PURPOSE: The interpretation of genetic information has always been challenging, but next-generation sequencing produces data on such a vast scale that many more variants of uncertain pathogenicity will be found. We exemplify this issue with reference to human rhodopsin, in which pathogenic mutations can lead to autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa. METHODS: Rhodopsin variants, with unknown pathogenicity, were found in patients by next-generation and Sanger sequencing and a multidisciplinary approach was used to determine their functional significance. RESULTS: Four variants in rhodopsin were identified: F45L, P53R, R69H, and M39R, with the latter two substitutions being novel. We investigated the cellular transport and photopigment function of all four human substitutions and found that the F45L and R69H variants behave like wild-type and are highly unlikely to be pathogenic. By contrast, P53R (a de novo change) and M39R were retained in the endoplasmic reticulum with significantly reduced functionality and are clearly pathogenic. CONCLUSION: Potential pathogenicity of variants requires careful assessment using clinical, genetic, and functional data. We suggest that a multidisciplinary pathway of assessment, using several functional assays, will be required if next-generation sequencing is to be used effectively, reliably, and safely in the clinical environment.
PURPOSE: The interpretation of genetic information has always been challenging, but next-generation sequencing produces data on such a vast scale that many more variants of uncertain pathogenicity will be found. We exemplify this issue with reference to human rhodopsin, in which pathogenic mutations can lead to autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa. METHODS: Rhodopsin variants, with unknown pathogenicity, were found in patients by next-generation and Sanger sequencing and a multidisciplinary approach was used to determine their functional significance. RESULTS: Four variants in rhodopsin were identified: F45L, P53R, R69H, and M39R, with the latter two substitutions being novel. We investigated the cellular transport and photopigment function of all four human substitutions and found that the F45L and R69H variants behave like wild-type and are highly unlikely to be pathogenic. By contrast, P53R (a de novo change) and M39R were retained in the endoplasmic reticulum with significantly reduced functionality and are clearly pathogenic. CONCLUSION: Potential pathogenicity of variants requires careful assessment using clinical, genetic, and functional data. We suggest that a multidisciplinary pathway of assessment, using several functional assays, will be required if next-generation sequencing is to be used effectively, reliably, and safely in the clinical environment.
Authors: Benjamin M Scott; Steven K Chen; Nihar Bhattacharyya; Abdiwahab Y Moalim; Sergey V Plotnikov; Elise Heon; Sergio G Peisajovich; Belinda S W Chang Journal: Genetics Date: 2018-12-04 Impact factor: 4.562
Authors: Morag E Shanks; Susan M Downes; Richard R Copley; Stefano Lise; John Broxholme; Karl Az Hudspith; Alexandra Kwasniewska; Wayne Il Davies; Mark W Hankins; Emily R Packham; Penny Clouston; Anneke Seller; Andrew Om Wilkie; Jenny C Taylor; Jiannis Ragoussis; Andrea H Németh Journal: Eur J Hum Genet Date: 2012-09-12 Impact factor: 4.246
Authors: D Paul Mallory; Elizabeth Gutierrez; Margaret Pinkevitch; Christie Klinginsmith; William D Comar; Francis J Roushar; Jonathan P Schlebach; Adam W Smith; Beata Jastrzebska Journal: Biochemistry Date: 2018-08-21 Impact factor: 3.162
Authors: Ricardo Parolin Schnekenberg; Emma M Perkins; Jack W Miller; Wayne I L Davies; Maria Cristina D'Adamo; Mauro Pessia; Katherine A Fawcett; David Sims; Elodie Gillard; Karl Hudspith; Paul Skehel; Jonathan Williams; Mary O'Regan; Sandeep Jayawant; Rosalind Jefferson; Sarah Hughes; Andrea Lustenberger; Jiannis Ragoussis; Mandy Jackson; Stephen J Tucker; Andrea H Németh Journal: Brain Date: 2015-05-16 Impact factor: 13.501
Authors: Andrea L Vincent; Joseph Carroll; Gerald A Fishman; Alexandra Sauer; Dianne Sharp; Phyllis Summerfelt; Vesper Williams; Adam M Dubis; Susanne Kohl; Fulton Wong Journal: Transl Vis Sci Technol Date: 2013-03-13 Impact factor: 3.283