OBJECTIVE: Studies have repeatedly found that providers miss 70-90% of opportunities to express empathy. Our study sought to characterize provider responses to patients' emotions, with the overall goal of better understanding reasons for lack of empathic response. METHODS: We analyzed 47 visits between patients and their providers. We defined empathic opportunities as instances where patients expressed a strong negative emotion. We then developed thematic categories to describe provider response. RESULTS: We found a total of 29 empathic opportunities within 21 visits. Provider responses were categorized as ignore, dismiss, elicit information, problem-solve, or empathize. An empathic statement occurred at some point in the response sequence in 13/29 opportunities (45%). When problem-solving was the initial response, empathic statements rarely occurred in subsequent dialogue. Among the 16 instances with no empathic statements, providers engaged in problem-solving in 8 (50%). CONCLUSION: Similar to other studies, we found providers missed most opportunities to respond empathically to patient emotion. Yet contrary to common understanding, providers often addressed the problem underlying the emotion, especially when the problem involved logistical or biomedical issues, as opposed to grief. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: With enhanced awareness, providers may better recognize situations where they can offer empathy in addition to problem-solving.
OBJECTIVE: Studies have repeatedly found that providers miss 70-90% of opportunities to express empathy. Our study sought to characterize provider responses to patients' emotions, with the overall goal of better understanding reasons for lack of empathic response. METHODS: We analyzed 47 visits between patients and their providers. We defined empathic opportunities as instances where patients expressed a strong negative emotion. We then developed thematic categories to describe provider response. RESULTS: We found a total of 29 empathic opportunities within 21 visits. Provider responses were categorized as ignore, dismiss, elicit information, problem-solve, or empathize. An empathic statement occurred at some point in the response sequence in 13/29 opportunities (45%). When problem-solving was the initial response, empathic statements rarely occurred in subsequent dialogue. Among the 16 instances with no empathic statements, providers engaged in problem-solving in 8 (50%). CONCLUSION: Similar to other studies, we found providers missed most opportunities to respond empathically to patient emotion. Yet contrary to common understanding, providers often addressed the problem underlying the emotion, especially when the problem involved logistical or biomedical issues, as opposed to grief. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: With enhanced awareness, providers may better recognize situations where they can offer empathy in addition to problem-solving.
Authors: Debra L Roter; Susan Larson; Harold Shinitzky; Robin Chernoff; Janet R Serwint; Graceanne Adamo; Larry Wissow Journal: Med Educ Date: 2004-02 Impact factor: 6.251
Authors: Mary Catherine Beach; Somnath Saha; P Todd Korthuis; Victoria Sharp; Jonathon Cohn; Ira B Wilson; Susan Eggly; Lisa A Cooper; Debra Roter; Andrea Sankar; Richard Moore Journal: AIDS Behav Date: 2011-05
Authors: Tabor E Flickinger; Somnath Saha; Debra Roter; P Todd Korthuis; Victoria Sharp; Jonathan Cohn; Susan Eggly; Richard D Moore; Mary Catherine Beach Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2015-09-03
Authors: Stewart C Alexander; Susan Ladwig; Sally A Norton; David Gramling; J Kelly Davis; Maureen Metzger; Jane DeLuca; Robert Gramling Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2014-03-03 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: Tai Kyung Hairston; Anne R Links; Vandra Harris; David E Tunkel; Jonathan Walsh; Mary Catherine Beach; Emily F Boss Journal: JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 2019-01-01 Impact factor: 6.223
Authors: Tabor E Flickinger; Somnath Saha; Debra Roter; P Todd Korthuis; Victoria Sharp; Jonathan Cohn; Richard D Moore; Karen S Ingersoll; Mary Catherine Beach Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2015-08-20
Authors: Megan Johnson Shen; Jamie S Ostroff; Heidi A Hamann; Noshin Haque; Smita C Banerjee; Daniel C McFarland; Daniela Molena; Carma L Bylund Journal: J Health Commun Date: 2019-09-16
Authors: Timothy J Williamson; Jamie S Ostroff; Chloé M Martin; Smita C Banerjee; Carma L Bylund; Heidi A Hamann; Megan Johnson Shen Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2020-08-11