AIM: Errors are most likely to occur during the pre- and postanalytic phases of the genetic testing process, which can contribute to underuse, overuse, and misuse of genetic tests. To mitigate these errors, we created a template for molecular genetic test reports that utilizes the combined features of synoptic reporting and narrative interpretation. METHODS: A variation of the Delphi consensus process with an expert panel was used to create a draft report template, which was further informed by focus group discussions with primary care physicians. RESULTS: There was agreement that molecular genetic test reports should present information in groupings that flow in a logical manner, and most participants preferred the following order of presentation: patient and physician information, test performed, test results and interpretation, guidance on next steps, and supplemental information. We define data elements for the report as "required," "optional," "possible," and "not necessary"; provide recommendations regarding the grouping of these data elements; and describe the ideal design of the report template, including the preferred order of the report sections, formatting of data, and length of the report. DISCUSSION: With input from key stakeholders and building upon prior work, we created a template for molecular genetic test reports designed to improve clinical decision making at the point of care. The template design should lead to more effective communication between the laboratory and ordering clinician. Studies are needed to assess the usefulness and effectiveness of molecular genetic test reports generated using this template.
AIM: Errors are most likely to occur during the pre- and postanalytic phases of the genetic testing process, which can contribute to underuse, overuse, and misuse of genetic tests. To mitigate these errors, we created a template for molecular genetic test reports that utilizes the combined features of synoptic reporting and narrative interpretation. METHODS: A variation of the Delphi consensus process with an expert panel was used to create a draft report template, which was further informed by focus group discussions with primary care physicians. RESULTS: There was agreement that molecular genetic test reports should present information in groupings that flow in a logical manner, and most participants preferred the following order of presentation: patient and physician information, test performed, test results and interpretation, guidance on next steps, and supplemental information. We define data elements for the report as "required," "optional," "possible," and "not necessary"; provide recommendations regarding the grouping of these data elements; and describe the ideal design of the report template, including the preferred order of the report sections, formatting of data, and length of the report. DISCUSSION: With input from key stakeholders and building upon prior work, we created a template for molecular genetic test reports designed to improve clinical decision making at the point of care. The template design should lead to more effective communication between the laboratory and ordering clinician. Studies are needed to assess the usefulness and effectiveness of molecular genetic test reports generated using this template.
Authors: Michael O Dorschner; Laura M Amendola; Brian H Shirts; Lesli Kiedrowski; Joseph Salama; Adam S Gordon; Stephanie M Fullerton; Peter Tarczy-Hornoch; Peter H Byers; Gail P Jarvik Journal: Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet Date: 2014-03-10 Impact factor: 3.908
Authors: Maren T Scheuner; Kenute Myrie; Jane Peredo; Lori Hoffman-Hogg; Margaret Lundquist; Stephanie L Guerra; Douglas Ball Journal: Fed Pract Date: 2020-08
Authors: Elizabeth Cutting; Meghan Banchero; Amber L Beitelshees; James J Cimino; Guilherme Del Fiol; Ayse P Gurses; Mark A Hoffman; Linda Jo Bone Jeng; Kensaku Kawamoto; Mark Kelemen; Harold Alan Pincus; Alan R Shuldiner; Marc S Williams; Toni I Pollin; Casey Lynnette Overby Journal: J Biomed Inform Date: 2016-07-14 Impact factor: 6.317
Authors: Jason L Vassy; Charles A Brunette; Nilla Majahalme; Sanjay Advani; Lauren MacMullen; Cynthia Hau; Andrew J Zimolzak; Stephen J Miller Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2018-10-24 Impact factor: 2.226
