Luc Tappy1, Bettina Mittendorfer. 1. Department of Physiology, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland. luc.tappy@unil.ch
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The assumption that fructose may be toxic and involved in the pathogenesis of noncommunicable diseases such as obesity, diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia, and even cancer has resulted in the call for public health action, such as introducing taxes on sweetened beverages. This review evaluates the scientific basis for such action. RECENT FINDINGS: Although some studies hint towards some potential adverse effects of excessive fructose consumption especially when combined with excess energy intake, the results from clinical trials do not support a significant detrimental effect of fructose on metabolic health when consumed as part of a weight-maintaining diet in amounts consistent with the average-estimated fructose consumption in Western countries. However, definitive studies are missing. SUMMARY: Public health policies to eliminate or limit fructose in the diet should be considered premature. Instead, efforts should be made to promote a healthy lifestyle that includes physical activity and nutritious foods while avoiding intake of excess calories until solid evidence to support action against fructose is available. Public health is almost certainly to benefit more from policies that are aimed at promoting what is known to be good than from policies that are prohibiting what is not (yet) known to be bad.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The assumption that fructose may be toxic and involved in the pathogenesis of noncommunicable diseases such as obesity, diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia, and even cancer has resulted in the call for public health action, such as introducing taxes on sweetened beverages. This review evaluates the scientific basis for such action. RECENT FINDINGS: Although some studies hint towards some potential adverse effects of excessive fructose consumption especially when combined with excess energy intake, the results from clinical trials do not support a significant detrimental effect of fructose on metabolic health when consumed as part of a weight-maintaining diet in amounts consistent with the average-estimated fructose consumption in Western countries. However, definitive studies are missing. SUMMARY: Public health policies to eliminate or limit fructose in the diet should be considered premature. Instead, efforts should be made to promote a healthy lifestyle that includes physical activity and nutritious foods while avoiding intake of excess calories until solid evidence to support action against fructose is available. Public health is almost certainly to benefit more from policies that are aimed at promoting what is known to be good than from policies that are prohibiting what is not (yet) known to be bad.
Authors: Kimber L Stanhope; Steven C Griffen; Andrew A Bremer; Roel G Vink; Ernst J Schaefer; Katsuyuki Nakajima; Jean-Marc Schwarz; Carine Beysen; Lars Berglund; Nancy L Keim; Peter J Havel Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2011-05-25 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Isabelle Aeberli; Philipp A Gerber; Michel Hochuli; Sibylle Kohler; Sarah R Haile; Ioanna Gouni-Berthold; Heiner K Berthold; Giatgen A Spinas; Kaspar Berneis Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2011-06-15 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Maria Maersk; Anita Belza; Hans Stødkilde-Jørgensen; Steffen Ringgaard; Elizaveta Chabanova; Henrik Thomsen; Steen B Pedersen; Arne Astrup; Bjørn Richelsen Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2011-12-28 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Vanessa Ha; John L Sievenpiper; Russell J de Souza; Laura Chiavaroli; D David Wang; Adrian I Cozma; Arash Mirrahimi; Matthew E Yu; Amanda J Carleton; Marco Dibuono; Alexandra L Jenkins; Lawrence A Leiter; Thomas M S Wolever; Joseph Beyene; Cyril W C Kendall; David J A Jenkins Journal: Hypertension Date: 2012-02-13 Impact factor: 10.190
Authors: G Maillard; M A Charles; L Lafay; N Thibult; M Vray; J M Borys; A Basdevant; E Eschwège; M Romon Journal: Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord Date: 2000-12
Authors: John L Sievenpiper; Russell J de Souza; Arash Mirrahimi; Matthew E Yu; Amanda J Carleton; Joseph Beyene; Laura Chiavaroli; Marco Di Buono; Alexandra L Jenkins; Lawrence A Leiter; Thomas M S Wolever; Cyril W C Kendall; David J A Jenkins Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2012-02-21 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Deborah F Tate; Gabrielle Turner-McGrievy; Elizabeth Lyons; June Stevens; Karen Erickson; Kristen Polzien; Molly Diamond; Xiaoshan Wang; Barry Popkin Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2012-02-01 Impact factor: 7.045