| Literature DB >> 23151213 |
Yvette L Roe1, Christopher J Zeitz, Bronwyn Fredericks.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Studies that compare Indigenous Australian and non-Indigenous patients who experience a cardiac event or chest pain are inconclusive about the reasons for the differences in-hospital and survival rates. The advances in diagnostic accuracy, medication and specialised workforce has contributed to a lower case fatality and lengthen survival rates however this is not evident in the Indigenous Australian population. A possible driver contributing to this disparity may be the impact of patient-clinician interface during key interactions during the health care process. METHODS/Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2012 PMID: 23151213 PMCID: PMC3547801 DOI: 10.1186/1472-6963-12-397
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Health Serv Res ISSN: 1472-6963 Impact factor: 2.655
Figure 1Conceptual diagram of the research.
Factors that influence patient-clinician engagement and the adverse consequences
| Cultural Safety | · Health professional are self-aware of their ontology, epistemology and axiology. | Actions that diminish, demean or disempower the cultural identity and well-being of an individual is unsafe clinical practice [ |
| | · An environment that facilitates and nurtures relationships | Patients viewed the medical system as cold, indifferent and inflexible [ |
| | · Health services do not comprise the patients legitimate cultural rights, views and values.” [ | |
| | · High staff turnover [ | |
| (Mis) Communication | · Language (verbal and non-verbal), | · May result in misdiagnosis; ineffective and inefficient clinical management; and marginalisation of the patient [ |
| | · Rules, conventions and etiquette; | |
| | Communication between the community primary health care provider and the tertiary institution [ | · An inefficient model of care i.e. ‘no shows’ in patient travel and patient has limited understanding of their clinical care [ |
| (Dis) Empowerment | · A distressing patient journey [ | · Patients feel disempowered, discriminated by their race and clinicians show a lack of empathy toward them [ |
| | · Financial burden | |
| | · Language barriers | |
| | · Lack of culturally appropriate resources | |
| | · Inadequate pre-operative preparation and post-operative follow-up. | |
| | · Lack of cognitive control [ | |
| (Mis) Trust | · Informed by a whole of life experience; which included systemic oppression and discrimination with societal institutions (particularly justice and education settings). | · In response to racist treatment people felt ashamed, humiliated, powerless and fearful; which in turn contributed to the lack of trust [ |
| | · In an individual encounter. | |
| Biomedical Model | · The dominance of medical language used to explain clinical diagnosis, management and long-term care. | · Removes the opportunity to construct a shared understanding of health care [ |
| · Marginalisation of the patience preferred language or knowledge [ | · Patients feel alienated and less likely to participate with the recommended care [ |
Focus Group Questions
| | | ||
| Opening | Participants get acquainted & feel comfortable | Please tell us your name and how are you feeling today? | Please tell us your name and where you work? |
| Introductory | Begins discussion of topic | How has having a heart problem influenced your life? | How long have you been employed in cardiac care? |
| Transition | Moves smoothly and seamlessly into key questions | I would like you to reflect when you became unwell because of your heart, when you were admitted to hospital and after you left hospital. | We often use the term patient journey, however there are many components to it i.e. clinical presentation, guidelines, risk factors, patient involvement etc. |
| | | Are there any specific things about the how you got along with the health care providers or the care you received that stands out in your mind? How would you describe your relationship with the people who provided your care? | Are there any specific things about that you have done during your interaction with patient that you felt made it a good interaction that is critical to providing cardiac care? E.g. imparting facts in a way that there is a shared meaning? |
| Key | Obtains insight into areas of central concern in the study | Do you feel that you were able to establish trust and rapport with the people who provided your care? | When I say the term ‘patient-clinician engagement’ what things come to mind? |
| | | Do you feel that you were able to talk easy to the health staff, especially if you had concerns about your heart or things that worried you? | Is it a term that you’ve heard of and that you are familiar with? |
| | | | Do you felt you developed trust and rapport with the patients? |
| | | What things made you feel like you had a good relationship with the people who provided your health care? | How do you build trust, rapport and a shared understanding with patients? |
| | | When you left hospital, how easy was it to gets health care so you could look after your heart? i.e. seeing the doctor or specialists, rehabilitation, getting medication etc. | Where do you think trust, rapport and understanding falls downs when you are caring for patients? |
| | | | Do you have a specific strategy when caring for Indigenous patients? |
| | | What are the things that may influence or stop you looking after your heart? | Can you provide some examples of how care maybe different for Indigenous and non-Indigenous patients? |
| | | What can health care providers do to help you look after your heart? | What can health professionals do to encourage patient-clinician engagement? Is this different for Indigenous and non-Indigenous patients? |
| Ending | Helps the researcher determine where to place emphasis and bring closure to the discussion. | Moderator to summarise key discussion points. | |
| | | Is this an adequate summary of what was said here? | |
| | | We are trying to make the patient journey better. | |
| What advice would you have for us? | |||
1. Houston S. Aboriginal cultural security. Perth: Health Department of Western Australia2001.
2. Shahid S, Finn L, Thompson S. Barriers to participation of Aboriginal people in cancer care: communication in the hospital setting. Medical Journal of Australia. 2009;190:574–9.
3. Gallaher G, Ziersch A, Baum F, Bently M, Palmer C, Edmondson W, et al. In our own backyard: Urban health inequities and Aboriginal experiences of neighbourhood life, social capital and racism. Adelaide: Flinders University2009.
4. Ramsden I. The Treaty of Waitangi and cultural safety: The role of the treaty in nursing and midwifery education in Aotearoa. Wellington: Nursing Council of New Zealand1996.
5. Lawrence M, Dodd Z, Mohor S, Dunn S, de Crespigny C, Power C, et al. Improving the Patient Journey: Achieving Positive Outcomes for Remote Aboriginal Cardiac Patients. Darwin: Cooperative Research Centre for Aboriginal Health2009.
6. Lowell A, Brown I, Marrnanyin B, Flack M, Christie M, Snelling P, et al. Sharing the true stories, Improving communication between health staff and Aboriginal patients, STAGE 1 Report. Darwin: Cooperative Research Centre for Aborignal Health2005.
7. Brown A, D., Morrissey M, J., Sherwood J, M. Uncovering the Determinants of Cardiovascular Disease among Indigenous People. Ethnicity & Health. 2006;11 [2]:191–210.
8. Cass A, Lowell A, Christie M, Snelling P, L., Flack M, Marrnganyin B, et al. Sharing the true stories: improving communication between Aboriginal patients and health care workers. Medical Journal of Australia. 2002 20 May 2002;176:466–70.
Figure 2Triple layered designed focus groups: Locations and Composition.