Ruopeng An1, Roland Sturm. 1. RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California, USA. ran@rand.org
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Various hypotheses link neighborhood food environments and diet. Greater exposure to fast-food restaurants and convenience stores is thought to encourage overconsumption; supermarkets and large grocery stores are claimed to encourage healthier diets. For youth, empirical evidence for any particular hypothesis remains limited. PURPOSE: This study examines the relationship between school and residential neighborhood food environment and diet among youth in California. METHODS: Data from 8226 children (aged 5-11 years) and 5236 adolescents (aged 12-17 years) from the 2005 and 2007 California Health Interview Survey were analyzed in 2011. The dependent variables are daily servings of fruits, vegetables, juice, milk, soda, high-sugar foods, and fast food, which were regressed on measures of food environments. Food environments were measured by counts and density of businesses, distinguishing fast-food restaurants, convenience stores, small food stores, grocery stores, and large supermarkets within a specific distance (varying from 0.1 to 1.5 miles) from a respondent's home or school. RESULTS: No robust relationship between food environment and consumption is found. A few significant results are sensitive to small modeling changes and more likely to reflect chance than true relationships. CONCLUSIONS: This correlational study has measurement and design limitations. Longitudinal studies that can assess links between environmental, dependent, and intervening food purchase and consumption variables are needed. Reporting a full range of studies, methods, and results is important as a premature focus on correlations may lead policy astray.
BACKGROUND: Various hypotheses link neighborhood food environments and diet. Greater exposure to fast-food restaurants and convenience stores is thought to encourage overconsumption; supermarkets and large grocery stores are claimed to encourage healthier diets. For youth, empirical evidence for any particular hypothesis remains limited. PURPOSE: This study examines the relationship between school and residential neighborhood food environment and diet among youth in California. METHODS: Data from 8226 children (aged 5-11 years) and 5236 adolescents (aged 12-17 years) from the 2005 and 2007 California Health Interview Survey were analyzed in 2011. The dependent variables are daily servings of fruits, vegetables, juice, milk, soda, high-sugar foods, and fast food, which were regressed on measures of food environments. Food environments were measured by counts and density of businesses, distinguishing fast-food restaurants, convenience stores, small food stores, grocery stores, and large supermarkets within a specific distance (varying from 0.1 to 1.5 miles) from a respondent's home or school. RESULTS: No robust relationship between food environment and consumption is found. A few significant results are sensitive to small modeling changes and more likely to reflect chance than true relationships. CONCLUSIONS: This correlational study has measurement and design limitations. Longitudinal studies that can assess links between environmental, dependent, and intervening food purchase and consumption variables are needed. Reporting a full range of studies, methods, and results is important as a premature focus on correlations may lead policy astray.
Authors: Mia A Papas; Anthony J Alberg; Reid Ewing; Kathy J Helzlsouer; Tiffany L Gary; Ann C Klassen Journal: Epidemiol Rev Date: 2007-05-28 Impact factor: 6.222
Authors: Lisa M Powell; Euna Han; Shannon N Zenk; Tamkeen Khan; Christopher M Quinn; Kevin P Gibbs; Oksana Pugach; Dianne C Barker; Elissa A Resnick; Jaana Myllyluoma; Frank J Chaloupka Journal: Health Place Date: 2011-06-02 Impact factor: 4.078
Authors: Lauren Fiechtner; Mona Sharifi; Thomas Sequist; Jason Block; Dustin T Duncan; Steven J Melly; Sheryl L Rifas-Shiman; Elsie M Taveras Journal: Child Obes Date: 2015-04-29 Impact factor: 2.992
Authors: Sara N Bleich; Jesse C Jones-Smith; Marian P Jarlenski; Julia A Wolfson; Johannah M Frelier; Huiru Tao; Yuchen Hu; Anna Zink; Caroline G Dunn; Mark J Soto; Bradley J Herring Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2020-02-14 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Cheng K Fred Wen; Stephanie Hsieh; Jimi Huh; Lauren Cook Martinez; Jamie N Davis; Marc Weigensberg; Donna Spruijt-Metz Journal: J Racial Ethn Health Disparities Date: 2016-10-17