills; Noel Eldridge; Edward J Dunn; Carol Samples; James R Turner; Audrey Revere; Ralph G DePalma; James P Bagian Journal: Arch Surg Date: 2009-11
Authors: Wouter K G Leclercq; Sarah Sloot; Bram J Keulers; Saskia Houterman; Johan Legemaate; Margot Veerman; Leslie Thomas; Marc R Scheltinga Journal: Patient Saf Surg Date: 2016-10-22
Authors: Madeline C MacKechnie; Michael A MacKechnie; Esther M M van Lieshout; Michael H J Verhofstad; Jose Eduardo Quintero; Luis G Padilla Rojas; Horacio Tabares Neyra; Bibiana Dello Russo; Vincenzo Giordano; Eduardo Vilensky; Sheryl L Fuehrer; Theodore Miclau Journal: OTA Int Date: 2021-10-19