Katia Ambert-Balay1, Pierre Pothier. 1. National Reference Center for Enteric Viruses, Laboratory of Virology, University Hospital of Dijon, 2 rue Angélique Ducoudray, BP 37013, 21070 Dijon, France. katia.balay@chu-dijon.fr
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The rapid detection of noroviruses is essential to implement measures to reduce the rapid spread of gastroenteritis infections they cause, notably in institutions. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate 4 rapid immunochromatographic tests: RIDA(®)QUICK Norovirus, ImmunoCardSTAT!(®) Norovirus, NOROTOP(®) and SD BIOLINE NOROVIRUS by determining their sensitivity and specificity on a large panel of samples representing 11 genotypes of norovirus genogroup I and 14 of genogroup II, and their cross-reactivity with other enteric viruses. STUDY DESIGN: Thawed stool samples containing norovirus genogroup I or II or other enteric viruses, and negative samples, were tested by the 4 assays and compared to the reference standard RT-PCR. Fresh stool samples were also tested by RIDA(®)QUICK. RESULTS: The sensitivity of RIDA(®)QUICK, ImmunoCardSTAT!(®), NOROTOP(®) and SD BIOLINE for the detection of norovirus genogroup I on thawed samples was 17%, 26%, 52% and 23%, respectively. For genogroup II, the sensitivity was 64%, 39%, 50% and 54%, respectively. For GII.4, the main circulating genotype, the sensitivity was 78%, 59%, 61% and 67%, respectively. For all tests, the specificity was 100% and no cross-reactivity with other enteric viruses was observed. The sensitivity of RIDA(®)QUICK on fresh stool samples positive for GII.4 was 71%. CONCLUSIONS: Knowing that most gastroenteritis cases are due to GII.4, the immunochromatographic tests may be useful for preliminary screening, notably in outbreaks. However, negative samples need to be tested using RT-PCR methods.
BACKGROUND: The rapid detection of noroviruses is essential to implement measures to reduce the rapid spread of gastroenteritis infections they cause, notably in institutions. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate 4 rapid immunochromatographic tests: RIDA(®)QUICK Norovirus, ImmunoCardSTAT!(®) Norovirus, NOROTOP(®) and SD BIOLINE NOROVIRUS by determining their sensitivity and specificity on a large panel of samples representing 11 genotypes of norovirus genogroup I and 14 of genogroup II, and their cross-reactivity with other enteric viruses. STUDY DESIGN: Thawed stool samples containing norovirus genogroup I or II or other enteric viruses, and negative samples, were tested by the 4 assays and compared to the reference standard RT-PCR. Fresh stool samples were also tested by RIDA(®)QUICK. RESULTS: The sensitivity of RIDA(®)QUICK, ImmunoCardSTAT!(®), NOROTOP(®) and SD BIOLINE for the detection of norovirus genogroup I on thawed samples was 17%, 26%, 52% and 23%, respectively. For genogroup II, the sensitivity was 64%, 39%, 50% and 54%, respectively. For GII.4, the main circulating genotype, the sensitivity was 78%, 59%, 61% and 67%, respectively. For all tests, the specificity was 100% and no cross-reactivity with other enteric viruses was observed. The sensitivity of RIDA(®)QUICK on fresh stool samples positive for GII.4 was 71%. CONCLUSIONS: Knowing that most gastroenteritis cases are due to GII.4, the immunochromatographic tests may be useful for preliminary screening, notably in outbreaks. However, negative samples need to be tested using RT-PCR methods.
Authors: Sue E Crawford; Nadim Ajami; Tracy Dewese Parker; Noritoshi Kitamoto; Katsuro Natori; Naokazu Takeda; Tomoyuki Tanaka; Baijun Kou; Robert L Atmar; Mary K Estes Journal: Clin Vaccine Immunol Date: 2014-11-26
Authors: Amy M Hurwitz; Wanzhi Huang; Mary K Estes; Robert L Atmar; Timothy Palzkill Journal: Protein Eng Des Sel Date: 2016-12-28 Impact factor: 1.650
Authors: Jennifer D Rogers; Nadim J Ajami; Bartlomiej G Fryszczyn; Mary K Estes; Robert L Atmar; Timothy Palzkill Journal: J Clin Microbiol Date: 2013-04-03 Impact factor: 5.948