Authors: Christopher G Chute; Mollie Ullman-Cullere; Grant M Wood; Simon M Lin; Min He; Jyotishman Pathak Journal: Genet Med Date: 2013-09-05 Impact factor: 8.822
Authors: Sue Richards; Nazneen Aziz; Sherri Bale; David Bick; Soma Das; Julie Gastier-Foster; Wayne W Grody; Madhuri Hegde; Elaine Lyon; Elaine Spector; Karl Voelkerding; Heidi L Rehm Journal: Genet Med Date: 2015-03-05 Impact factor: 8.822
Authors: Susanne B Haga; Rachel Mills; Kathryn I Pollak; Catherine Rehder; Adam H Buchanan; Isaac M Lipkus; Jennifer H Crow; Michael Datto Journal: Genome Med Date: 2014-07-31 Impact factor: 11.117
Authors: Ribhi Hazin; Kyle B Brothers; Bradley A Malin; Barbara A Koenig; Saskia C Sanderson; Mark A Rothstein; Marc S Williams; Ellen W Clayton; Iftikhar J Kullo Journal: Genet Med Date: 2013-09-12 Impact factor: 8.822
Authors: Maren T Scheuner; Jane Peredo; Kelly Tangney; Diane Schoeff; Taylor Sale; Caroline Lubick-Goldzweig; Alison Hamilton; Lee Hilborne; Martin Lee; Brian Mittman; Elizabeth M Yano; Ira M Lubin Journal: Genet Med Date: 2016-06-30 Impact factor: 8.822
Authors: Catherine A Brownstein; Alan H Beggs; Nils Homer; Barry Merriman; Timothy W Yu; Katherine C Flannery; Elizabeth T DeChene; Meghan C Towne; Sarah K Savage; Emily N Price; Ingrid A Holm; Lovelace J Luquette; Elaine Lyon; Joseph Majzoub; Peter Neupert; David McCallie; Peter Szolovits; Huntington F Willard; Nancy J Mendelsohn; Renee Temme; Richard S Finkel; Sabrina W Yum; Livija Medne; Shamil R Sunyaev; Ivan Adzhubey; Christopher A Cassa; Paul I W de Bakker; Hatice Duzkale; Piotr Dworzyński; William Fairbrother; Laurent Francioli; Birgit H Funke; Monica A Giovanni; Robert E Handsaker; Kasper Lage; Matthew S Lebo; Monkol Lek; Ignaty Leshchiner; Daniel G MacArthur; Heather M McLaughlin; Michael F Murray; Tune H Pers; Paz P Polak; Soumya Raychaudhuri; Heidi L Rehm; Rachel Soemedi; Nathan O Stitziel; Sara Vestecka; Jochen Supper; Claudia Gugenmus; Bernward Klocke; Alexander Hahn; Max Schubach; Mortiz Menzel; Saskia Biskup; Peter Freisinger; Mario Deng; Martin Braun; Sven Perner; Richard J H Smith; Janeen L Andorf; Jian Huang; Kelli Ryckman; Val C Sheffield; Edwin M Stone; Thomas Bair; E Ann Black-Ziegelbein; Terry A Braun; Benjamin Darbro; Adam P DeLuca; Diana L Kolbe; Todd E Scheetz; Aiden E Shearer; Rama Sompallae; Kai Wang; Alexander G Bassuk; Erik Edens; Katherine Mathews; Steven A Moore; Oleg A Shchelochkov; Pamela Trapane; Aaron Bossler; Colleen A Campbell; Jonathan W Heusel; Anne Kwitek; Tara Maga; Karin Panzer; Thomas Wassink; Douglas Van Daele; Hela Azaiez; Kevin Booth; Nic Meyer; Michael M Segal; Marc S Williams; Gerard Tromp; Peter White; Donald Corsmeier; Sara Fitzgerald-Butt; Gail Herman; Devon Lamb-Thrush; Kim L McBride; David Newsom; Christopher R Pierson; Alexander T Rakowsky; Aleš Maver; Luca Lovrečić; Anja Palandačić; Borut Peterlin; Ali Torkamani; Anna Wedell; Mikael Huss; Andrey Alexeyenko; Jessica M Lindvall; Måns Magnusson; Daniel Nilsson; Henrik Stranneheim; Fulya Taylan; Christian Gilissen; Alexander Hoischen; Bregje van Bon; Helger Yntema; Marcel Nelen; Weidong Zhang; Jason Sager; Lu Zhang; Kathryn Blair; Deniz Kural; Michael Cariaso; Greg G Lennon; Asif Javed; Saloni Agrawal; Pauline C Ng; Komal S Sandhu; Shuba Krishna; Vamsi Veeramachaneni; Ofer Isakov; Eran Halperin; Eitan Friedman; Noam Shomron; Gustavo Glusman; Jared C Roach; Juan Caballero; Hannah C Cox; Denise Mauldin; Seth A Ament; Lee Rowen; Daniel R Richards; F Anthony San Lucas; Manuel L Gonzalez-Garay; C Thomas Caskey; Yu Bai; Ying Huang; Fang Fang; Yan Zhang; Zhengyuan Wang; Jorge Barrera; Juan M Garcia-Lobo; Domingo González-Lamuño; Javier Llorca; Maria C Rodriguez; Ignacio Varela; Martin G Reese; Francisco M De La Vega; Edward Kiruluta; Michele Cargill; Reece K Hart; Jon M Sorenson; Gholson J Lyon; David A Stevenson; Bruce E Bray; Barry M Moore; Karen Eilbeck; Mark Yandell; Hongyu Zhao; Lin Hou; Xiaowei Chen; Xiting Yan; Mengjie Chen; Cong Li; Can Yang; Murat Gunel; Peining Li; Yong Kong; Austin C Alexander; Zayed I Albertyn; Kym M Boycott; Dennis E Bulman; Paul M K Gordon; A Micheil Innes; Bartha M Knoppers; Jacek Majewski; Christian R Marshall; Jillian S Parboosingh; Sarah L Sawyer; Mark E Samuels; Jeremy Schwartzentruber; Isaac S Kohane; David M Margulies Journal: Genome Biol Date: 2014-03-25 Impact factor: 13.583