| Literature DB >> 22619708 |
Joan Earle Hahn1, Leah Fitzgerald, Young Kee Markham, Paul Glassman, Nancy Guenther.
Abstract
Access to oral health care is essential for promoting and maintaining overall health and well-being, yet oral health disparities exist among vulnerable and underserved populations. While nurses make up the largest portion of the health care work force, educational preparation to address oral health needs of elders and persons with disabilities is limited across nursing curricula. This descriptive study reports on the interdisciplinary development, implementation, and testing of an oral health module that was included and infused into a graduate nursing curriculum in a three-phase plan. Phase 1 includes evaluation of a lecture presented to eight gerontological nurse practitioner (GNP) students. Phase 2 includes evaluation of GNP students' perceptions of learning, skills, and confidence following a one-time 8-hour practicum infused into 80 required practicum hours. The evaluation data show promise in preparing nurse practitioner students to assess and address preventive oral health needs of persons aging with disabilities such that further infusion and inclusion in a course for nurse practitioners across five specialties will implemented and tested in Phase 3.Entities:
Year: 2012 PMID: 22619708 PMCID: PMC3350980 DOI: 10.1155/2012/157874
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nurs Res Pract ISSN: 2090-1429
Components of oral health module.
| (i) Classroom lecture |
| (a) Taught with collaboration of nursing and dental faculty |
| (b) Didactic lecture with photos |
| (c) Demonstration of oral screening by dental faculty member |
| (d) Return demonstration by students |
| (e) Packet of resource materials on oral health for elders and PWDs |
|
|
| (ii) Practicum with persons aging with disabilities |
| (a) Packet of resource and teaching materials shared with students |
| (b) Forms for use in practicum |
| (1) Dental assessment for the nondentist |
| (1a) Assessment instruction sheet and protocols to guide recommendations |
| (2) Oral health-screening exam results |
| (2a) An oral health assessment form to record findings, treatment needs, and recommendations for oral health |
| (3) Oral health prevention plan |
| (3a) Identifies plan for overcoming obstacles to dental health |
|
|
| (iii) Module evaluation |
| (a) Lecture evaluation |
| (1) Likert-type scale survey with open-ended questions |
| (2) Rating of learning and improved confidence and skills |
| (b) Practicum evaluation |
| (1) For nursing students |
| (2) For persons with disabilities |
Gerontological nurse practitioner evaluation of oral health module lecture (n = 5).
| Category item |
|
|---|---|
|
| |
| Preventive oral health care | 5 |
| Role of APN in preventive oral health care for elders | 5 |
| Role of preventive oral health care for PWDs | 5 |
|
| |
| Materials on preventive oral health care | 5 |
| Overall rating of didactic | 5 |
| Overall rating of demonstration | 5 |
| Overall rating of return demonstration portion | 5 |
aBased on Likert scale (1: none to 5: learned an abundance of information). bBased on Likert scale (1: not satisfied at all to 5: highly satisfied).
APN: Advanced Practice Nurse; PWDs: persons with disabilities.
Gerontological nurse practitioner evaluation of practicum using evaluation tool.
| Category item |
|
|---|---|
|
| |
| Conducting a geriatric health screening with PWDs | 3.65 (0.94) |
| Identifying need for preventive education or support | 3.48 (0.90) |
| Identifying need for routine or emergent/urgent follow-up | 2.91 (1.16) |
|
| |
| Rating of improved confidence | 3.18 (0.85) |
| Rating of improved skills | 3.23 (0.81) |
|
| |
| Overall rating of oral health components | 3.27 (1.08) |
| Rating of Dental Assessment for the Nondentist form | 3.32 (1.09) |
| Overall rating of practicum | 3.86 (0.77) |
aBased on Likert scale (1: not much to 5: an abundance of information).bBased on Likert scale (1: poor to 5: excellent);
PWDs: persons with disabilities.
Gerontological nurse practitioner anecdotal comments about practicum.
| Theme/category |
|---|
| Comments |
| Oral health |
| Oral health component was great! |
| (liked) guided assessment |
| Materials and Setting |
| (liked) the screening tools, availability of space and instruments |
| Need for Training |
| Is often overlooked area in this patient population |
| I enjoyed learning how we can be an advocate for clients, families, and caregivers |
| This was an enlightening experience. |
| Great experience! Wish we had more time here. |
| Attitude |
| Excellent clinical rotation and experience. I feel more at ease/comfortable with assessing this population. |
Figure 1Rating of satisfaction by persons with I/DD with geriatric and oral health screening.
