Jennifer A Emond1, Hala N Madanat, Guadalupe X Ayala. 1. Cancer Prevention and Control Program, UCSD Moores Cancer Center, University of California, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, San Diego, CA 92093-0901, USA. jemond@ucsd.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To compare non-ethnically based supermarkets and Latino grocery stores (tiendas) in a lower-income region with regard to the availability, quality and cost of several healthy v. unhealthy food items. DESIGN: A cross-sectional study conducted by three independent observers to audit twenty-five grocery stores identified as the main source of groceries for 80 % of Latino families enrolled in a childhood obesity study. Stores were classified as supermarkets and tiendas on the basis of key characteristics. SETTING: South San Diego County. SUBJECTS: Ten tiendas and fifteen supermarkets. RESULTS: Tiendas were smaller than supermarkets (five v. twelve aisles, P = 0·003). Availability of fresh produce did not differ by store type; quality differed for one fruit item. Price per unit (pound or piece) was lower in tiendas for most fresh produce. The cost of meeting the US Department of Agriculture's recommended weekly servings of produce based on an 8368 kJ (2000 kcal)/d diet was $US 3·00 lower in tiendas compared with supermarkets (P < 0·001). The cost of 1 gallon of skimmed milk was significantly higher in tiendas ($US 3·29 v. $US 2·69; P = 0·005) and lean (7 % fat) ground beef was available in only one tienda (10 %) compared with ten (67 %) supermarkets (P = 0·01). CONCLUSIONS: Barriers remain in the ability to purchase healthier dairy and meat options in tiendas; the same is not true for produce. These results highlight the potential that tiendas have in improving access to quality, fresh produce within lower-income communities. However, efforts are needed to increase the access and affordability of healthy dairy and meat products.
OBJECTIVE: To compare non-ethnically based supermarkets and Latino grocery stores (tiendas) in a lower-income region with regard to the availability, quality and cost of several healthy v. unhealthy food items. DESIGN: A cross-sectional study conducted by three independent observers to audit twenty-five grocery stores identified as the main source of groceries for 80 % of Latino families enrolled in a childhood obesity study. Stores were classified as supermarkets and tiendas on the basis of key characteristics. SETTING: South San Diego County. SUBJECTS: Ten tiendas and fifteen supermarkets. RESULTS: Tiendas were smaller than supermarkets (five v. twelve aisles, P = 0·003). Availability of fresh produce did not differ by store type; quality differed for one fruit item. Price per unit (pound or piece) was lower in tiendas for most fresh produce. The cost of meeting the US Department of Agriculture's recommended weekly servings of produce based on an 8368 kJ (2000 kcal)/d diet was $US 3·00 lower in tiendas compared with supermarkets (P < 0·001). The cost of 1 gallon of skimmed milk was significantly higher in tiendas ($US 3·29 v. $US 2·69; P = 0·005) and lean (7 % fat) ground beef was available in only one tienda (10 %) compared with ten (67 %) supermarkets (P = 0·01). CONCLUSIONS: Barriers remain in the ability to purchase healthier dairy and meat options in tiendas; the same is not true for produce. These results highlight the potential that tiendas have in improving access to quality, fresh produce within lower-income communities. However, efforts are needed to increase the access and affordability of healthy dairy and meat products.
Authors: M I Harris; K M Flegal; C C Cowie; M S Eberhardt; D E Goldstein; R R Little; H M Wiedmeyer; D D Byrd-Holt Journal: Diabetes Care Date: 1998-04 Impact factor: 19.112
Authors: John P Elder; Guadalupe X Ayala; Nadia R Campbell; Elva M Arredondo; Donald J Slymen; Barbara Baquero; Michelle Zive; Theodore G Ganiats; Moshe Engelberg Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2006-06-15 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: Cynthia L Ogden; Margaret D Carroll; Lester R Curtin; Margaret A McDowell; Carolyn J Tabak; Katherine M Flegal Journal: JAMA Date: 2006-04-05 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Guadalupe X Ayala; John P Elder; Nadia R Campbell; Donald J Slymen; Nupur Roy; Moshe Engelberg; Theodore Ganiats Journal: Womens Health Issues Date: 2004 Sep-Oct
Authors: Rebecca E Lee; Katie M Heinrich; Ashley V Medina; Gail R Regan; Jacqueline Y Reese-Smith; Yuka Jokura; Jay E Maddock Journal: Environ Health Insights Date: 2010-07-21
Authors: May C Wang; Soowon Kim; Alma A Gonzalez; Kara E MacLeod; Marilyn A Winkleby Journal: J Epidemiol Community Health Date: 2007-06 Impact factor: 3.710
Authors: Joanna Calderon; Guadalupe X Ayala; John P Elder; George E Belch; Iana A Castro; Nadir Weibel; Julie Pickrel Journal: Health Educ Behav Date: 2016-07-09
Authors: Carmen R Isasi; Mercedes R Carnethon; Guadalupe X Ayala; Elva Arredondo; Shrikant I Bangdiwala; Martha L Daviglus; Alan M Delamater; John H Eckfeldt; Krista Perreira; John H Himes; Robert C Kaplan; Linda Van Horn Journal: Ann Epidemiol Date: 2013-10-09 Impact factor: 3.797
Authors: Guadalupe X Ayala; Barbara Baquero; Julie L Pickrel; Joni Mayer; George Belch; Cheryl L Rock; Laura Linnan; Joel Gittelsohn; Jennifer Sanchez-Flack; John P Elder Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2015-04-27 Impact factor: 2.226
Authors: Jennifer C Sanchez-Flack; Barbara Baquero; Laura A Linnan; Joel Gittelsohn; Julie L Pickrel; Guadalupe X Ayala Journal: Ecol Food Nutr Date: 2016-01-22 Impact factor: 1.692
Authors: Guadalupe X Ayala; Mercedes Carnethon; Elva Arredondo; Alan M Delamater; Krista Perreira; Linda Van Horn; John H Himes; John H Eckfeldt; Shrikant I Bangdiwala; Daniel A Santisteban; Carmen R Isasi Journal: Ann Epidemiol Date: 2013-10-21 Impact factor: 3.797