BACKGROUND: It was recently hypothesized by Lake (Schizophrenia Bulletin 2008; 34: 109-117) that Formal Thought Disorder (FTD) can be accounted for by a single disorder that is currently diagnosed as bipolar disorder. OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to analyze the underlying dimensions of FTD and to examine to what extent FTD factors can be accounted for by clinical distractibility, attentional impairment, severity of mania, and familial liability of bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. METHODS: Six hundred and sixty inpatients were assessed using a semistructured interview, and FTDs were assessed with the Thought, Language, and Communication scale. "Inattentiveness during Mental Status Testing" item of the Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms scale and a composite mania score were used. The Family History-Research Diagnostic Criteria was used. RESULTS: FTD is a multidimensional construct comprised at least 5 dimensions: disorganization, verbosity, poverty of speech, idiosyncratic thinking, and blocking. Clinical distractibility loadings split in 2 factors, disorganization and blocking, but it did not load on the mania-related (verbosity) factor. Attentional disturbance was significantly associated with each FTD factor except for idiosyncratic thinking, and these associations were largely independent from the severity of mania. The associations of FTDs with mania and attentional disturbances were independent from each other. FTD factors were not significantly associated with familial liability to bipolar or to schizophrenia. CONCLUSIONS: Disorganization was the main FTD component. Distractibility was a core feature of FTD factors but it was not specifically accounted for by mania-related attentional impairment. The hypothesis of mutual interdependence between mania and attentional disturbance leading to FTDs could not be confirmed.
BACKGROUND: It was recently hypothesized by Lake (Schizophrenia Bulletin 2008; 34: 109-117) that Formal Thought Disorder (FTD) can be accounted for by a single disorder that is currently diagnosed as bipolar disorder. OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to analyze the underlying dimensions of FTD and to examine to what extent FTD factors can be accounted for by clinical distractibility, attentional impairment, severity of mania, and familial liability of bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. METHODS: Six hundred and sixty inpatients were assessed using a semistructured interview, and FTDs were assessed with the Thought, Language, and Communication scale. "Inattentiveness during Mental Status Testing" item of the Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms scale and a composite mania score were used. The Family History-Research Diagnostic Criteria was used. RESULTS:FTD is a multidimensional construct comprised at least 5 dimensions: disorganization, verbosity, poverty of speech, idiosyncratic thinking, and blocking. Clinical distractibility loadings split in 2 factors, disorganization and blocking, but it did not load on the mania-related (verbosity) factor. Attentional disturbance was significantly associated with each FTD factor except for idiosyncratic thinking, and these associations were largely independent from the severity of mania. The associations of FTDs with mania and attentional disturbances were independent from each other. FTD factors were not significantly associated with familial liability to bipolar or to schizophrenia. CONCLUSIONS: Disorganization was the main FTD component. Distractibility was a core feature of FTD factors but it was not specifically accounted for by mania-related attentional impairment. The hypothesis of mutual interdependence between mania and attentional disturbance leading to FTDs could not be confirmed.
Authors: Kenneth L Subotnik; Keith H Nuechterlein; Michael F Green; William P Horan; Tasha M Nienow; Joseph Ventura; Annie T Nguyen Journal: Schizophr Res Date: 2006-04-19 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Maria de Gracia Dominguez; Wolfgang Viechtbauer; Claudia J P Simons; Jim van Os; Lydia Krabbendam Journal: Psychol Bull Date: 2009-01 Impact factor: 17.737
Authors: Abraham Reichenberg; Philip D Harvey; Christopher R Bowie; Ramin Mojtabai; Jonathan Rabinowitz; Robert K Heaton; Evelyn Bromet Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2008-05-20 Impact factor: 9.306
Authors: Petra V Viher; Katharina Stegmayer; Stéphanie Giezendanner; Andrea Federspiel; Stephan Bohlhalter; Roland Wiest; Werner Strik; Sebastian Walther Journal: Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci Date: 2016-12-28 Impact factor: 5.270
Authors: Frederike Stein; Elena Buckenmayer; Katharina Brosch; Tina Meller; Simon Schmitt; Kai Gustav Ringwald; Julia Katharina Pfarr; Olaf Steinsträter; Verena Enneking; Dominik Grotegerd; Walter Heindel; Susanne Meinert; Elisabeth J Leehr; Hannah Lemke; Katharina Thiel; Lena Waltemate; Alexandra Winter; Tim Hahn; Udo Dannlowski; Andreas Jansen; Igor Nenadić; Axel Krug; Tilo Kircher Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2022-06-21 Impact factor: 7.348
Authors: Konstantinos N Fountoulakis; Elena Dragioti; Antonis T Theofilidis; Tobias Wikilund; Xenofon Atmatzidis; Ioannis Nimatoudis; Erik Thys; Martien Wampers; Luchezar Hranov; Trayana Hristova; Daniil Aptalidis; Roumen Milev; Felicia Iftene; Filip Spaniel; Pavel Knytl; Petra Furstova; Tiina From; Henry Karlsson; Maija Walta; Raimo K R Salokangas; Jean-Michel Azorin; Justine Bouniard; Julie Montant; Georg Juckel; Ida S Haussleiter; Athanasios Douzenis; Ioannis Michopoulos; Panagiotis Ferentinos; Nikolaos Smyrnis; Leonidas Mantonakis; Zsófia Nemes; Xenia Gonda; Dora Vajda; Anita Juhasz; Amresh Shrivastava; John Waddington; Maurizio Pompili; Anna Comparelli; Valentina Corigliano; Elmars Rancans; Alvydas Navickas; Jan Hilbig; Laurynas Bukelskis; Lidija Injac Stevovic; Sanja Vodopic; Oluyomi Esan; Oluremi Oladele; Christopher Osunbote; Janusz Κ Rybakowski; Pawel Wojciak; Klaudia Domowicz; Maria Luisa Figueira; Ludgero Linhares; Joana Crawford; Anca-Livia Panfil; Daria Smirnova; Olga Izmailova; Dusica Lecic-Tosevski; Henk Temmingh; Fleur Howells; Julio Bobes; Maria Paz Garcia-Portilla; Leticia García-Alvarez; Gamze Erzin; Hasan Karadağ; Avinash De Sousa; Anuja Bendre; Cyril Hoschl; Cristina Bredicean; Ion Papava; Olivera Vukovic; Bojana Pejuskovic; Vincent Russell; Loukas Athanasiadis; Anastasia Konsta; Dan Stein; Michael Berk; Olivia Dean; Rajiv Tandon; Siegfried Kasper; Marc De Hert Journal: Int J Neuropsychopharmacol Date: 2019-11-01 Impact factor: 5.176
Authors: Manuela Russo; Stephen Z Levine; Arsime Demjaha; Marta Di Forti; Stefania Bonaccorso; Paul Fearon; Paola Dazzan; Carmine M Pariante; Anthony S David; Craig Morgan; Robin M Murray; Abraham Reichenberg Journal: Schizophr Bull Date: 2013-05-09 Impact factor: 7.348