| Literature DB >> 22026518 |
Kari R Hexem1, Abigail M Bosk, Chris Feudtner.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The work of care for parents of children with complex special health care needs may be increasing, while excessive work demands may erode the quality of care. We sought to summarize knowledge and develop a general conceptual model of the work of care.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2011 PMID: 22026518 PMCID: PMC3234186 DOI: 10.1186/1471-2431-11-95
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Pediatr ISSN: 1471-2431 Impact factor: 2.125
Systematic review methodology
| Methods topics | Description | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility Criteria | ||
| Years | All | To assess change in patterns of reporting over time. |
| Language | English only | Study authors were only fluent in English. |
| Publication status | Peer reviewed journals | Peer review set minimum criteria for quality, journals used as primary medium for communication of information. |
| Information sources | ||
| Databases | PUBMED, PSYCINFO, CINAHL, and SOCIOLOGICAL ABSRACTS | Multiple databases were selected to provide access to a breadth of journals. |
| References | Review of reference sections | Provided additional articles not found in database searches. |
| Search | PUBMED example | Multiple searches using different terms revealed different journal articles to review. |
| Study selection | See figure 1 | |
| Data collection process | Data extracted from 30 journal articles chosen in random order, and 15 additional articles purposefully selected to increase diversity of sample | Used to prevent bias while at the same time sampling from entire population of articles. |
| Data items | See Tables 3 and 4 | Code list generated from qualitative methods based on Grounded Theory (Strauss & Corbin 1987). |
| Summary measures | See Tables 3 and 4 | Categories based on code list. |
| Synthesis of results | Theoretical model used to organize codes/categories | Theoretical model based on data as well as theories of work, coping, and complex systems. |
| Risk of bias across studies | "Medicalization" of work of care in peer review journals, exclusion of lay literature | Journal audience is comprised of medical and research personnel. |
Figure 1Procedure for systematic identification and selection of included articles.
Study information for articles retrieved using databases, iterative review of each paper's references, and purposefully
| N | |
|---|---|
| Mean articles per journal | 2.6 |
| Number of journals with one article only | 123 |
| Number of journals with 10 or more articles | 9 |
| Retrieved from | |
| PUBMED | 14 (47%) |
| Reference sections of articles | 9 (30%) |
| Other databases | 7 (23%) |
| Study type | |
| Qualitative (Interviews, Focus Groups, Ethnography) | 13 (43%) |
| Literature reviews+ | 8 (26%) |
| Quantitative (Survey, Time diaries) | 7 (20%) |
| Mixed methods | 2 (7%) |
| Randomized Intervention Studies | 0 |
| Study period | |
| Cross-sectional or one visit | 21 (70%) |
| Longitudinal or multiple visits | 1 (3%) |
| N/a (literature review) | 8 (27) |
| Contained visual model | |
| Yes | 5 (17%) |
| No | 25 (83%) |
| Disease type | |
| Unspecified (CSCHN, Chronic Illness, Disability) | 16 (53%) |
| Asthma | 3 (10%) |
| Epilepsy | 2 (7%) |
| Assisted by medical technology | 2 (7%) |
| Type 1 Diabetes | 2 (7%) |
| Other* | 5 (17%) |
| Country of study site | |
| United States | 14 (47%) |
| Australia, Canada, U.K. | 11 (37%) |
| Other** | 5 (17%) |
| Gender of parent-participants | |
| Mothers only | 5 (17%) |
| Mothers and fathers eligible, greater than 55% mothers | 7 (23%) |
| Mothers and fathers eligible, less than or equal to 55% mothers | 3 (10%) |
| Fathers only | 2 (7%) |
| Unspecified | 5 (17%) |
| N/a (literature review) | 8 (27%) |
| Addressed racial or ethnic minorities | |
| Yes | 1 (3%) |
| No | 29 (97%) |
| Longitudinal observational studies | 5 (33%) |
| Intervention studies | 5 (33%) |
| Addressed racial, ethnic, or very poor minorities | 5 (33%) |
+Included only 1 Literature Review with explicit search criteria. * Other disease includes 1 of each of the following: Anorexia, Cancer, Juvenile Rheumatoid Arthritis, Schizophrenia, and Infants At-Risk of SIDS.
** Other country includes 1 of each of the following: Germany, New Zealand, Sweden, Switzerland, and 1 study comparing U.S. and Icelandic populations
Figure 2Core components of the dynamic system of parental work of care.
Work of Care Tasks
| Category | Codes | Papers |
|---|---|---|
| Medical tasks | Medications and care of technical devices | [ |
| Management | Overall management | [ |
| Collaboration with medical professionals | [ | |
| Bureaucracy/paperwork | [ | |
| Crisis care and emergency room visits | [ | |
| Monitoring | Constant awareness of child's health status | [ |
| Decision Making | Deciding which tasks to take on, and which roles. | [ |
| Education | Seeking medical information/skills training | [ |
| Parenting tasks | Emotional support and developmental needs | [ |
| Day-to-day | Daily routines and "normal" life, time management | [ |
| Division of labor | Care of siblings | [ |
| Employment | [ | |
| Household chores | [ | |
| Helping and supporting each other | [ | |
| Communication | Talking with other family members about situation | [ |
| Self-care | Emotional management | [ |
| Diet, exercise, and relaxation | [ | |
| Personal religious practice (i.e. prayer) | [ | |
| Finding support | Maintaining communication with friends | [ |
| Support of other families in similar situations | [ | |
| Advocacy | Educating others | [ |
Work of Care Resources/Constraints
| Category | Codes | Papers |
|---|---|---|
| Gender | How child's gender affects the situation | [ |
| Disease | Diagnosis and prognosis | [ |
| Severity, symptoms, and child's quality of life | [ | |
| Episodic quality of illness and uncertainty | [ | |
| Medical care | Type of technology or equipment | [ |
| Frequency of treatments | [ | |
| Age | Newborns, children, and adolescents | [ |
| Transitioning to Adult Care | [ | |
| Behavior | Cognitive and emotional function/expression | [ |
| Functional ability/activity limitations | [ | |
| Location | Home, hospital, or elsewhere | [ |
| Gender roles | How the roles of mothers and fathers differ | [ |
| Mental health | Emotions, quality of life, and stress | [ |
| Personality | Hardiness, self-esteem, and coping style | [ |
| Physical health | Sleep, immune function | [ |
| Knowledge | Medical and parenting skills and experience | [ |
| Education level | [ | |
| Social support | Availability of friends and family | [ |
| Family structure | Family cohesion, including marital dynamics | [ |
| Single parents | [ | |
| Step parents and foster parents | [ | |
| Siblings | [ | |
| Finances | Employment, income, and expenses | [ |
| Insurance and eligibility for services | [ | |
| Minority status | Race, ethnicity, language, culture, and SES | [ |
| Geographic locale | Different regions, countries. Immobility. | [ |
| Attitudes and norms | Disability and disease in childhood | [ |
| Parental responsibility and gender norms | [ | |
| Health services | Availability of care facilities and providers | [ |
| Awareness of available services | [ | |
| Political system | Government policies and funding | [ |