| Literature DB >> 22942882 |
Frederike Schirmbeck1, Mathias Zink.
Abstract
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is rarely associated with schizophrenia, whereas 20 to 30% of schizophrenic patients, suffer from comorbid obsessive-compulsive symptoms (OCS). So far no single pathogenetic theory convincingly explained this fact suggesting heterogeneous subgroups. Based on long-term case observations, one hypothesis assumes that second-onset OCS in the course of schizophrenia might be a side effect of second generation antipsychotics (SGA), most importantly clozapine (CLZ). This review summarizes the supporting epidemiological and pharmacological evidence: Estimations on prevalence of OCS increase in more recent cross-sectional studies and in later disease stages. Longitudinal observations report the de novo-onset of OCS under clozapine treatment. This association has not been reported with first generation antipsychotics (FGA) or SGAs with mainly dopaminergic mode of action. Finally, significant correlations of OCS-severity with duration of treatment, dose and serum levels suggest clozapine-induced OCS. However, supposed causal interactions need further verifications. It is also unclear, which neurobiological mechanisms might underlie the pathogenetic process. Detailed genotypic and phenotypic characterizations of schizophrenics with comorbid OCS regarding neurocognitive functioning and activation in sensitive tasks of functional magnetic imaging are needed. Multimodal large-scaled prospective studies are necessary to define patients at risk for second-onset OCS and to improve early detection and therapeutic interventions.Entities:
Keywords: Clozapine; comorbidity; compulsive; obsessive; pharmacology; schizophrenia; serotonin.
Year: 2012 PMID: 22942882 PMCID: PMC3286851 DOI: 10.2174/157015912799362724
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Curr Neuropharmacol ISSN: 1570-159X Impact factor: 7.363
Epidemiological Evidence
| Argument | References | Number of Patients and Clinical Characterization | Design | Main Findings | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Rubino | 197 Schizophrenic patients | Retrospective assessment of morbidity before the age of 18 | 8 % of schizophrenic patients suffer from OCD before age of 18 | ||
|
Niendam | 64 UHR-patients | Cross-sectional survey using SIPS and Padua-inventory | 20 % of UHR patients report OCS. This comorbid subgroup, however, shows a lower risk for conversion into psychosis. | ||
| De
Haan | 196 FEP | Retrospective chart study | 7 % of FEPs showed OCS at first manifestation. | ||
|
Shioiri | 219 FEP | Retrospective assessment of OCS-prevalence | 3 % of FEPs showed OCS in the prodromal phase and 1.5 % fulfil diagnostic criteria for OCD at first manifestation | ||
|
Poyurovsky | 50 FEP | Cross-sectional assessment of OCD comorbidity | At first manifestation of psychosis, 14 % fulfil criteria for OCD. | ||
|
Sterk | 194 FEP | Cross-sectional assessment of OCS comorbidity | At first manifestation of psychosis, 9.3 % fulfil criteria for OCD. | ||
|
Mukhopadhaya | 1972 | Review of studies reporting on OCS prevalence in schizophrenia | High variability. Mean prevalence of 22 % reviewing data on 1972 patients. | ||
|
Buckley | 3656 | Review of studies reporting on OCS prevalence in schizophrenia | Mean prevalence of 23 %. | ||
|
Lysaker | Not specified | Review of studies reporting on OCS prevalence in schizophrenia | Amongst schizophrenic patients, more than one third suffers from clinically significant OCS, 10 to 25 % meet diagnostic criteria of OCD | ||
|
Case reports Zink
| Longitudinal observation of course of illness | First manifestation and start of antipsychotic treatment precede onset of OCS | |||
| De
Haan | 121 recent-onset schizophrenic patients | Longitudinal observation of course of illness | Emergence or increase of OCS in 1.3 % of non-clozapine treated and 20.6 % of clozapine-treated patients | ||
|
Lykouras | 55 schizophrenia patients | Systematic review of published case reports |
Until 2003, a | ||
| De