Types of referrals made by gerontological nurse practitioner students following a geriatric and oral health screening in 2008 (N = 16).
| Referral type |
| % |
|---|---|---|
| Primary care provider | 6 | 37.5 |
| Dentist | 3 | 18.8 |
| Physical therapist | 3 | 18.8 |
| Nursea | 2 | 12.5 |
| Ophthalmologist | 1 | 6.3 |
| Psychiatrist | 1 | 6.3 |
| Service coordinatora | 1 | 6.3 |
aThese personnel were from the service coordination agency.
(a) Phase 1: curriculum development and testing
| Project phase | Activities | Methods | Participants | Data and response rate | Outcomes of activities |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Development of oral health forms and evaluation methods Identification of resources (for elders and PWDs) | Curriculum development with collaboration of dental and nursing faculty/staff and project director | Dental faculty/staff (2) | Resource list | ||
| Module development and testing | 2-hour didactic lecture with oral health screening demonstration and GNP student return demonstration and post intervention evaluation | Educational intervention with postlecture evaluation | Nurse faculty member (1) | Lecture Evaluation Tool | High level of reported student satisfaction with module and learning of content |
| Practicum site coordination | Nursing faculty member (1) | Agency established as clinical practicum site |
PWDs: persons with disabilities; GNP: gerontological nurse practitioner.
(b) Phase 2: module integration (clinical section)
| Project phase | Activities | Methods | Participants | Data and response rate | Outcomes of activities |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Infusion and inclusion into one clinical section | Integration of oral health content and resources in GNP clinical practicum section | Practicum educational intervention with postlecture evaluation for GNP students and for elders with I/DD who attended the health fair | Clinical nursing faculty (1) | Practicum evaluation by | Favorable ratings by GNP students on learning, improvement in confidence and skills and satisfaction with materials, tools, and practicum |
GNP: gerontological nurse practitioner; I/DD: intellectual and/or developmental disabilities.
(c) Phase 3: module integration (nursing program)
| Project phase | Activities | Methods | Participants | Data and response rate | Outcomes of activities |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Integration into one NP course in graduate nursing programa | Integration of oral health module (lecture, practicum, and evaluation tools) into one course for all NP students in graduate nursing program activities | Educational intervention: 2-hour lecture by dental faculty, 12 required oral health screenings and preventive oral health plans per each NP student in practicum, and pre/postevaluation | Dental faculty member (1) | Forthcoming in next academic quarter | Learner gain based on pre/posttest |
NP: nurse practitioner.
aCourse is inclusive of NP students in acute care, adult/gerontology, family, adult/occupational health, and oncology graduate master's NP program. bAll NP students in program except for pediatric NP students. cOne clinical faculty member per section of twelve students.
(a)
|
|
|---|
| Oral health screening |
| Oral health screening procedures |
| Age-associated changes |
| Non-age related conditions |
| Oral cancer |
| Xerostomia |
| Tooth decay/loss |
| Periodontal disease |
| Immune-related disease |
| Recognizing common oral health conditions for elders |
| (with photos and descriptions) |
| (e.g., candida, keratosis, “hairy leukoplasia” squamous cell carcinoma, ulcers, nicotine stomatitis) |
| Oral health prevention |
| Need for immediate dental treatment |
| Oral hygiene |
| Denture fit and denture care |
aThe lecture content outline on elders is from the lecture presented by S. Spackman to gerontological nurse practitioner students. The lecture has elements from curricular content developed by J. Bauer and S. Spackman for the program in Geriatric Dentistry at UCLA School of Dentistry, Los Angeles, USA.
(b)
|
|
|---|
| Definitions of disability |
| Demographics and oral health disparities among persons with I/DD |
| Conditions associated with developmental disabilities |
| (e.g., intellectual disability, Down syndrome, cerebral palsy, Fragile X syndrome) |
| Common oral health conditions |
| (e.g., cheilitis, xerostomia, malocclusion) |
| Other oral health concerns |
| (e.g., bruxism, pica, GERD, pocketing food) |
| Review of oral health assessment and preventive oral health education and practice |
| Urgent, emergent, routine follow-up |
| Positioning, accommodations, and adaptive equipment |
| Consideration of fears or anxiety related to oral care |
| Roles and teaching of caregivers |
bThe lecture content outline about oral health and persons with intellectual and developmental disabilities was developed from a number of resources including Developmental Disabilities and Oral Health: Strategies for Providing Oral Care to People With Developmental Disabilities—Practical Oral Care for People with Developmental Disabilities Series For Health Professionals—available at http://www.nidcr.nih.gov/OralHealth/Topics/DevelopmentalDisabilities/.