Haan | 200 recent-onset schizophrenic patients | Longitudinal observation of course of illness | Emergence or increase of OCS in 0 % of non-clozapine treated and 9.8 % of clozapine-treated patients. | ||
|
Lin | CLZ: 102 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-treatment with or without OCS | Within 39 clozapine-treated patients with OCS, 29 were classified as clozapine-induced. | ||
|
Lim | Total sample: 209, comorbid subsample: 26 | Cross-sectional. Stratification for SZ with or without OCS | Within 26 schizophrenics with SGA-associated OCS, only 3 had a history of transient OCS before the onset of psychosis | ||
|
Schirmbeck |
CLZ: 26 | Cross-sectional. Stratification for treatment with SGAs in monotherapy | Within 39 patients, 28 showed OCS, but only 3 reported OCS before or at onset of psychosis. | ||
Epidemiological evidence in favour of an increase of OCS-prevalence during course of illness suggests the de novo-onset of an SGA-induced side effect. Abbreviations: FEP: first episode schizophrenic patients; FGA: first generation antipsychotics; OCD: obsessive compulsive disorder; OCS: obsessive compulsive symptoms; OLZ: olanzapine; SGA: second generation antipsychotics; SIPS: Structured interview for prodromal symptoms; SZ: schizophrenia and schizophrenia spectrum disorders; UHR: Ultra high risk
Pharmacological Evidence
| Argument | Reference | Number of Patients | Design | Main Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Lim | Total sample: 209, comorbid subsample: 26 | Cross-sectional. Stratification for SZ with or without OCS | CLZ-treatment in 35.9 % of the total sample, but in 76.9 % of the comorbid patients | |
|
Sa |
CLZ: 40 | Cross-sectional. Stratification for treatment with CLZ or HAL | Prevalence of OCS 20 % (CLZ) vs. 10 % (HAL). Higher severity of OCS with CLZ | |
|
Ertugrul | CLZ: 50 | Cross-sectional. Stratification of treatment with CLZ |
Within 50 patients treated with CLZ, 76% showed OCS.
20 % reported retrospectively | |
|
Schirmbeck
|
CLZ: 26 | Cross-sectional. Stratification for treatment with SGAs in monotherapy | Prevalence of OCS 71.8 % in CLZ or OLZ vs. 9.7 % in AMS or APZ. Highest severity of OCS with CLZ | |
|
Lin | CLZ: 102 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-treatment with or without OCS | Duration of CLZ-treatment significantly longer in CLZ-OCS-patients (82 vs. 56 months), no difference in duration of illness | |
|
Schirmbeck
| CLZ: 26 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-monotherapy | Duration of CLZ-treatment correlates positively with OCS severity (YBOCS, R=0.59). | |
|
Reznik | N=15 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-therapy | Dosage-related, pro-obsessive influence of CLZ | |
|
Mukhopadhaya | N=59 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-therapy | Higher CLZ-dosage in patients with comorbid OCS (432 mg/day) than without (351 mg/day) | |
|
Schirmbeck
| CLZ: 26 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-monotherapy | CLZ-dosage correlates positively with OCS severity (YBOCS, R=0.50). | |
|
Lin | CLZ: 102 | Cross-sectional: Stratification for CLZ-treatment with or without OCS | Higher plasma concentrations in CLZ-treated patients with OCS (595 ng/L) than without OCS (434 ng/L). | |
|
Rocha | 3 | Longitudinal observation of OCS severity | Reduction of OCS severity after CLZ down-tapering in combination with APZ | |
|
Zink | 1 | Longitudinal observation of OCS severity | Reduction of OCS severity from YBOCS 24 to 19 after reduction of CLZ from 500 to 250 mg/die and combination with APZ (30 mg) | |
|
Englisch | 7 | Longitudinal observation of OCS severity | Reduction of OCS severity from YBOCS 19 to 12 after reduction of CLZ from 364 to 293 mg/die and combination with APZ (23 mg) |
Pharmacological evidence in favour of an association between clozapine-treatment and OCS. Abbreviations: AMS: amisulpride; APZ: aripiprazole; CLZ: clozapine; FGA: first generation antipsychotics; HAL: haloperidol; OCS: obsessive compulsive symptoms; OLZ: olanzapine; SGA: second generation antipsychotics; SZ: schizophrenia and schizophrenia spectrum disorders; YBOCS: Yale-Brown-Obsessive-Compulsive Scale.